Paula from Creative Cakes by Donna was absolutely wonderful throughout the entire planning process. She was incredibly helpful when it came to choosing the perfect flavors, especially considering both my husband and I have gluten intolerance. Her knowledge and care made the process easy and stress-free.
The cake itself was delicious — moist with just the right balance of flavors. The combination of berries and chocolate was perfect and delighted all of our guests. We wanted a simple cake that matched our wedding theme and reflected our personalities, and Paula nailed it perfectly.
A special touch that made the cake even more meaningful was how it incorporated my husband’s woodworking hobby. The beautiful flowers on the cake were wood, and the wooden slab the cake rested on was hand-cut by him. It was such a unique and personal detail that really made the cake stand out.
Throughout the entire process, Paula was patient, kind, and attentive, always making sure we were happy and comfortable with every decision. I can’t recommend her enough to anyone looking for a delicious, beautiful, and thoughtfully made wedding cake!
Thank you! Mel & Scott
Emily
Cakes by Donna made our wedding cake and we were blown away by the final product. It tasted amazing and looked exactly like the vision we discussed. We were so pleased with the result and couldn’t recommend Cakes by Donna enough!
Joe Flat
Spectacular work! We wanted something a bit different, and they delivered. Paula was very helpful throught the process, and the cake was everything we wanted. Thank you so much for helping us have a perfect wedding day!
Sarah Foley
Donna was the vendor that did our cake through the Pond House Cafe! Not only was it absolutely beautiful, it was also delicious. We went with a vanilla cake with strawberry cream filling and buttercream frosting. It was fantastic. Absolutely love that she partners with local venues, makes everything so easy.
Nicole Dan
We had the best wedding cake! It was so beautiful and tasted so good!! Thanks Donna and her team!
Lindsey Horvath
My husband and I ordered our wedding cake through Cakes by Donna (Pond House Cafe venue) and would happily use them again for any cake needs in the future. Our cake was beautiful and delicious! Highly recommend!
Julia Koper
Tasted as amazing as it looked! Highly recommend
Ronald Jr Pizzano
Great flavors and designing was easy
Mario Castiello
I’m so glad for many reasons that creative cakes by Donna was included in our wedding at Saybrook Point Inn. Donna’s cake was absolutely delicious and looked great too! We got to pick from a variety of options at our wedding tasting. It was a close call between so many delicious flavors from cake to topping and designs / themes. Attached are photos of our cake on our special day. I highly recommend you reach out to them - they were communicative, easy to work with, easy to connect with, and did a job well done!
Nicole Bach
We worked with Creative Cakes by Donna for our wedding cake through our venue The Society Room. Our cake was so beautiful and delicious. We went with vanilla cake with strawberry buttercream with fresh strawberry filling. Thanks Donna! Photographer is Anchored Roots
Donna and her team were such a pleasure to work with! They were very informative, had an amazing cake-tasting pick up box that we could comfortably try from home, and they did an amazing job making my wedding cake look and taste incredible!
Danielle Marie Amarone
Donna and her team were such a pleasure to work with! They were very informative, had an amazing cake-tasting pick up box that we could comfortably try from home, and they did an amazing job making my wedding cake look and taste incredible!
Mihoko S.
Donna and her team were very easy to work with through the whole wedding cake design process, and they executed my vision perfectly. The cake was not only beautiful visually, but also delicious - our guests raved about it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Andrea Scarpini
Creative Cakes by Donna made me the BEST wedding cake. Seriously the most tasty wedding cake I have ever had. Every guest was raving about how good the cake was. I gave her full artistic freedom for my cake other than the flavor and that I wanted it skim coated, but other than that the cake she created was so beautiful and perfect for my wedding! I highly recommend using her for any weddings or events you have!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
alexandria stiteler
Our wedding cake from Donna and Ellie was absolutely stunning and exceeded all our expectations. We opted for a tiered cake on cake risers, featuring a classic white and gold color scheme that beautifully matched our wedding’s theme. The elegance of the design was a perfect complement to the overall decor. The cake had three delicious flavors. We chose marble cake with coffee buttercream, white cake with strawberry buttercream and fresh strawberries, and marble cake with coconut buttercream. Each flavor was distinct and delicious. We received numerous compliments on both the taste and the stunning presentation. Donna and Ellie worked closely with us to ensure our vision was brought to life. They meticulously double-checked all the details of our order to make sure everything was exactly as we wanted.
