Alyssa's Cakery

156 Center St, Wallingford
(203) 269-9408

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Theresa Borchetta’s

I was at a wedding recently in Southington. As soon as I tried the mini cupcakes I had to know where they came from. I found out it was here. The icing was perfect, not too sweet and the cake part was moist. Best ever, and I am picky

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Mini Cupcakes

Marissa LaLuna

I cannot say enough great things about Alyssa’s Cakery. They are very responsive, helpful and accommodating to any needs. The prices are amazing and the quality of their baked goods are even better!! I have ordered 4+ times this year and every single time I’m more impressed! This is my favorite bakery for specialty cakes and cupcakes or even just an afternoon treat!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dan Petroskey

My family and I have had wonderful experiences with the cakes and cupcakes we have ordered from Alyssa’s over the years! Everything was delicious and the staff was always so friendly and accommodating!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sarah Rose Bloom

My husband and I got cupcakes and our wedding cake from Alyssa’s cakery 3 years ago. And now we are enjoying our wedding cupcakes for our third anniversary. The staff was kind, responsive and helpful. We super appreciate this place.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rayanne Sola

Thank you so much to the amazing team over at Alyssa Cakery for an incredible job on my grandfather's 90th birthday lobster feast cake!

From booking to day of pickup Alyssa's Cakery was super helpful to bring my inspo vision to life! My grandfather loves seafood so the team took their time with every detail in this lobster pot cake and it showed!!!!!!

The cannoli filing tasted so good and every guest admired the cake so much!

When I picked up the cake order Alyssa was so sweet and let my mom and I see the cake before it was boxed up! It was a truly special moment to see the true talent and craftsmanship Alyssa's Cakery has!!!

Highly recommend!!! As a Wedding Content Creator taking content of this lobster pot cake was so much fun ;)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cindy Iannini

I custom ordered a Bourbon Barrel cake for my husband’s birthday this past weekend. From the start in the ordering process it was absolutely efficient and pleasant. The finished product was a WOW, the guests were blown away with the look and taste! I highly recommend using this bakery for any and all custom cakes.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jennifer Diglio

If you have allergies or celiac, stay far away! The cake was decorated nice, tasted okay although frosting was a bit too sweet! It was also pricy at $70 for a small round cake. We ordered a gluten free cake and were assured that they’d do everything possible to avoid cross contamination. That clearly didn’t happen! My celiac daughter has been very sick after eating this cake! If you have allergies/celiac, bake your own cake or go to another bakery that can truly accommodate!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Natalie Acone

Alyssa and her team did a wonderful job for my wedding! We got a cake and the mini cupcakes from her. Both were fantastic, and we got so many compliments! Everyone loved the variety of cupcakes especially the lemon blueberry, strawberry and smores'! Price was right, and the product and service were wonderful! 10/10 recommend!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake, Mini Cupcakes

Gina Duffy

We used Alyssa’s Cakery for cupcakes and a cake for our son’s birthday and everything turned out fantastic! They came out exactly how we wanted, and everyone keeps saying how delicious they were. We will definitely be back for future events!

Cara Perillo

Alyssa did a cake for a family baby shower, and she knocked it out of the park! The cake was the hit of the party! Beautiful and It tasted absolutely phenomenal (chocolate cake with strawberry filling and whipped cream frosting) the whole cake almost went, which I feel like never happens at parties, everyone was asking me where we got the cake, I think Alyssa Cakery just acquired many new customers. Cannot wait for my wedding to be here so we can Indulge in more cake! 😍

Chynna Marrero

Ordered a cake and cupcakes for my 30th Birthday Brunch! Not only was Alyssa quick to respond but super friendly!! Amazing flavors and exactly what I wanted! I did Butterscotch Blondie and Strawberry Prosecco for the cupcakes and a Funfetti Cake! Absolutely delicious. Thank you so much!!

Darleen Seal

Went to a 13 party the cake was delicious with fresh strawberries and a wonderful frosting. The bday girl was gluten also

Kaitlyn Nolan

I've ordered two birthday cakes from Alyssa's now and both are amazing! Alyssa is amazing to work with on cake design and her execution is flawless. And most importantly, her cakes are DELICIOUS. I've had many of a beautifully decorated cake, but the cake itself wasn't good. Alyssa's cakes are always so good and she has a great range of flavors to really get the taste you're looking for. I'm looking forward to ordering again!

Elisa Sansone

My girlfriend and I always order their chocolate cake with chocolate mousse filling, for special occasions. delicious cakes. great customer service

Mille Lopez

LOVE this bakery! Always satisfied with a purchase and I also love attending the cake decorating classes offered! I’ve attended with family, & coworkers! Always an amazing time! Highly recommend!!

Loading...