We ordered two pies one white chicken and broccoli and one red sauce with meatball and mushroom. They were both delicious and we noticed that both pies had a gorgonzola flavor which we liked but wondered if that was their secret ingredient? It was mild and buttery and I never thought it could be a thing until we had this.
George Knezek
Great takeout pizza option.
Bonnie Flanigan
Have had their pizza before and it's good. This time I ordered 2 meatball calzones, 1 meatball and pepper calzone, and 1 chicken parm grinder. The calzones had a lot of cheese but very little meat and the meatballs were not very good at all. And the calzone with peppers had no peppers at all. This large calzone was served with approximately 1/4 cup of sauce which wasn't enough even for half of the calzone. Chicken parm grinder was bland. Will not return.
Kim Clifford
We placed a delivery order. Part of our order was missing. The delivery driver confirmed that he picked up everything. I called the restaurant and asked them to deliver the missing food. They wouldn’t do so. All I could get was a refund through the delivery service. I didn’t want a refund. I wanted the missing food. Also, the food that we did receive was mediocre. The eggplant parmigiana was very soggy and tasteless too. Ziti on the side was ordered, but it was piled on top of the eggplant parmigiana. This was our first time ordering, and we will not be back. Terrible customer service and the food was not good.
Sonia Kolodziej
My go to pizza place! Very very similar to New Haven pizza, if not better!!! Staff is extremely friendly as well! Highly recommended ☺️
Anarcho Abolitionist
Somehow managed to get this far in life without trying (to my recollection) a real New Haven slice. Well today was the day, as I ended up in CT for work and was looking for a quick bite.
The pizza was pretty darn good. Solid undercarriage, excellent crisp, and the overall taste was very good. The price (for 2 slices and a drink) was also extremely reasonable. Plus, the guy behind the counter was super friendly. I will definitely be returning if I end up in this area again.
I'm sure some would argue that there are better New Haven slices out there but for a first experience, I came away impressed. I would highly recommend this place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dan Farkas
Excellent New Haven style pizza, you're missing out if you don't try it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Vanessa Kristoff
Delicious cheese pizza and the staff is really nice!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Judy
Horrible! It was disgusting we couldn’t eat it! It had a smell to it like old mushrooms and burnt oven!
Food: 1
Alice Valinsky
Placed an order on the app for 12:15, the pizza was super cold and the cheese was extremely sparing. The receipt with the pizza box has a timestamp of 11:27. Don't intend on returning here.
Recommended dishes: Chicken & Broccoli Pizza with White Sauce
Polly Martin
I do not recommend this pizzeria!!!!. This was our first time in Seymour. We ordered Large pizza with two different flavors - price -$36. First shock for us - all the edges were burnt!!!!. To eat it I had to tear off the edges. #2-The pizza was not whole - but somehow - made of two halves - and a piece was stolen from each half!!!! Check your orders!!! - Recommendation for the pizzeria - change the temperature in the oven, feed the baker --- so as not to steal and install cameras in the kitchen - this is a failure!!! You will lose business with this approach to customers.
Kori Gregory
BETTER THAN MODERN!!! Grew up in CT and always loved any pizza I could get, but the only place I crave when I’m home in Ohio is First Street! Everytime I come back to Connecticut I make sure to eat as much as I can! DO NOT SLEEP ON FIRST STREET!!!!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Allison Hanson
Not sure how I haven’t found this place sooner but I am impressed. Pizza was definitely a delicious newhavent style pizza.Wings were delicious, flavorful and cooked perfectly and the salad and bread was very fresh!10/10 recommend. Can’t wait to go back and try more
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Storm Boris
Best pizza place in town. Not a huge dining section but who cares. “First street?”
We ordered two pies one white chicken and broccoli and one red sauce with meatball and mushroom. They were both delicious and we noticed that both pies had a gorgonzola flavor which we liked but wondered if that was their secret ingredient? It was mild and buttery and I never thought it could be a thing until we had this.
Great takeout pizza option.
Have had their pizza before and it's good. This time I ordered 2 meatball calzones, 1 meatball and pepper calzone, and 1 chicken parm grinder. The calzones had a lot of cheese but very little meat and the meatballs were not very good at all. And the calzone with peppers had no peppers at all. This large calzone was served with approximately 1/4 cup of sauce which wasn't enough even for half of the calzone. Chicken parm grinder was bland. Will not return.
We placed a delivery order. Part of our order was missing. The delivery driver confirmed that he picked up everything. I called the restaurant and asked them to deliver the missing food. They wouldn’t do so. All I could get was a refund through the delivery service. I didn’t want a refund. I wanted the missing food. Also, the food that we did receive was mediocre. The eggplant parmigiana was very soggy and tasteless too. Ziti on the side was ordered, but it was piled on top of the eggplant parmigiana. This was our first time ordering, and we will not be back. Terrible customer service and the food was not good.
My go to pizza place! Very very similar to New Haven pizza, if not better!!!
Staff is extremely friendly as well!
Highly recommended ☺️
Somehow managed to get this far in life without trying (to my recollection) a real New Haven slice. Well today was the day, as I ended up in CT for work and was looking for a quick bite.
The pizza was pretty darn good. Solid undercarriage, excellent crisp, and the overall taste was very good. The price (for 2 slices and a drink) was also extremely reasonable. Plus, the guy behind the counter was super friendly. I will definitely be returning if I end up in this area again.
I'm sure some would argue that there are better New Haven slices out there but for a first experience, I came away impressed. I would highly recommend this place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent New Haven style pizza, you're missing out if you don't try it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious cheese pizza and the staff is really nice!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Horrible! It was disgusting we couldn’t eat it! It had a smell to it like old mushrooms and burnt oven!
Food: 1
Placed an order on the app for 12:15, the pizza was super cold and the cheese was extremely sparing. The receipt with the pizza box has a timestamp of 11:27. Don't intend on returning here.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
Restaurantji Recommends
Good pizza and good customer relations
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken & Broccoli Pizza with White Sauce
I do not recommend this pizzeria!!!!. This was our first time in Seymour. We ordered Large pizza with two different flavors - price -$36. First shock for us - all the edges were burnt!!!!. To eat it I had to tear off the edges. #2-The pizza was not whole - but somehow - made of two halves - and a piece was stolen from each half!!!! Check your orders!!! - Recommendation for the pizzeria - change the temperature in the oven, feed the baker --- so as not to steal and install cameras in the kitchen - this is a failure!!! You will lose business with this approach to customers.
BETTER THAN MODERN!!! Grew up in CT and always loved any pizza I could get, but the only place I crave when I’m home in Ohio is First Street! Everytime I come back to Connecticut I make sure to eat as much as I can! DO NOT SLEEP ON FIRST STREET!!!!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Not sure how I haven’t found this place sooner but I am impressed. Pizza was definitely a delicious newhavent style pizza.Wings were delicious, flavorful and cooked perfectly and the salad and bread was very fresh!10/10 recommend. Can’t wait to go back and try more
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza place in town. Not a huge dining section but who cares. “First street?”
Food: 5
Loading...