Middlebury's Best

750 Straits Turnpike, Middlebury
(203) 598-7235

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Emily Lee

This place has super delicious ice cream, froyo, and frozen custard. Excellent friendly service, clean shop, and a bathroom. Thank you for a wonderful birthday treat. We will be back!

Ms SB

Great quality just wish for fresh fruit, flavor rotation, & pie variety

The Batman (Rosario S. Cassata)

We visited Middlebury's greatest ice cream while we made a stop in Middlebury, Connecticut. Despite being a small store, they are able to produce a wide variety of flavors. We were served by a really nice young girl.
The ice cream tastes great. Worth the stop, it is situated in a little strip center.

Belladonna C

The smoothies were wonderful!!! Thanks so much!

nia 0412

The girl who served us was super friendly and patient- made our experience even better! Ice cream is delicious-lots of options. I had a sundae with smores ice cream and marshmallow topping.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Riona Dermaku

The girl named Devin that was working on sep 18th at 1:30 pm was so friendly and patient she deserves a raise, she gave me so many options and recommendations and was so patient with me. Extremely AMAZING service

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Matt

Best ice cream place in Middlebury!!

Dietary restrictions: We have gluten and corn allergies. And the best part is that they have sugar free ice cream. If you don't want to crack your kids out then this is your place

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Frozen Yogurt

TanayaWatlington

My sister (non-vegan) got the red velvet regular ice cream, which she enjoyed. But the vegan options are mix in flavorings to non-dairy vanilla ice cream. The actual non dairy ice cream had a gritty texture??? The staff was very kind, patient and explained everything in detail. The actual ice cream I wasn't a fan of.... the nondairy ice cream sandwiches are okay (kind of tastes like a sugar free vanilla oreo sandwich). Only would recommend if you aren't vegan to try the regular options...

Carol Damelio

Nicest staff best smoothies

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

David Murray

Nice selection of frozen yogurt and ice cream. Staff was very nice and very informative about all the menu options. Cake batter was ?. Going back to try a smoothie soon!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nicole Mulligan

Service was some of the best we've encountered! The girls working were able to handle our large crowd and questions easily! Ice cream was great too!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Devon Mitrik

I love this place! They are open for lunchtime till 9pm so I can get my smoothie or sweet treat during lunch or after work!! I brought my daughter in with me a few times. And the staff were patient and helpful with helping us decide what would be the best combination of toppings with our ice creams! They even give us samples of each so we could really choose the best choice! I even have a new favorite base for my Frozen Money smoothie now! Triple chocolate frozen yogurt ?.I got a cake here too! I have a friend with a gluten allergy and they helped me make the PERFECT cake for her! She loved it!They always have pre-made treats too! So I can swing by before any event I'm going too and bring the best desserts to it.So now I know why they are called Middleburys BESTBest serviceBest pricesBest treats!!!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Frozen Yogurt, Custom Cakes and Pies, Custard

Brittney Perlini

This was my favorite ice cream spot until yesterday around 7 pm or so. Me and my son both ordered a medium soft serve ice cream , no toppings or cone. The girl charged us for a large $5.99 each. I repeated to her that we only ordered mediums and she still made me pay for 2 larges! If I was alone I would’ve left the ice cream and walked out. But my child was so excited I couldn’t. & Because of that employee who overcharged me for my order purposely, I won’t be going back.If I only order a medium why am I being charged for a large? Just terrible! I’ll bringing my money elsewhere.

Service: 1

Laura Benson

Today we visited for our creamy delight..Mary and Katelyn were so polite.Can't wait for the vegan flying saucers

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mike

Best smoothies in town or any other town.

Loading...