Middlebury's Best

750 Straits Turnpike, Middlebury
(203) 598-7235

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Custom Cakes and Pies
Frozen Yogurt
Custard

Frozen Treats
Soft Serve Frozen Custard
Soft Serve Frozen Yogurt
Soft Serve Ice Cream
Soft Serve Dairy Free VEGAN Ice Cream
We change up our dairy free option between Ripple, Almond Milk Swirl, and Temptations Oat Milk. Please call to see what we currently have available.

Smoothies
Mixed Berry
Raspberries, strawberries, blueberries and cranberry juice.
Blueberry Bliss
Blueberries, banana, cranberry juice.
Tropical Breeze
Pineapple, mango and pineapple juice.
Frozen Monkey
Peanut butter, banana and oat milk
Mango Medley
Mangos, banana, pineapple juice.
Peaches N Cream
Peaches, banana, orange juice.
Pina Colada
Pineapple, toasted coconut and pineapple juice.
Pineapple Peach Paradise
Peaches, banana, pineapple juice.
Raspberry Rhapsody
Raspberries, strawberries, banana, cranberry juice.
Strawberry Sunrise
Strawberries, banana, orange juice.

Specialty
Cafe Frappe
Base of your choice blended with fresh coffee
Milkshake
Root Beer Float
Proudly served with A&W Root Beer
Tornado
Don't like your toppings only on the top? Have them blended in for some in every bite!
Banana Split
3 scoops of ice cream with a full banana, hot fudge, whipped cream and a maraschino cherry
Parfait
16 ounces of layered base and toppings

Sundae
Hard Ice Cream Sundae
Ice Cream of your choice, hot fudge, whipped cream & a cherry
Soft Serve Ice Cream Sundae
Ice Cream of your choice, hot fudge, whipped cream & a cherry

From the freezer
6pk Cookiewich Vanilla Ice Cream
6pk Cookiewich Vanilla/Chocolate Ice Cream
3 vanilla and 3 chocolate ice cream sandwiches
6pk Cookiewich Vanilla Custard
6pk Custard Cannoli's
6pk Custard Filled Chocolate Cannoli's

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: zomato
+29 photos
Photo credit: google
+28 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

This place has super delicious ice cream, froyo, and frozen custard. Excellent friendly service, clean shop, and a bathroom. Thank you for a wonderful birthday treat. We will be back!
October 2025
We visited Middlebury's greatest ice cream while we made a stop in Middlebury, Connecticut. Despite being a small store, they are able to produce a wide variety of flavors. We were served by a really nice young girl.
The ice cream tastes great. Worth the stop, it is situated in a little strip center.
July 2025
The girl who served us was super friendly and patient- made our experience even better! Ice cream is delicious-lots of options. I had a sundae with smores ice cream and marshmallow topping.
November 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Subway - 750 Straits Turnpike Suite 1A
Sandwich Shop, Fast Food
Le Bobadel Gourmet Market - 819 Straits Turnpike
Deli
Maples Family Restaurant - 725 Straits Turnpike
Family, Italian, Vegetarian

Middlebury's Best

750 Straits Turnpike, Middlebury, CT 06762
(203) 598-7235