Everything at Anthony's is great, pizza, sandwiches, and salads. I love that they have a variety of pizza by the slice for a quick lunch. The crew at Wallingford is super friendly, keeps me going back.
Service: 5
Christine Vachon
I used this place twice now for a catered luncheon. They did a great job. I should have taken pictures. I usually order their hand-helds on a panini. These are huge!I ordered a variety each time and everyone loved them. I believe I’ve ordered every kind. Their catered salad was delicious too. I’ve tried both the Greek and the garden salad. What sealed the deal is their cookies, especially the peanut butter chocolate chip.I will definitely be using them again
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Zachary Georgina
I work just down the street and they have become one of the "Go To" lunch options. The quality of their food is great, especially their bread. Its one of those things places over look but not here, you best believe that your artisan tuna sandwich is on some of the best bread around and boy does it make that sandwich pop! Other thing of note is the soup, when they have the Potato Leek get it, if they have the Potato Leek with Bacon GET A LARGE! Chicken Rice Soup is also good, and a regular cold day item worth having. Last thing, they have both Deep River Chips, and Foxon Park Sodas, which is a plus in my book!Parking: Limited Parking in the front, but there are additional spaces around back. Back parking access is on the right side of the building.
Would NEVER EVER recommend this place to any living human being or worst enemy !! TOTALLY DISGUSTED! I could only wish their website allowed me to post pic of my disgusting burnt beyond recognition calzone COMPLETELY burnt on the outside & ice cold inside ! cheeses & ricotta not melted on inside!! IM SOOO PISSED OFF!! Not to mention had to go back 2 x's! my order was totally incorrect.. ordered one large pizza one calzone picked up order only to come home and realize I had 2 large pizzas w/all the wrong toppings!! & No Calzone! DISGUSTING
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Vintage_gallery 1304 Gizmo
The service and food are excellent.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Maria M'ino
A reliable source for yummy fresh pizza or meals!! I love the pizza by the slice, garlic knots and desserts.
Adam kyasky
They charge full price for topping on half the
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Christopher Pietras
We ordered a few pies from here the other nite. One was Anthony's Special and a Veggy. Both were delicious. The crust was perfectly done. Everything was great. Will be ordering again soon.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brian Pedalino
Hands down the best hidden sandwich shop in wallingford!! Staff is super friendly and food is fantastic. So good it may of become a staple weekly spot when I need a quick meal and don't have time to cook. Everything on the menu is a worldly experience. Highly highly recommend. And don't skimp out, get a garlic knot on the side!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mr Potato Pizza, Rams Short Rib Grilled Cheese Sandwich, Gluten Free Pizza, Pesto Chicken Sandwich, Hot Angus Top Round Sandwich
Thomas Andrews
Definitely one of the top 2 pizza places in Wallingford - closest to a new have style that I’ve had.
Pizza very very good Soups are spectacular Has become our "go to" place Very good clean friendly and delicious
Chris Edwards
Great place for something quick to eat. Got some sandwiches which were delicious, staff was friendly and service was
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lyndsay C.
One of my family's go-to places for easy, delicious takeout. You can order online (HUGE plus), and their menu is diverse enough to have something for everyone, but not so diverse that you can't tell what their deal is (like those pizza places that randomly sell quesadillas or hot dogs). We have tried a lot of the offerings - their pizza is totally legit. Not life changing but highly decent. Their stuffed breads are really, really good and a huge value. One can feed two grown men easily. The pasta dinners are great - but don't have high expectations for the side salad, it's a rather sad smattering of lettuce leaves and a couple of olives. Personally I have a hard time ordering anything other than the Bobcat as a panini- it'a a 10/10 every time. Bottom line - this place hits the mark on convenience, price, and taste. A rare find, I hope they are around for a long, long time!
Daniel L.
The pizza is incredible at Anthony's Pizzeria and deli. This is my favorite pizza place in CT. The pizza sauce is great. The mozzarella cheese is very neutral tasting and the dough and crust have a nice crunch to it. Highly recommend.
Scott K.
