Pizzaro's Pizzeria

225 West St, Seymour
(203) 881-9551

Recent Reviews

Dave Montefusco

Pizza very good, atmosphere is very nice,and the people , waitress are great

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Geoffrey Fouad

Better than Sally's (New Haven)

Cameron Thomas

Best pizza in

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

sloww06gto

This is the most inconsistent pizza place ever. When it's good, its good but thats few and far between. They skimp out on topping but charge an arm and a leg for them. On top of that your topping will be scattered about like a 2 year old put it on. Some slices will have a little bit of topping while other slices, nothing. 90% of the time it's drenched in sauce. Avoid larges unless you like an insane amount of sauce. I've switch to getting smalls and it's definitely better as far as sauce and topping placement but then you are paying more. Dinners are all over the place too. Also, not the happiest girls behind the counter.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Chris N.

Good food with good service. I have only gotten takeout but the food is always fresh at a good value

Melissa

Best pizza outside of New Haven! Love the wood fired pizza! The sauce is the perfect tomato sauce for a pizza! A little pricey but once you take that first bite it’s all worth it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Elizabeth Brucker

Wood oven pizza is really

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Antipasto Salad

Ryan B.

Ordered a large pepperoni pizza for pick up, i drove down there and the older women was in the middle of making the pizza as i walked in. I paid for the pizza with younger lady there and i had a comfortable seat as the pizza cooked, i like to get the pizza fresh and hot as soon as it comes out of the oven to bring it home still hot for the family. The inside of restaurant looked clean and cozy for dine in, tv's playing and holiday lights on. The pie with one topping and tax came to $21.47 which is alittle more than i would like to pay for a one topping large pizza but all in all it was cooked well and tasty still when i got home. Something to note is that if you want to do a half one topping pizza, it still cost the same amount for the one topping cost which i don't particularly like when restaurants do that.

Kristine Brown

My son, his dad and I have been eating here for a while. The waitress and staff always seemed nice....until, on Sunday an older white lady said to my 11 year old son and his father...."Oh I heard that you two are the messy ones." Then my son was waiting for his dad to get his car and a white man looked at my child and said "OH im not going out this way" We can spend our money anywere and these microaggressions will not be tolerated. Ignorant, typical suburban garbage....

Monique Gebeau

Amazing! Pizza and grinders. My go to.

Victoria

The food is the best in town. I don’t order anywhere else but this place I absolutely love there food!!! Also customer service is absolutely awesome. I give it a 10 out of 10.?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

alban zeqiraj

Great people and great thin sliced pizza

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

William Gittings

Very good pizza. It's a thin crust in a wood fired oven so it's has a smoky flavor and was a bit chewy which is normal for this kind of pizza. I only ordered pizza so I can't comment on other menu items. It's good but not my personal favorite.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Cherie Cuzzolina

I love this place, I take my kids here all the time. Pizza has a great taste. The cheese is the best. Garlic knots out of this world. Calamari was fresh and not over cooked. Staff is very nice and accommodating. Would definitely recommend to a friend or family member. Well o have already lol. So I’d say best place in Seymour hands down. Just wish they were open today!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Melissa Reyes

In the area and wanted pizza! My family normally orders from here so I decided to pick up a pizza! It was really good! Their pizza sauce is delicious and the pizza is not soggy but not too crispy. It was just right! Definitely have to try other options next time. The service was good too!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Load More