Creative Cakes by Donna – Wedding Cake Review
Paula from Creative Cakes by Donna was absolutely wonderful throughout the entire planning process. She was incredibly helpful when it came to choosing the perfect flavors, especially considering both my husband and I have gluten intolerance. Her knowledge and care made the process easy and stress-free.
The cake itself was delicious — moist with just the right balance of flavors. The combination of berries and chocolate was perfect and delighted all of our guests. We wanted a simple cake that matched our wedding theme and reflected our personalities, and Paula nailed it perfectly.
A special touch that made the cake even more meaningful was how it incorporated my husband’s woodworking hobby. The beautiful flowers on the cake were wood, and the wooden slab the cake rested on was hand-cut by him. It was such a unique and personal detail that really made the cake stand out.
Throughout the entire process, Paula was patient, kind, and attentive, always making sure we were happy and comfortable with every decision. I can’t recommend her enough to anyone looking for a delicious, beautiful, and thoughtfully made wedding cake!
Thank you!
Mel & Scott
Cakes by Donna made our wedding cake and we were blown away by the final product. It tasted amazing and looked exactly like the vision we discussed. We were so pleased with the result and couldn’t recommend Cakes by Donna enough!
Spectacular work! We wanted something a bit different, and they delivered. Paula was very helpful throught the process, and the cake was everything we wanted. Thank you so much for helping us have a perfect wedding day!
Donna was the vendor that did our cake through the Pond House Cafe! Not only was it absolutely beautiful, it was also delicious. We went with a vanilla cake with strawberry cream filling and buttercream frosting. It was fantastic. Absolutely love that she partners with local venues, makes everything so easy.
We had the best wedding cake! It was so beautiful and tasted so good!! Thanks Donna and her team!
My husband and I ordered our wedding cake through Cakes by Donna (Pond House Cafe venue) and would happily use them again for any cake needs in the future. Our cake was beautiful and delicious! Highly recommend!
Tasted as amazing as it looked! Highly recommend
Great flavors and designing was easy
I’m so glad for many reasons that creative cakes by Donna was included in our wedding at Saybrook Point Inn. Donna’s cake was absolutely delicious and looked great too! We got to pick from a variety of options at our wedding tasting. It was a close call between so many delicious flavors from cake to topping and designs / themes. Attached are photos of our cake on our special day. I highly recommend you reach out to them - they were communicative, easy to work with, easy to connect with, and did a job well done!
We worked with Creative Cakes by Donna for our wedding cake through our venue The Society Room. Our cake was so beautiful and delicious. We went with vanilla cake with strawberry buttercream with fresh strawberry filling. Thanks Donna!
Photographer is Anchored Roots
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Donna and her team were such a pleasure to work with! They were very informative, had an amazing cake-tasting pick up box that we could comfortably try from home, and they did an amazing job making my wedding cake look and taste incredible!
Donna and her team were such a pleasure to work with! They were very informative, had an amazing cake-tasting pick up box that we could comfortably try from home, and they did an amazing job making my wedding cake look and taste incredible!
Donna and her team were very easy to work with through the whole wedding cake design process, and they executed my vision perfectly. The cake was not only beautiful visually, but also delicious - our guests raved about it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Creative Cakes by Donna made me the BEST wedding cake. Seriously the most tasty wedding cake I have ever had. Every guest was raving about how good the cake was. I gave her full artistic freedom for my cake other than the flavor and that I wanted it skim coated, but other than that the cake she created was so beautiful and perfect for my wedding! I highly recommend using her for any weddings or events you have!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our wedding cake from Donna and Ellie was absolutely stunning and exceeded all our expectations.
We opted for a tiered cake on cake risers, featuring a classic white and gold color scheme that beautifully matched our wedding’s theme. The elegance of the design was a perfect complement to the overall decor.
The cake had three delicious flavors. We chose marble cake with coffee buttercream, white cake with strawberry buttercream and fresh strawberries, and marble cake with coconut buttercream. Each flavor was distinct and delicious. We received numerous compliments on both the taste and the stunning presentation.
Donna and Ellie worked closely with us to ensure our vision was brought to life. They meticulously double-checked all the details of our order to make sure everything was exactly as we wanted.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Loading...