Simply Sweet by Elana

28 Jericho Dr, Old Lyme

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Alyssa Loiler

Elana kills it on every birthday cake we order! She always goes above and beyond to make sure the vision is perfect. 🤩

Allyson Wallauer

Thank you Elana for the awesome cupcakes! I’m so happy I found your website when I started looking to support a small business owner for an employee birthday celebration at work. They were a HUGE hit and everyone loved them!! Thank you again!! Could not recommend her enough!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lindsey Sypher

We embarked on a journey from Florida to Connecticut for a family vacation, where we organized a birthday celebration for our cousin. I was determined to find the perfect cake for this momentous occasion. Following some research, I discovered Simply Sweet by Elana and commissioned her to create a custom cake that would align with my vision. I am pleased to say that she precisely replicated my idea, and the cake not only looked superb but also tasted exquisite. She truly delivered! ⭐️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ HIGHLY recommend!

Jennifer Saindon

Amazing cupcakes. I don't usually like how sweet buttercream is, BUT this was amazing!

Allison Saindon

Soo so good and I am not a cupcake lover. Could use a tiny bit more jam but that is just me! Definitely recommend-Edit They did get sent to me by mistake so there was definitely some background mix-up not sure if it was the business itself or the person that ordered them...

Sonja Austin-Willett

We had a special key lime cake made for my Mother-in-law’s 84th birthday. It was fabulous! Thank you for making such a delicious cake.

Sarah Frick

Elana made our absolutely perfect wedding cake! We were so lucky to have found her. Not only was the cake was truly delicious, one of the best wedding cakes I've ever had (bride bias aside)! Elana was so helpful and responsive answer any and all questions and truly working with us to understand the design we were looking for. I would absolutely recommend her to anyone in search for a cake!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cheyenne Belval

WOW!! Delicious is an understatement! You can tell that Elana puts time and love into her baking with just how fantastic her cupcakes taste. We went with the red velvet, chocolate truffle, apple crumb pie and funfetti. Our cake was simple and beautiful, honestly perfect. Elana's attention to detail, communication and professionalism is unmatched. Don't look anywhere other than Elana for your wedding dessert dreams!

Evan Brown

Elana created an absolutely beautiful cake for our wedding, and also a variety of gourmet cupcakes to satisfy the various tastes at the festivities.Masterpieces all!I cannot tell you how pleased we were with everything - or how many compliments we received. On that front all credit, goes to Simply Sweet by Elana. Elena is a true artist, and her art is both visual and gustatorial. She helped make our wedding the event we envisioned.Do yourselves a favor, and whatever event you're having, enlist Simply Sweet by Elana to craft your desserts.

Cheyenne Jameson

WOW!! Delicious is an understatement! You can tell that Elana puts time and love into her baking with just how fantastic her cupcakes taste. We went with the red velvet, chocolate truffle, apple crumb pie and funfetti. Our cake was simple and beautiful, honestly perfect. Elana's attention to detail, communication and professionalism is unmatched. Don't look anywhere other than Elana for your wedding dessert dreams!

Jay Addison Church

Elana made delicious cupcakes to celebrate my son’s birthday. Elana delivered her goodies precisely on time at US Coast Guard Academy with paper plates and napkins! I highly recommend and will place orders with Elana in the future. Below is a screenshot of my Elana recommendation at the Facebook USCGA Class of 2025 Parents Group page.

Taylor Cyr

Great cupcakes! Made exactly how i wanted them and tasted amazing!!!!!

Loading...

Simply Sweet by Elana

28 Jericho Dr, Old Lyme, CT 06371