Recently changed most products. No longer jumbo wings-paid $18 for 12 tiny wings and only got 11. Mozzarella sticks also different and no longer the quality they were previously. Last two pizzas I ordered they stretched the dough so thin that it flopped like a piece of paper when I picked up a slice. Been a regular patron since original owners 7-8 years ago. Tonight was the last time I will spend money there. Doesn’t help that the cook spends his spare time sitting in the corner picking his feet.
Jonathan McClelland
Party pizza is not as well made, but all the rest are good and have plenty of toppings.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Build Your Own Pizzas 10 Small, Pepperoni Pizza
Ann Rochester
Great food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Eric Fontes
I placed an order on slice for delivery via the shop's website. I called the shop when the order was 30 minutes past the delivery time estimated. The worker stated that it went out for delivery 5-10 minutes ago. I said okay. I understand it's a Friday night and the shop may be busy. I waited an additional 30 minutes before a Doordash driver texted me and stated the pizza shop told them that my order had been picked up already. I called them again, and they said they needed to speak to the manager. I was hung up on. Called back again, the worker said I'm gonna put you on hold. Hung up. I drove to the shop. They stated someone else picked it up and refused to refund. The younger man asked if he could make the food again. I said, if that is my only option I would except. The older man then started getting upset and speaking to the younger (not in English so I couldn't understand what was being said) and the younger turned to me and stated I would need to talk to Slice for a refund. So refund and food was off the table. I couldn't be more disappointed. So now they have lost the food, the money that will be refunded to me through Slice, and a customer for years to come. Unfortunate all around.
Service: 1
Bryan Daniels
Atmosphere is dreadful. Service is constant but slow. Really nothing special about the food. It's kinda costly. 4 or so very thin slices of turkey, lettuce, tomatoes cheese. $11-12.00 that's not it specially since right up the road for the same price it is double the size and triple the ingredients. Aka Frankos. They own the store also. And for a $0.99 item. They want $5 around. No lie. That's 5 times. That's not a convenience store or convenience store prices. I do expect to pay a little extra. But they go and buy from Walmart and Aldi and makes 4-5 times what Walmart and Aldi are making on their own products. $4-5 a candy bar. Not even the biggest or best candy bar. Anyways. Good luck. Just buy cigs here if you smoke. Will for now. I noticed they went up and trying to go up more without you noticing. But a cheapo pack. Aka crowns. Have been$8.50 after tax forever. Now it's almost 9 in one week. It was the only thing left there at a half way decent price.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 2
Kacey Terranova
Chicken and Broccoli Alfredo was Alfredo Soup. Called to let them know and was told the Chef always cooks great.
Travis Palmer
I will never go here again you can see straight into the kitchen the employees had their hair down with no internet on or hair nets over their beards
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jim
Don't do it! This place is so gross, food is terrible, service is terrible. Don't waste your time.
Service: 1
Dave
When you walk in the whole place is, for lack of a better word, scuzzy. I ordered a ham grinder with swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato and onion. Swiss is not an option???? When I opened it at home there was tons of lettuce but no onion and the bread was very stale. Will not repeat. Good luck Dave
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Peter Baker
One of the worst bbq chicken pizza’s I have ever had. Crust was so dry and hard you almost couldn’t cut it with a knife. Horrible will not go back.
I moved to Wauregan about 5 years ago. My husband and I went there once to buy pizza. The owners came to tell me that the people here in Wauregan weren't good. He spoke very badly about the community itself... we didn't understand anything, in the end we never went back there again because the pizza wasn't good and we watched the way it was made and were horrified...
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: French Fries
Matthew Coy
Ordered on the advice of my neighbor. The order never arrived ...called the Door Dash Driver .. was hung up on . Called Wauregan Pizza .. absolutely no help what's so ever ..WILL NOT USE EITHER AGAIN .. Wauregan Pizza will NEVER get my business. They could have been the hero and saved the day ..Nooooo!!! instead they were to busy pointing fingers not realizing that it will hurt their business as well ..not only will I never order from them I will go out of my way to rip them to shreds every chance I get to anyone and everyone who will listen .. !!! The right thing to do would have been to make a new order and offer to have us come pick it up . It's far less expensive to make a new pizza in french fries versus losing a customer.
Rick “Windlizard” Escudero
Better, than expected, GiantPizza is underwhelming, their chicken parm looks like hot dog on a big roll
Julie Dalpe
Very good pizza. Had meat pizza, an a veggie pizza.
