Decent pizza. Was Luke warm to cold when delivered though.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
clare balus
2 pizzas for nearly $70. The pizzas were tasty, toppings minimal, limp crust. Overall, I'll never order here again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 3
Ramona PuchalskiPiretti
The location is impossible to find and there is no signage to assist. It is located inside Odin’s Lair but there is no indication of that online.When I went to pick up, there always no one at the counter and at least 4-5 people who clearly worked in the location in some capacity walked back and forth in front of me without ever saying a word. There was a bag and a pizza box on the counter, so I checked them and discovered they were mine and simply took them and left.The wings were drenched in rub with the entire bottom of the container filled as though they forgot to put it on and then just poured it over afterwards. The pizza was undercooked and the meatball grinder looked tossed together and squished.I can’t believe I had to pay what I did for this and if I could retract the tip, I most definitely would. It makes me reconsider even going back to the Vernon location we normally go to and I absolutely makes me not want to go do axe throwing again which we did a couple times in the past and found a fun and silly night out. There will be no return trip to either business.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Michael B.
One of the lowest quality pizzas we have ever ordered. The cheese was a microscopic film over the paper thin crust, the toppings were stingy (or in the case of bacon non-existent), and it was burnt beyond an acceptable level.
Jan Harris
We ordered 3 pizzas. My husband ordered a 1 truffle and 1 Margarita pizza. I wanted a vegetable pizza which didn’t seem difficult to me but they didn’t have just regular peppers so I ended up with hot peppers which I’m fine with and olives which is good. I wanted mushrooms and red onion, which did not ever appear on the pizza and my husband said that his pizzas were flavorless and the margarita didn’t have any fresh mozz. Terrible pizza!! Stay away!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 2
Crystal Agvent
Wow, little gem ? of Enfield!The Pizza was AWESOME!Thin crust, wood fired to perfection?. The options pre selected pizza are on the menu for good reason! ?The Bianco Pizza was SOoooo good!? Who knew alittle maple syrup on pizza was going to be so delicious! The ceaser salad was also great. Romaine was crispy and Dry as it should be and the ceaser dressing is House made!?DRINK Options are at another separate pay station (pirate ☠️ ship) which is a nice addition.Atmosphere was really fun,Axe throwing, corn hole, and pool all going on ODINS tab.Warm atmosphere, will definately be back ?My ONLY recommendation would be for sturdier forks and knives for my pizza cutting! ?Nothing like a pizza right OUT of the wood oven. DINE in! ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Craig Werder
I read all of the bad reviews, but decided to give it a shot in hopes I would have a different experience… unfortunately, I got cold, dry pizza (margherita and pepperoni). It seemed like they were made a day earlier and gently reheated prior to delivery. The 18” pizzas were 14”. Too bad, I wanted to like it - I will not be ordering from here again.Only positive I can say is that they delivered the pizzas ahead of schedule.
Food: 1
Service: 1
Abby D
I usually don’t leave reviews on places but I want to warn others: this place is not great. The toppings on our pizza were wrong and when we asked if they had forgotten it they lied and said they put it on… Also some kind of fuzz or cat hair was on the crust… Staff was short and ignored us when we had a question. Cookies weren’t warm either (and hard as a rock.) Overall wouldn’t recommend.
