Holy Cow Ice Cream Shop
51 Church Hill Rd, Newtown
(203) 426-1359
Customers' Favorites
Pumpkin Ice Cream Come with Chocolate Sprinkles
Floats & Ice Cream Soda
Mint Chocolate Chips
Chocolate PB Chip
Waffle Cone
Cookie
Menu
Photos
+31 photos
+30 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Wonderful, wonderful, wonderful. Gives me nostalgia in the best way. Had to come all the way to Connecticut to get premium Black Raspberry soft serve ice cream. Enjoyed it thoroughly. If you’re in the area it’s well worth the stop.
This is a local gem! Freshly made local ice cream - you can’t beat it.
We got the salted caramel chip which was delicious. Rich salted caramel swirls and shards of chocolate - amazing! Definitely worth stopping by
We got the salted caramel chip which was delicious. Rich salted caramel swirls and shards of chocolate - amazing! Definitely worth stopping by
You May Also Like
Burgerittoville - 57 Church Hill Rd
![]()
Hamburger, Burgers, American, Vegetarian
Reverie Brewing Company - 57B Church Hill Rd
![]()
Brewery, Pet Friendly, Vegetarian
Newtown Pizza Palace - 65 Church Hill Rd
![]()
Pizza, Italian, Mediterranean, Vegetarian
One highlight for me is the chocolate dip. When I asked for it, I was blown away—it’s thick, rich, and truly feels like real chocolate, not just a thin syrup. This dip makes all the...