Recently changed most products. No longer jumbo wings-paid $18 for 12 tiny wings and only got 11. Mozzarella sticks also different and no longer the quality they were previously. Last two pizzas I ordered they stretched the dough so thin that it flopped like a piece of paper when I picked up a slice. Been a regular patron since original owners 7-8 years ago. Tonight was the last time I will spend money there. Doesn’t help that the cook spends his spare time sitting in the corner picking his feet.
Party pizza is not as well made, but all the rest are good and have plenty of toppings.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Build Your Own Pizzas 10 Small, Pepperoni Pizza
Great food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I placed an order on slice for delivery via the shop's website. I called the shop when the order was 30 minutes past the delivery time estimated. The worker stated that it went out for delivery 5-10 minutes ago. I said okay. I understand it's a Friday night and the shop may be busy. I waited an additional 30 minutes before a Doordash driver texted me and stated the pizza shop told them that my order had been picked up already. I called them again, and they said they needed to speak to the manager. I was hung up on. Called back again, the worker said I'm gonna put you on hold. Hung up. I drove to the shop. They stated someone else picked it up and refused to refund. The younger man asked if he could make the food again. I said, if that is my only option I would except. The older man then started getting upset and speaking to the younger (not in English so I couldn't understand what was being said) and the younger turned to me and stated I would need to talk to Slice for a refund. So refund and food was off the table. I couldn't be more disappointed. So now they have lost the food, the money that will be refunded to me through Slice, and a customer for years to come. Unfortunate all around.
Service: 1
Atmosphere is dreadful. Service is constant but slow. Really nothing special about the food. It's kinda costly. 4 or so very thin slices of turkey, lettuce, tomatoes cheese. $11-12.00 that's not it specially since right up the road for the same price it is double the size and triple the ingredients. Aka Frankos. They own the store also. And for a $0.99 item. They want $5 around. No lie. That's 5 times. That's not a convenience store or convenience store prices. I do expect to pay a little extra. But they go and buy from Walmart and Aldi and makes 4-5 times what Walmart and Aldi are making on their own products. $4-5 a candy bar. Not even the biggest or best candy bar. Anyways.
Good luck. Just buy cigs here if you smoke. Will for now. I noticed they went up and trying to go up more without you noticing. But a cheapo pack. Aka crowns. Have been$8.50 after tax forever. Now it's almost 9 in one week. It was the only thing left there at a half way decent price.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 2
Chicken and Broccoli Alfredo was Alfredo Soup. Called to let them know and was told the Chef always cooks great.
I will never go here again you can see straight into the kitchen the employees had their hair down with no internet on or hair nets over their beards
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Don't do it! This place is so gross, food is terrible, service is terrible. Don't waste your time.
Service: 1
When you walk in the whole place is, for lack of a better word, scuzzy. I ordered a ham grinder with swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato and onion. Swiss is not an option???? When I opened it at home there was tons of lettuce but no onion and the bread was very stale. Will not repeat.
Good luck
Dave
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
One of the worst bbq chicken pizza’s I have ever had. Crust was so dry and hard you almost couldn’t cut it with a knife. Horrible will not go back.
Restaurantji Recommends
Worst pizza I have ever had.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
I moved to Wauregan about 5 years ago. My husband and I went there once to buy pizza. The owners came to tell me that the people here in Wauregan weren't good. He spoke very badly about the community itself... we didn't understand anything, in the end we never went back there again because the pizza wasn't good and we watched the way it was made and were horrified...
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: French Fries
Ordered on the advice of my neighbor. The order never arrived ...called the Door Dash Driver .. was hung up on . Called Wauregan Pizza .. absolutely no help what's so ever ..WILL NOT USE EITHER AGAIN .. Wauregan Pizza will NEVER get my business. They could have been the hero and saved the day ..Nooooo!!! instead they were to busy pointing fingers not realizing that it will hurt their business as well ..not only will I never order from them I will go out of my way to rip them to shreds every chance I get to anyone and everyone who will listen .. !!! The right thing to do would have been to make a new order and offer to have us come pick it up . It's far less expensive to make a new pizza in french fries versus losing a customer.
Better, than expected, GiantPizza is underwhelming, their chicken parm looks like hot dog on a big roll
Very good pizza. Had meat pizza, an a veggie pizza.
Loading...