Square Peg Pizzeria Orange

I placed an order online. I got a text telling me my pizza would be ready at 6:45 -6:50. I showed up at 6:50 and notified the guy that I was there to pick up an order. He said that he was busy and he would need about 15 minutes to do my pizza. This was on a Wednesday evening, The place was damn near dead. I'd hate to see the delay on a Friday/Saturday night

Food: 3

Service: 2

We had wing, pizza, and garlic knots...all of it was amazing.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We had wing, pizza, and garlic knots...all of it was amazing.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Best pizza crust around- welcome to Orange!

Atmosphere: 5

Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza

Parking: Is right across from the place

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza

Had cheese, pepperoni & a sausage pizza. Good stuff! Fired, just the right char, great balance of sauce & cheese w crust to be eaten. Will order again

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: GF Hebron Ave

Too bad don’t order

Ordered online through their website. Door dash delivered. The pie was ice cold. Had to warm it up. Then it was pretty good. For the price it should've at least shown up warm. While Doordash is likely to blame, since I ordered from Square Pegs website this is on them. Lost a customer.

Good new haven style pie, brick oven, wood and gas not coal, super unprofessional. Close when they get slow at the axe throwing place. Or when they get tired regardless of hours posted. Sally's prices with a inferior pie and a lot of attitude to go with it. Close at 12 tonight, I called to order at 1045 and he told me kitchens closed. I had to argue to get him to make me a pie, for that kinda money ill go get Pappas on Naugatuck Ave milford and get a better pie for 5$ less and they stick to their hours posted. I do not recommend this place and will never go back

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Pizza was delicious! Ordered the pepperoni and it was so good! The cook was so nice and helpful.

Terrible place. They didnt put any bacon on the pizza and the dipping sauce was cold. Definitely not an italian pizza place.

Didn’t find an option for the food truck so picked this location. We had this pizza from the truck at Black Hog Brewery. I quite like the pizza. Charred crust like New Haven style but soft and chewy (not crispy like New Haven style). The crust wasn’t too think so the soft inside was really really good. Cheese had a great flavor and the pepperoni was also somewhat charred, delicious. I will definitely look into one of the actual restaurants because the food truck was so good.

Terrible place. They didnt put any bacon on the pizza and the dipping sauce was cold. Definitely not an italian pizza place.

Better pizza than Zuppes!I'd go here over any place in town.

Parking: Huge parking, shared with xmas tree shop.

Wouldn't honor coupon listed on the brochure through the site.So I figured I would phone in the order. Turns out they never answered phone listed on the brochure.Guess they didnt want my business.