We ordered a small cheese pizza and a gyro, then we got a sample of their Greek yogurt with Greek cherries. Let's just say that the Gyro is the best we have ever had! The yogurt begs for more! We love it here and the food is never a disappointment! We will be back!! Outstanding!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
andrew L
Ordered a large pizza and penne alla vodka and thought it was terrible. Total waste of $40. Threw it out . It was actually so bad I'm upset and hungry. Not to mention completely overpriced for what tasted like heated up frozen food. Portion size of $20 pasta dish was very small too. All around terrible. Wish I could get my money back.
Peter Hall
Quality Greek style pizza.
lyndsay dayfield
They were awesome at some point but must have switched chefs? Definitely not the same as they were a few years ago. I do not have a polygenic disease but the pizza tastes like one so I guess I do now. All jokes aside . But then again I don’t listen to anyone’s review because we all have different opinions because we are all different. Someone else will love but taste not for me.
Fran O
Disgusting…. I was shocked that the side salad cost $3 extra….but when I looked at the falafel I knew it was an issue….dried up old falafel balls with awful tomatoes and burnt grilled onions (which I paid extra for). The tziatiski that I also paid extra for was the only thing worth keeping. The side bulgar salad was very off tasting. Even the red coulis that came with it was spoiled. Nothing was fresh. $17 for this mess. Went in the garbage.
William Shaw
smaller pizza with 4 toppings 2995..and a thick crust I like thin.they put alot of peppers very few mushrooms and onions and not the best chez..there's a few places two large pies for 24.00 and soho only 3 buildings away large 15.00 twice the size try them you'll be so happy
Erin McManus
One of the best Margaritas pies I’ve had, highly recommend. Fresh taste, not overly filling. I could taste the love put into this pizza. If you’ve not been here yet, you’re missing out.
Does not recommend this place waited hours for an order that did not show up after they said they would re make my food have have it delivered waited long time no food thankgod for Italia Mia
Sharon Jerome
My number one pick for pizza in New Milford!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tina Colton
Has been a staple in our household for years. One of the best pizza joints in the area.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Tammy Reardon
Fantastic varieties of pizza! all of those that I've tried have been delicious!
Food: 5
Kimberly Taylor Cross
We have enjoyed NMPS takeout. It's been our go-to for delicious crispy pizza in New Milford. We loved the The One for Meat Lovers as well as the One with Chicken, Truffle Oil & ‘Shrooms. The sauce was great and it was still steaming hot once we got it home. If you're every planning a get-together, on Tuesdays they offer an extra pie when you purchase two!
Pizza is so good!
Food: 4
Service: 4
We ordered a small cheese pizza and a gyro, then we got a sample of their Greek yogurt with Greek cherries. Let's just say that the Gyro is the best we have ever had! The yogurt begs for more! We love it here and the food is never a disappointment! We will be back!! Outstanding!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered a large pizza and penne alla vodka and thought it was terrible. Total waste of $40. Threw it out . It was actually so bad I'm upset and hungry. Not to mention completely overpriced for what tasted like heated up frozen food. Portion size of $20 pasta dish was very small too. All around terrible. Wish I could get my money back.
Quality Greek style pizza.
They were awesome at some point but must have switched chefs? Definitely not the same as they were a few years ago. I do not have a polygenic disease but the pizza tastes like one so I guess I do now. All jokes aside
. But then again I don’t listen to anyone’s review because we all have different opinions because we are all different. Someone else will love but taste not for me.
Disgusting…. I was shocked that the side salad cost $3 extra….but when I looked at the falafel I knew it was an issue….dried up old falafel balls with awful tomatoes and burnt grilled onions (which I paid extra for). The tziatiski that I also paid extra for was the only thing worth keeping. The side bulgar salad was very off tasting. Even the red coulis that came with it was spoiled. Nothing was fresh. $17 for this mess. Went in the garbage.
smaller pizza with 4 toppings 2995..and a thick crust I like thin.they put alot of peppers very few mushrooms and onions and not the best chez..there's a few places two large pies for 24.00 and soho only 3 buildings away large 15.00 twice the size try them you'll be so happy
One of the best Margaritas pies I’ve had, highly recommend. Fresh taste, not overly filling. I could taste the love put into this pizza. If you’ve not been here yet, you’re missing out.
Refused to deliver if I wanted to use cash.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Refused to deliver if I wanted to use cash.
Restaurantji Recommends
Does not recommend this place waited hours for an order that did not show up after they said they would re make my food have have it delivered waited long time no food thankgod for Italia Mia
My number one pick for pizza in New Milford!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Has been a staple in our household for years. One of the best pizza joints in the area.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Fantastic varieties of pizza! all of those that I've tried have been delicious!
Food: 5
We have enjoyed NMPS takeout. It's been our go-to for delicious crispy pizza in New Milford. We loved the The One for Meat Lovers as well as the One with Chicken, Truffle Oil & ‘Shrooms. The sauce was great and it was still steaming hot once we got it home. If you're every planning a get-together, on Tuesdays they offer an extra pie when you purchase two!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Greek Fries, Mediterranean
Loading...