SQUARE PEG PIZZERIA HIGGANUM

We door dashed a large order (several pizzas & "garlic bread"). The Dasher had to wait for the order at least 10 mins. We are 12 mins from this establishment & everything was ICE COLD. That order was sitting there for quite some time so it wasn't the Door Dashers fault. We were very hungry & looking forward to dinner. This was good pizza before. It's not good anymore. Extremely disappointed. Will NEVER order from here again. Even if u paid us we won't do it.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

The pizza was not cooked. The staff was friendly, but the pizza was terrible.

Amazing pizza, the quality is great. Having lived in New Haven I’m a little bit of a pizza snob and this place really surprised me.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We had the same experience. The large was so small a child could have eaten it. It is very pricey for what you receive. Not sure if I would try it again. Very disappointed

Great pizza and

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

I ordered a couple of large pizzas for a small crowd and they were a hit! Everything was fresh and delicious, really yummy ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

Never again

Great pizza, awesome bar with plenty of local beers to choose from. Don't expect a quiet sit-down though, the tables are right next to the pickleball court.

Parking: Big lot

Kid-friendliness: Yeah it's a bar, but it's very chill, and most people are cool with kids being there.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Figgy Piggy, Cheesy Garlic Bread, Pepperoni Pizza

Very tasty food and even better atmosphere. Very unique little spot!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Really cool with it's "secret back entrance" check it out !I had their pizza and it's amazing!Their interior looks like it'd be alot of fun! They have a bar, games, and a bunch of cornhole layed out tournament style.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

The pizza is amazing, but my only critique is that it generally arrives lukewarm or cold from doordash. When it comes out of the oven they need a place to keep it warm while they wait for it to be picked up.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I dont know how a place can mess up something as easy as making pizza.. i called tonight to order 1 Large half pepperoni pizza. When i called, they picked up and hung up on me. I called back from 2 different phones about a dozen times. They never answered. So i went on their website and placed an order from there. Its about as simple as it gets, half pepperoni. First of all, it was 33.22 for one large pizza. Thats absurd to start. I got an order confirmation, with the correct order. I sent my friend to pick up the pizza. They charged him, after i had already paid online. And they gave him a large double pepperoni pizza on the entire pizza. They eventually fixed it. But for 33 dollars, they should have sprinkled gold ontop of it and had the correct order ready, on time. Get it together. And stop being so greedy. Pepes doesnt even charge 33 dollars

If I could rate this negative stars I would do so. We just moved to Middletown. We got a flyer in the mail and are looking to find “our new places” to go. So we went. What a mistake. A large pizza, garlic bread and 2 sodas were $39.71. I gave them $40 I guess they decided I did not need my change back. Anyway, the place is filthy. The table had dried ice cream and other items adhered to the table - they clearly had been there quite some time. The massive cob web in the corner above us was disturbing. Now the food. Have you ever been to Chuck E Cheese? Well then you have had this pizza before. Limp crust, it was cold and tasteless. The sauce for the garlic bread was freezing cold. There is really no place to sit. It’s not a restaurant, the main space is taken with corn hole and then a bar. Then advertise your place as such. So disappointed. It might be in a brick oven but frozen pizza in my oven would have been better. Oh and we had to go pick up our items when they were ready and bus our own table when we were done. Yeah needless to say we will never be back and if you were smart you will do the same!

Parking: As we were leaving an employee got in his car (in one of the spots in front of the entrance) really?

We decided to try the local pizza place tonight and what a mistake. The flavor was ok, but when we asked about the size of the small pie we were told a small was "14 inches of pizza" over the phone. Obviously the 12 year old who worked there didn't know what a ruler was. 4 small pies came to $80 - eighty - eighty dollars - 4 small pizzas. $80. Did you get that? We got them home and the cook on the crusts across 4 pies was raw to burnt. This is pizza for drunk people in the bar and maybe those who brought their kids out so they could have fun - fine, we get it. But this is NOT a take out pizza place so go spend $40 elsewhere and get twice the pizza for half the cost. Booooo

Love their food and staff is always so friendly. The Spicy margarita pizza is our favorite!