The Iron Rail

10 Railroad St, New Milford
(860) 799-5606

Recent Reviews

Jessica O.

Loved the flavor and cook of the Thai chili wings. We did not choose a protein for our nachos as it was over $7 depending on the type of meat. While the nachos were definitely cheesy.... That's kinda all they were. Lacked the typical veggie toppings. About 5 large jalapeños, a few red onions, and a few tomatoes hidden. We were very impressed with our cranberry walnut salad! I could be wrong but I thought they were supposed to be candied walnuts but they tasted plain. We will definitely go back as we had kind and quick service!

Missy J.

Jenn, the bartender is awesome! She has an upbeat attitude and does a great job with her service.

Kate Huizinga

My husband and I have eaten here multiple times and always had a great experience! The restaurant has a laid back but classy atmosphere. Andy is a very kind and friendly server and the food is always delicious! I would definitely recommend any of the burgers.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Robert Reilly

The only thing keeping me from a 5 stat rating is that the online menu does not match the physical menu.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Peter C.

We came on a rainy night after reading reviews- we were in the mood for steak and it didnt disappoint! Crab cake special was EXCELLENT - better than some seafood places we've been to - steaks were cooked perfectly and the fries and mash were also perfection ... chocolate lava cake was just the right ending, along with the most excellent chocolate martini - perfect meal for a dreary day!!! We will definitely be coming back!!!

Doug Lastra

The food is excellent. Two friends and myself enjoyed a wonderful meal and 6 drinks for under 120 and it felt like a 200 experience. I highly recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Terence N.

Had the Sesame Ahi Tuna Salad; it was very good. It's a nice restaurant, good atmosphere. Pleasantly surprised.

Melissa Fife

We keep coming back in hopes it gets better, but it doesn’t. We came for brunch again, the place was half full. The service was slow as usual. I ordered the burger & Hubby ordered steak & eggs (his food was OK enough) I made a point to mention no bacon and my burger came out WITH bacon. The server, who was very apologetic, brought the burger back into the kitchen and came back out 2 minutes later with what I can only assume was the same burger with just the same burger & the bacon was peeled off of it, as someone with religious restrictions this was not OK. We also ordered an appetizer of monkey bread that never came out, when we asked about it we got it after our meal came and it was uncooked on the bottom. I ordered the mocha espresso martini which was delicious.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Lizbeth N

Found a piece of plastic in my burger. It was not small either, I really Wanted to like this place but that definitely threw me off completely.

Food: 1

Service: 2

Alicia K.

Terrible service. It's too bad bc we really like the food. My husband and I went there on Sat. There were only 2 others at the bar, and the bartender never came over. We sat there for at least 15 minutes, and it wasn't till we got up and put our coats on to leave that he came over. Too late.. We went to the new bbq place and got served right away. Please do something about the service, because speaking to others, the poor and slow service is a deal breaker for them as well.

Kitten Cuddles (Sam D.)

Stopped here while in town to try something new. The food was excellent and our server was very attentive and sincere. However, the wait time for our entrees was outrageous. We had to wait close to an hour because the kitchen had lost our tickets and we were a minute shy of walking out. If that didn’t happen I would have happily given this restaurant 5 stars.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Wes Poole

First time eating here and will be the last. Traveled in from out of town excited to try IR. Ordered prime rib on a Friday. It came out ice cold on my plate. Waitress took it back to kitchen on my bread plate (weird) and then brought it back out after they obviously heated it in an oven. Ordered medium, when it was brought back out slightly warm it was well done like shoe leather. Not much flavor either. Don't waste your money going here. Another person in our party was celebrating their birthday, the petite filet they ordered looked like a hockey puck. McDonald's can cook beef better. This place is in no way a culinary destination. Hard pass!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Trish G.

In town for a visit and stopped by for a quick bite. Pros: the waitress was nice and attentive The decor was nice ,place was clean Cons: ordered the special salad. Only thing that made it special was the beets . They don't have them so it's just a salad. Then I ordered the crispy chicken as added protein. Thinking it was chicken breast. Which is what you usually get on a salad. Nope chicken thigh. The cranberries in the salad were hard like a rock. I literally threw one on the plate and it bounced with a ping. If I go again before I leave I will avoid the salads

Sarah Becker

Festive local landmark.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Neko E.

Wow, thoroughly surprised with my first visit. Amazing cocktails, great food, awesome interior and dope vibe. Will be back.

Load More