Food: 1
Service: 1
Bob B
Worst pizza in Enfield and that's saying alot
Alex Agro
Very disappointed! It was very burnt. I know it’s brick oven but it was burnt like black. No flavor at all and it was very cold. Was told to pick up at 6 cause their ovens were still heating up. It was definitely done way before that. The box wasn’t even hot. Never going back
Enfield is full of half way decent Greek style pizza so when square peg opened up and we had a Neapolitan style option it was great to hear. There is nothing like a Pepes or a Harry’s or a Naples anywhere near us. Quality since they first opened though has completely fallen apart. First couple times it was okay but last couple times it’s been a train wreck. Margarita they forgot the cheese a few weeks back. Tonight Caesar salad was half empty container with no croutons, cheese pizza was over cooked and pepperoni pizza was wildly under done and basically roni and no cheese. Square peg is noticeably more expensive than grabbing a pizza at any other local place so suffice to say we are finally checked out rolling the dice with this place. The kids throwing this together clearly don’t give a sheet
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
RaiRaiBrown
This place is located within the axe throwing activities and entertainment business. It's definitely a place to go for a good time, age 12 or over. It's confusing to find if you don't know the pizza business is within the other business. There's no signs or notes on Google or any other way of knowing that it's there unless they tell you over the phone. That definitely needs to be addressed. The service and pizza was pretty good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ryan
Decided to give this a try tonight. There's potential here. Mind you, for a town full of Italians Enfield sure does have some awful pizza. Is it wood fired? Sure is. Does it stack up with the famous wood fired pizzas from the shore? Depending on how you look at it: Flavors of both the Bianco and Pepperoni were phenomenal. My only complaint about the Bianco is it didn't have enough heat with the calabrian chili oil. The execution in the oven came up a little short. It could use another minute or two with a turn in the oven. Or more heat in the oven. The crust doesn't have enough crisp for a wood fired pie. I don't think there's anything wrong with the dough itself. It all tastes good, just a tad chewey with it being slightly underdone for a wood fired pie. Compared to the rest of the pizza joints in the area, this definitely tastes the best. Lastly, this type of pizza definitely dies a quick death being in a box, so it might be better to try this fresh out of the oven next time. I will try this place again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Wednesday Lemieux
I'm a regular at Odins keeps, because of this I have really grown to love square peg! The young blonde woman is always such a delight! She’s super positive and friendly, the food is always phenomenal! I have noticed that the girl is always alone with no other support, which is insane does she even get the opportunity to take a break? She's running around 24/7 making sure everyone is happy with their orders. I have been a general manger of a fast food chain for years now and it is very hard to find and keep hard dedicated workers like her. Hence why I have noticed her incredible work ethic! The few times she hasn’t been working the pizza did take a little longer than normal and I did notice there were two workers instead of the usually two. I want to write a review for this young lady, I feel bad she has to run the store solo but that doesn’t stop her from making great pizzas. Definitely will be ordering again! Hope you guys know which girl I'm talking about, I feel bad I can’t remember her name right now. She’s appears to be in her early 20s, kinda short and blonde! I hope you guys value such a fantastic employee, I know I would if she worked for me!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Small Buffalo Chicken
Katrina Sylvester
Really disappointed in this place. We were so excited to try this and ordered $85+ in food online plus delivery and their fees. Waited the 45 minutes only to get a text that our order was refunded because their website was “messed up for hours”.We expressed our displeasure on the phone the first time and they didn’t even try and fix the mistake (offer to rush an order through)…. We hung up but decided a few minutes later to just have them make the food and wait another 45 minutes… so we tried calling back only to be on hold for almost 10 minutes and never spoke to someone. It was 645pm they close at 8pm.Guess they are doing so well that they don’t need our business.
Decent pizza. Was Luke warm to cold when delivered though.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
2 pizzas for nearly $70. The pizzas were tasty, toppings minimal, limp crust. Overall, I'll never order here again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 3
The location is impossible to find and there is no signage to assist. It is located inside Odin’s Lair but there is no indication of that online.When I went to pick up, there always no one at the counter and at least 4-5 people who clearly worked in the location in some capacity walked back and forth in front of me without ever saying a word. There was a bag and a pizza box on the counter, so I checked them and discovered they were mine and simply took them and left.The wings were drenched in rub with the entire bottom of the container filled as though they forgot to put it on and then just poured it over afterwards. The pizza was undercooked and the meatball grinder looked tossed together and squished.I can’t believe I had to pay what I did for this and if I could retract the tip, I most definitely would. It makes me reconsider even going back to the Vernon location we normally go to and I absolutely makes me not want to go do axe throwing again which we did a couple times in the past and found a fun and silly night out. There will be no return trip to either business.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
One of the lowest quality pizzas we have ever ordered. The cheese was a microscopic film over the paper thin crust, the toppings were stingy (or in the case of bacon non-existent), and it was burnt beyond an acceptable level.
We ordered 3 pizzas. My husband ordered a 1 truffle and 1 Margarita pizza. I wanted a vegetable pizza which didn’t seem difficult to me but they didn’t have just regular peppers so I ended up with hot peppers which I’m fine with and olives which is good. I wanted mushrooms and red onion, which did not ever appear on the pizza and my husband said that his pizzas were flavorless and the margarita didn’t have any fresh mozz. Terrible pizza!! Stay away!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 2
Wow, little gem ? of Enfield!The Pizza was AWESOME!Thin crust, wood fired to perfection?. The options pre selected pizza are on the menu for good reason! ?The Bianco Pizza was SOoooo good!? Who knew alittle maple syrup on pizza was going to be so delicious! The ceaser salad was also great. Romaine was crispy and Dry as it should be and the ceaser dressing is House made!?DRINK Options are at another separate pay station (pirate ☠️ ship) which is a nice addition.Atmosphere was really fun,Axe throwing, corn hole, and pool all going on ODINS tab.Warm atmosphere, will definately be back ?My ONLY recommendation would be for sturdier forks and knives for my pizza cutting! ?Nothing like a pizza right OUT of the wood oven. DINE in! ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
I read all of the bad reviews, but decided to give it a shot in hopes I would have a different experience… unfortunately, I got cold, dry pizza (margherita and pepperoni). It seemed like they were made a day earlier and gently reheated prior to delivery. The 18” pizzas were 14”. Too bad, I wanted to like it - I will not be ordering from here again.Only positive I can say is that they delivered the pizzas ahead of schedule.
