Supreme Seafood Restaurant

We ate at Supreme Seafood Restaurant for the first time on 9/14/25. Their fried shrimps and steak fries (full portions) were delicious! Their shrimps were large and perfectly cooked; and the steak fries were cooked to perfection and well seasoned!

📅 August 13, 2025 WRITTEN REVIEW Big Al’s Reel Reviews – Ep.150 🎥 Supreme Seafood 💣 Town of North Branford, CT Sometimes a great review starts with a simple follow. I’ve said it before — when restaurants and food spots follow me, I follow back. Then their posts start showing up in my feed, and before you know it, I’m pulling up to see what they’re about. That’s exactly how I ended up here today at Supreme Seafood — and I’m glad I did. At 2:45 in the afternoon, I had the place all to myself. Bright, welcoming dining room, quiet atmosphere, and a warm greeting from my server Allison, who was friendly and attentive from start to finish. Not long after I sat down, Manager Jeremy came out to introduce himself — and that’s when this visit went from a review to an experience. 1️⃣ Lobster Bisque (Cup) – $9.99 💣 Creamy, rich, and packed with fresh chunks of lobster meat — not the stringy filler you get at some places. Every spoonful had that fresh ocean flavor. 2️⃣ Lobster Roll (4 oz.) – $28 I had this on order, but before it arrived, Jeremy decided to step it up… 💣 One-Pound Lobster Roll (Complimentary) This thing was a showstopper. Super fresh, super soft, and super delicious lobster meat piled high on a perfectly toasted roll. The butter wasn’t just plain melted butter — it was lobster juice water mixed with butter and a touch of vinegar. That slight tang cut through the richness and made the sweetness of the lobster pop. 3️⃣ Supreme Combo (Half) – $24.99 💣 Shrimp, scallops, sole fish, calamari, clam strips, and fries — all cooked to perfection. Shrimp passed my personal “Whole Tail Test” (so good I ate the tails) Scallops were sweet and buttery Calamari tender and flavorful Clam strips crispy outside, tender inside Sole fish was on point Even the fries were excellent 4️⃣ Wings (Complimentary) 👍🏾 Jeremy wasn’t done yet — he also brought me a basket of their chicken wings, telling me they might be a seafood place, but their wings are legit. And he wasn’t lying — these were respectfully good wings, some of the very best I’ve had anywhere. Perfectly cooked, great flavor, and a surprise standout for a seafood spot. Service & Hospitality I never walk into a spot expecting freebies, and my review was already forming in my head before this happened. But when a manager steps out, greets you personally, and sends out a 1-pound lobster roll and a basket of wings — unasked — that’s hospitality on another level. When the check came, it was clear they took care of more than just the extras. My total was $41.85 for what could have been much higher. I left a $20 tip because genuine kindness and great service deserve recognition. That gesture didn’t buy my opinion — it earned my respect. Overall Supreme Seafood lived up to its name today. From the perfectly cooked seafood to the personal touch in their hospitality, this was one for the books. It’s not just me saying it — Yelp named Supreme Seafood the “Best Seafood in Every State” for Connecticut in 2025. After my visit, I can see why. The seafood here was top-notch — the lobster roll was 💣, the seafood platter at $24.99 was a great deal and 💣, and that lobster bisque was rich and delicious.💣 You know what? I’m going to go ahead and say it — so far, they’re probably serving up one of the very best seafood experiences in the state of Connecticut that I’ve had. This spot is the 💣, so what you need to do is get your a** down there right away, and make sure you tell ’em Big Al sent you! ☝🏾❤️ – Big Al Mayo “See you on the Rebound, Peace✌🏾out”

This is awesome little quaint place for delicious seafood… The food proportions are more than satisfying and the taste is extraordinary tasteful. I RECOMMEND ANYONE WHO WANTS DELICIOUS SEAFOOD AND FULL PORTIONS to get to Supreme Seafood Restaurant. The Service and atmosphere were A+.
They also have a nice section if you would like to eat outside.

Since the new owners took over this restaurant, It has gone downhill FAST! There portions are smaller! There prices increased and the recipes have changed dramatically! We ordered food to go last night and it was so disgusting, that I wouldn't even serve it to my dogs!!!! AND! The owner is so callous and rude! He doesn't deserve the credit that he gets from certain people who have no idea what good food really is!!!! He just got very lucky to be handed over a restaurant that once had great reviews! Congrat's to the resent owners of a once great fried seafood restaurant! You did an amazinging job destroying it!

Food was not crispy and fried clams were not cleaned.

They had Fish and Cheese Grits as part of their Juneteenth menu and I was blown away. I love dishes that celebrate holidays especially this one that is dear to me, but this one, I mean this dish should be on the year-round menu.

The food is way overpriced. The worst coleslaw , 80.00 dollars for a 1 lb lobster roll. I ordered a side of scallops and they cut the scallops in half , and ordered a shrimp dinner 65.00 dollars outrageous. The batter on the seafood was so bland. I’ll never go back again.

The food servings are incredibly big. The place is very casual, and there is no need to dress up. I was hoping they'd have a nice wine to pair w the seafood, but as I said, it's a casual setting. More cafeteria style than restaurant style. Not that it takes away from the food.

The food has always been delicious in the past. When you purchase a thriving business I think it would serve the new owners best to keep the ingredients the same as in the past. Changing Ingredients just doesn't cut it. Today I was looking so forward to enjoying a wonderful soft shell crab. That is NOT what I got. Instead of the light batter I got in the past, I got a heavy flour base coating.
The onion rings were no better
What happened to the light batter?? You should be able to enjoy the flavor of what your eating and not the flour
Go back to the original recipes or I really believe you will regret it.
I certainly don't mind paying the price (which is high)
When the food is good. The lobster bisque had NOT 1 piece of lobster.
You should take a long hard look at what you are doing, and correct it before it's to late. It pains me to have to say this because my family always came to the restaurant.

Large portions, food is amazing 🤩. Try the honey old bay wings 😗. Fish was fresh and hot

Got fried calamari X2 to go and I live a stone's throw away. The portions and seasonings were both above average but the calamari itself was nothing more than mush. It wasn't greasy, it was simply lacking any crispness at all. I've heard all good things, but unfortunately can't get on board with this order

Food: 2

Service: 5

I have had bang bang shrimp all over including Florida. Supreme by far is the best. Plenty of shrimp, Big, Plump, juicy and slight sweet taste with a burst of hot delicious sauce. Absolutely a must. Never disappointed. This is a must.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: N E Clam Chowder, Lobster Roll, Fried Shrimp Platter, Calamari, Supreme Combo, Fried Calamari, French Fries

Change of ownership and just not the same. This was a favorite spot but now way more greasy.. maybe just working out the kinks. Give them a try, they were the best and hopefully will get there!
UPDATE: Still my favorite spot for seafood! They surely care and wanted to know exactly what went wrong and when/why. Have been since this review and as usual.. stellar!

Food: 4

Service: 5

Loving the place

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Supreme Seafood

2 star restaurant with 4 star price!!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Lobster Roll