Old Mystic Country Store

47 Main St, Stonington
(860) 245-5533

Recent Reviews

Sort by
BSAR Patel

Wonderful country vibe with delicious food.

Joe Hartung

My family loves this place. I get the best breakfast sandwiches there my kids love there grinders and the pizza is always hot and fresh! Way to go Tony great job!

LORI BIELECKI

UNBELIEVABLE!!!!!! NO WORDS CAN DESCRIBE HOW MUCH FUN WE ALL HAD! Had a party with about 40 + people.....Tony and Chantel went above and beyond to make the most UNBELIEVABLE pizzas!!!! THE BIG MAC pizza and soupy pizza was a BIG hit!!!!HIGHLY .....HIGHLY......RECOMMEND!!!!

Betty Duncan

Awesome wraps, great pizza!

Bruce Kennedy

Excellent grinder!

Chris Keenan

Love this place!!! Great people! Great food!!

Josephine Guarnaccia

Love their sausage grinder. Delicious! Friendly staff. A real gem!

Cyndi Katt Card

I got a everything pizza, perfectly cooked!!!! Crust cooked to perfection. And the shakes are out of this world!!

aldavis73

We went in this shop just to browse, but I ended up coming out with many cooking kits to bring home to try. The maple candy was also an item that we tested out and impressed. Once returning home, I called the store and placed an order for a shipment of items we loved. Not only does this store have great cooking options, condiments, fudge and candy, but is also an interesting store to browse for household items and souvenirs. It seems this is listed as a restaurant on Tripadvisor, but is actually a small store.

John Morris

Today we had a bacon pizza delivered.It was the best pizza we have had in an awfully long time.It came hot and quickly.Thumbs-up to the chef and the delivery person for a great job.

Diana B

Recently changed ownership, but the pizza is still great. We come at least once a month. Wish they had longer hours.

Google user

I ordered a bacon egg and cheese on a roll, salt pepper ketchup... roll was a rock, no salt pepper or ketchup, egg was over easy and spilled all over the place, and I’m confused on what cheese was used... not the traditional yellow American... was more like Queso cheese sauce Or something. Really bizarre. And it took 20 minutes to get my stale incorrect mess of a sandwich. Will be telling the friends to not go here.

Christopher Thorp

5 weeks ago I stood at the counter for almost 10 minutes and wasnt greeted by the chef who looked right at me and walked away to finish his conversation with the other guy in the kitchen so I left . I promised myself I wouldnt go back . Today I decided Id give it another try. Ordered a small meatball grinder , picked it up and got meatballs with sausage on it , not what I ordered . Id have refused it but was on my lunch hour and couldnt waste time waiting for my order to be correctly made. Im done , its always something with this place.

Renee McCammon

Tried the pizza at Olde Mistick country store last night and it was fantastic. The staff were very friendly and the pizza was delicious. My son declared it was his new favorite pizza!! We had the meatball ricotta and really enjoyed it!

UnikelyFan

A very nice General Store. It had a little bit of everything, nuts, fudge, soup mixes, seasonings and more. It is definitely a must see!

Loading...