Tavern 1757

318 Roosevelt Dr, Seymour
(203) 516-5461

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Lynda Codeghini

The worst dining experience ever. Music too loud, soup cold, crab cakes like hockey pucks and clams that were also cold. This place hardly has edible food. Service was terrible. Took a half hour to get cold soup and another twenty minutes to get substandard main. Oh boy!! Sad to say as I so want to support local business but can't this time. Hope they improve.

Kevin Mackowski

This is a very rustic, friendly place. The wood-fired pizza oven makes delicious pizzas, and the service is excellent. Prices are fair considering the quality & freshness of the ingredients. Good place to bring a date.

Joy DiMauro

Baby shower. Anniversary party. Nice surroundings well set up. Decent food.

Karen Gabianelli

Bday party for 16yr olds good food. The guy assigned to us was awesome

Katelyn Gullo

Ordered food to go and when I got my sandwich it was missing the most important ingredient.....PESTO!! I ordered the "Pesto Chicken" which was a sandwich and I did not get any pesto on it. It was only chicken, tomatoes, and fresh mozz on overly buttered grilled bread. The menu said sundried tomatoes came on it but instead I got raw tomatoes...which I hate!! I was so upset!...the reason why I ordered this sandwich was because I love pesto.

Jill Wynn

How does a restaurant that has an extensive list of pizza choices run out of mozzarella? How does a restaurant run out of French Fries and hamburgs? Lobster sliders, out of? Orange rice for the salmon dinner; we can substitute risotto? This is the second time that we were here with soooo many items not available. The staff was excellent and very apologetic, and even bought a drink for my husband, but how do you manage a restaurant that continues to run out of popular menu items? Unfortunately it was probably our last time there...

Brian Nentwick

Brunch was overpriced, the drinks weren't that great and the locations of some stations were not only unlabeled (the waffles and some other things are on the bar half obstructed by a wall where the staff go to pick up dishes from the kitchen during a normal shift), which would have been fine if it wasn't for no one being there to make an omelette or waffle.

B Gonzo

Attempted to get in contact with the "general manager" in regards to booking our wedding rehearsal dinner in there wine cellar. We emailed, left a voicemail and even texted the "general manager" and we had not received any form of a reply in a week. Other places emailed us back the same day. Today, we received an email from the "general manager" that contained only 5 words.. just letting us know that the date we requested was available. In our initial email not only did we ask if the date was available but we asked for a bunch of other details as well. Clearly this restaurant and the "general manager" have other things to do rather than host parties for there guests or even take 5 minutes to reply to an email with effort. If you are looking to book your event here, look elsewhere as there are many other places available and this place seems like they will just take there time while wasting yours.

B Rizzle

1 of the best in the area! Great menu options and always willing to go above and beyond. Great bar and service!

Dan Marcucio

Amazing food. Tonight Joe, the owner, put on an amazing chef's dinner. The food was absolutely amazing. I can't recommend this place enough.

Giuliano Di Nino

Great atmosphere and food

Katie MacLean

Amazing food!! This was our third NYE dinner there, we go every year for our anniversary, every year we leave impressed with the food! Also had our rehearsal dinner here and the food was awesome! Thank you!

Roseann Mayer

My husband and I both had the filet steak. It was very tender and tasty. The wait staff was very friendly and efficient.

Erin Tong

We had the stuffed chicken and the French onion NY Strip! Food was out of this world and the service was fantastic! The owner Joe even came out to introduce himself and thanked us for coming! We will definitely be back.

Chrystal Illes

We held a bridal shower here of roughly 45 people and everything about our experience was wonderful. The staff was so friendly and attentive. We did a brunch style buffet for our event and the food was amazing! We truly had no complaints and I highly recommend holding any event of yours here!

Loading...