Mel's Downtown Creamery

37 W Broad St, Pawcatuck
(860) 599-1363

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Premium Hard Ice Cream Sundae Kit
Del's Lemonade Glass Bottle
Chocolate Lover's Dream
Hard Yogurt Sundae Kit
Cotton Candy Ice Cream
Shaved Ice Strawberry
Large Chocolate Cup
Ice Cream Nachos
Mini Mel Sundaes
Del's Refresher

Menu

Ice Cream
Premium Hard Ice Cream Cup
Choose your favorite flavor of premium hard ice cream or yogurt followed by the size and any toppings that you would like added.
Premium Hard Ice Cream Milkshakes
Your choice of ice cream blended with milk and shake syrup for a delicious shake.
Vegan Non Dairy Ice Cream Cup
Our Vegan Non Dairy Ice Cream is a delicious coconut milk based treat for all to enjoy
Ice Cream Float
Ice cream and beverage come separately. Choose from coca cola, diet coke, root beer or orange soda with vanilla ice cream.

Sundae Kit
Hard Ice Cream
Build your sundae kit. Choose 1 Quart of your favorite premium ice cream or yogurt flavor, 1 sundae topping, 1 candy topping and sprinkles of your choice. Cherries included.
Non-Dairy Ice Cream
Build your sundae kit. Choose 1 Quart of non dairy vegan ice cream, 1 sundae topping, 1 candy topping and sprinkles of your choice. Cherries included.

Specialty Sundaes and Sweet Treats
Peanut Better Dayz
2 scoops of ice cream surrounded by hot fudge, hot peanut butter sauce, Rees's pieces and homemade whipped cream.
Oreo Madness
Two scoops of Oreo Ice Cream surrounded by Hot Fudge, Oreo crumbles and finished with homemade whipped cream.
Chocolate Lover's Dream
A brownie sandwiched between two delicious scoops of Extreme Chocolate ice cream drenched in hot fudge then topped with homemade whipped cream and chocolate krispy krunch.
Chocolate Dipped Frozen Cheesecake
A delicious slice of New York style cheesecake frozen on a stick then dipped in chocolate just like your favorite fair food.
Non Dairy Peanut Better Dayz
Non dairy chocolate or non dairy vanilla ice cream surrounded by hot peanut butter and hot fudge topped with mini reeses pieces and homemade whipped cream.
Non Dairy Oreo Madness
Non dairy chocolate or non dairy vanilla ice cream topped with hot fudge, crushed oreos and homemade whipped cream.
Non Dairy Chocolate Lover's Dream
Non dairy chocolate ice cream topped with hot fudge, chocolate krispy krunch and homemade whipped cream.
Non Dairy Elvis
Banana sliced between 2 scoops of non dairy vanilla surrounded by hot peanut butter sauce then topped with mini chocolate chips and homemade whipped cream.
Non Dairy Banana Fosters
Banana sliced between 2 non dairy vanilla ice cream scoops with caramel topping, cinnamon streusel and homemade whipped cream.
S'More Lovin
Campfire s'more ice cream surrounded by hot fudge and marshmallow drizzle, topped with homemade whipped cream and crumbled graham cracker.
American Pie
Classic vanilla ice cream ice cream topped with a delicious maple apple drizzle, homemade whipped cream and cinnamon streusel.
Sweetheart Sundae
Chocolate ice cream covered with sweet strawberries, topped with homemade whipped cream and finished with a hard chocolate drizzle.
Homemade Chocolate Chip Cookie Ice Cream Sandwich
Your favorite scoop of ice cream between two homemade chocolate chip cookies for a locally delicious ice cream sandwich.
Bonfire Sundae
Hot fudge and marshmallow sauce surrounded by two scoops of graham central station ice cream topped with graham crumbles, homemade whipped cream, and a chocolate drizzle
Tornado
Soft serve ice cream blended with your choice of candy topping.
Ice Cream Flight
Your Choice of 6 Sample Size Scoops of Ice Cream for a FUN dessert experience
Loaded Ice Cream Nachos
2 mounds of soft serve with a side of homemade whipped cream, your choice of 1 candy topping and 1 sundae topping finished with 12 waffle cone nachos
Loaded Ice Cream Nachos for 2
4 mounds of Soft Serve with 4 sides of homemade whippe cream, your choice of 1 candy topping and 1 sundae topping finished with 25 waffle cone nachos.

Kindness Cones
Kindness Cones
Kindness cones will be delivered to those in need, first responders, the youth center, and more. Purchase a cone today to donate and make someone's day sweeter. All kindness cones will be distributed by Mel's downtown creamery to the recipient in the form of a coupon card. This item is not delivered.

Drinks
Del's Classic Lemonade - Glass Bottle
Del's Pink Lemonade - Glass Bottle
Canned Soda
Bottled Water
Glass Bottled Soda

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+59 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+58 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Ice cream wasn't bad, but the place was dirty and smelled musty. My feet were sticking to the floor. One of the young female employees was swearing quite a bit - and I was there with my grandchildren. Not sure if I'd go back
July 2025
Fun old fashioned ice cream shop with great decor and delicious ice cream. They have a good variety of flavors, including special flavors and Hawaiian shaved ice as well. The shop had great ambiance and even had a dj playing music for entertainment.
June 2025
First time I’ve ever been here, and inside the shop was very cute! I asked to taste the campfire s’mores ice cream, and it was very tasty. I ordered a milkshake with that flavor and was really disappointed with my milkshake because it was so melted, almost like soup lol. Definitely gunna go back to try them out again but maybe not a milkshake lol.
November 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Bess Eaton - 1 Coggswell St
Coffee Shops, Coffee, Coffee & Tea, Donuts, Bagels
Hoof's Restaurant & Bar - 59 W Broad St
Italian, Bar
Bogue's Alley LLC - 11 W Broad St
Deli

Mel's Downtown Creamery

37 W Broad St, Pawcatuck, CT 06379
(860) 599-1363