Food: 1
Service: 1
I usually don’t leave reviews on places but I want to warn others: this place is not great. The toppings on our pizza were wrong and when we asked if they had forgotten it they lied and said they put it on… Also some kind of fuzz or cat hair was on the crust… Staff was short and ignored us when we had a question. Cookies weren’t warm either (and hard as a rock.) Overall wouldn’t recommend.
Food: 1
Service: 1
Worst pizza in Enfield and that's saying alot
Very disappointed! It was very burnt. I know it’s brick oven but it was burnt like black. No flavor at all and it was very cold. Was told to pick up at 6 cause their ovens were still heating up. It was definitely done way before that. The box wasn’t even hot. Never going back
Restaurantji Recommends
Enfield is full of half way decent Greek style pizza so when square peg opened up and we had a Neapolitan style option it was great to hear. There is nothing like a Pepes or a Harry’s or a Naples anywhere near us. Quality since they first opened though has completely fallen apart. First couple times it was okay but last couple times it’s been a train wreck. Margarita they forgot the cheese a few weeks back. Tonight Caesar salad was half empty container with no croutons, cheese pizza was over cooked and pepperoni pizza was wildly under done and basically roni and no cheese. Square peg is noticeably more expensive than grabbing a pizza at any other local place so suffice to say we are finally checked out rolling the dice with this place. The kids throwing this together clearly don’t give a sheet
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
This place is located within the axe throwing activities and entertainment business. It's definitely a place to go for a good time, age 12 or over. It's confusing to find if you don't know the pizza business is within the other business. There's no signs or notes on Google or any other way of knowing that it's there unless they tell you over the phone. That definitely needs to be addressed. The service and pizza was pretty good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Decided to give this a try tonight. There's potential here. Mind you, for a town full of Italians Enfield sure does have some awful pizza. Is it wood fired? Sure is. Does it stack up with the famous wood fired pizzas from the shore? Depending on how you look at it: Flavors of both the Bianco and Pepperoni were phenomenal. My only complaint about the Bianco is it didn't have enough heat with the calabrian chili oil. The execution in the oven came up a little short. It could use another minute or two with a turn in the oven. Or more heat in the oven. The crust doesn't have enough crisp for a wood fired pie. I don't think there's anything wrong with the dough itself. It all tastes good, just a tad chewey with it being slightly underdone for a wood fired pie. Compared to the rest of the pizza joints in the area, this definitely tastes the best. Lastly, this type of pizza definitely dies a quick death being in a box, so it might be better to try this fresh out of the oven next time. I will try this place again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
I'm a regular at Odins keeps, because of this I have really grown to love square peg! The young blonde woman is always such a delight! She’s super positive and friendly, the food is always phenomenal! I have noticed that the girl is always alone with no other support, which is insane does she even get the opportunity to take a break? She's running around 24/7 making sure everyone is happy with their orders. I have been a general manger of a fast food chain for years now and it is very hard to find and keep hard dedicated workers like her. Hence why I have noticed her incredible work ethic! The few times she hasn’t been working the pizza did take a little longer than normal and I did notice there were two workers instead of the usually two. I want to write a review for this young lady, I feel bad she has to run the store solo but that doesn’t stop her from making great pizzas. Definitely will be ordering again! Hope you guys know which girl I'm talking about, I feel bad I can’t remember her name right now. She’s appears to be in her early 20s, kinda short and blonde! I hope you guys value such a fantastic employee, I know I would if she worked for me!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Small Buffalo Chicken
Really disappointed in this place. We were so excited to try this and ordered $85+ in food online plus delivery and their fees. Waited the 45 minutes only to get a text that our order was refunded because their website was “messed up for hours”.We expressed our displeasure on the phone the first time and they didn’t even try and fix the mistake (offer to rush an order through)…. We hung up but decided a few minutes later to just have them make the food and wait another 45 minutes… so we tried calling back only to be on hold for almost 10 minutes and never spoke to someone. It was 645pm they close at 8pm.Guess they are doing so well that they don’t need our business.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1