Stella's Restaurant and Pizzeria

My family ordered 4 pizzas to be delivered to our home last night. Delivery was on time . 3 of the 4 pizzas were absolutely delicious. The crust is awesome with great cheese and fresh ingredients. Only thing that wasn't on the great side is one pizza came with a seriously burnt crust ....the kind of burnt crust that leaves a horrible taste behind ( my husband wasn't pleased). All in all great pizza with delivery and we will be ordering again !

Great tasting extra thin crust pizza. Hope to return sometime real soon. Worth the drive for the quality of the pizza.

Good food, friendly service. Nice ambiance.

Looks like they're closed - today a sign on the door says "closed permanently"...

Love the fact that they deliver in old Lyme, the pizza and wings were delicious!

Great food and atmosphere

Awesome time at Stella's! Mouth-watering Hanger Steak - so tender and delicious! The staff, especially Barbara, was excellent. This is why everybody loves Stella's!

We love coming to Stella's! My favorite is the Gorgonzola fondue appetizer. Wow, just, wow! It's no wonder everybody loves Stella's.

Favorite Friday night spot! Food is always fresh and delicious! Barbara is amazing......highly recommend!

Love Stella's! It's our Friday go-to... can't go wrong with the amazing pizza, drinks and obviously our favorite waitress Barbara! Definitely reccomend!

Its the greatest place ever..killer staff...luv u all...food is awesome

Great pizza and comfortable atmosphere

The food and service was amazing! Loved my server, Barbara! I was there a couple weeks ago with my whole family, and everyone had an incredible experience! Server was so accommodating to the young children and elderly parents! Such a great family environment... there was something to eat for everyone!! Highly recommend!

A hidden gem, excellent service, delicious and generous portions, pizza was highly customized with extra toppings and ranks up there with the top pizzas I've ever had. The Cinco de Mayo Au Poivre Sirloin Tips and capellini were exceptionally tasty and paired off perfectly with the house fine red wine we were served.

This place was recommended to us. We were only one of 2 tables being served a late lunch while there. As we were seated by the bar I asked for a Manhattan. The only server working said it would take a while because she had only been a server for a week and did not know how to make drinks. Apparently there was no one working at that time who knew how to tend their bar. Thankfully she did know how to open a bottle of wine. The food was average and expensive for what was served. My friends salmon dish was overcooked and dry. Someone did come out from the back to speak to the server while she was at the bar. They spoke in hushed tones while looking at our table. Stellas was sadly understaffed and we left with no apology for the poor customer service.