This is their second location, the original being in Cheshire. I've stopped in this location a few time but haven't written about it until now. Ermel, the owner, it usually here and is just such a great person and restauranteur. The pizza is excellent. The sandwiches and salads, made fresh, are also very good. The freshly baked cookies and frozen desserts round off a complete selection. Oh, yeah. He bakes fresh rolls and bread for sale each day, too! I can't say I've ever had a better roll anywhere.
Everything at Anthony's is great, pizza, sandwiches, and salads. I love that they have a variety of pizza by the slice for a quick lunch. The crew at Wallingford is super friendly, keeps me going back.
Service: 5
I used this place twice now for a catered luncheon. They did a great job. I should have taken pictures. I usually order their hand-helds on a panini. These are huge!I ordered a variety each time and everyone loved them. I believe I’ve ordered every kind. Their catered salad was delicious too. I’ve tried both the Greek and the garden salad. What sealed the deal is their cookies, especially the peanut butter chocolate chip.I will definitely be using them again
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I work just down the street and they have become one of the "Go To" lunch options. The quality of their food is great, especially their bread. Its one of those things places over look but not here, you best believe that your artisan tuna sandwich is on some of the best bread around and boy does it make that sandwich pop! Other thing of note is the soup, when they have the Potato Leek get it, if they have the Potato Leek with Bacon GET A LARGE! Chicken Rice Soup is also good, and a regular cold day item worth having. Last thing, they have both Deep River Chips, and Foxon Park Sodas, which is a plus in my book!Parking: Limited Parking in the front, but there are additional spaces around back. Back parking access is on the right side of the building.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mr Potato Pizza, Rams Short Rib Grilled Cheese Sandwich, Tuna Rama Sandwich, Chicken Bacon Ranch, Pesto Chicken Sandwich, Chicken Cutlet, Grilled Cheese, Grandma's Meatballs, Steak and Cheese
Would NEVER EVER recommend this place to any living human being or worst enemy !! TOTALLY DISGUSTED! I could only wish their website allowed me to post pic of my disgusting burnt beyond recognition calzone COMPLETELY burnt on the outside & ice cold inside ! cheeses & ricotta not melted on inside!! IM SOOO PISSED OFF!! Not to mention had to go back 2 x's! my order was totally incorrect.. ordered one large pizza one calzone picked up order only to come home and realize I had 2 large pizzas w/all the wrong toppings!! & No Calzone! DISGUSTING
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
The service and food are excellent.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A reliable source for yummy fresh pizza or meals!! I love the pizza by the slice, garlic knots and desserts.
They charge full price for topping on half the
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
We ordered a few pies from here the other nite. One was Anthony's Special and a Veggy. Both were delicious. The crust was perfectly done. Everything was great. Will be ordering again soon.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hands down the best hidden sandwich shop in wallingford!! Staff is super friendly and food is fantastic. So good it may of become a staple weekly spot when I need a quick meal and don't have time to cook. Everything on the menu is a worldly experience. Highly highly recommend. And don't skimp out, get a garlic knot on the side!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mr Potato Pizza, Rams Short Rib Grilled Cheese Sandwich, Gluten Free Pizza, Pesto Chicken Sandwich, Hot Angus Top Round Sandwich
Definitely one of the top 2 pizza places in Wallingford - closest to a new have style that I’ve had.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Pizza very very good Soups are spectacular Has become our "go to" place Very good clean friendly and delicious
Great place for something quick to eat. Got some sandwiches which were delicious, staff was friendly and service was
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
One of my family's go-to places for easy, delicious takeout. You can order online (HUGE plus), and their menu is diverse enough to have something for everyone, but not so diverse that you can't tell what their deal is (like those pizza places that randomly sell quesadillas or hot dogs). We have tried a lot of the offerings - their pizza is totally legit. Not life changing but highly decent. Their stuffed breads are really, really good and a huge value. One can feed two grown men easily. The pasta dinners are great - but don't have high expectations for the side salad, it's a rather sad smattering of lettuce leaves and a couple of olives. Personally I have a hard time ordering anything other than the Bobcat as a panini- it'a a 10/10 every time. Bottom line - this place hits the mark on convenience, price, and taste. A rare find, I hope they are around for a long, long time!
The pizza is incredible at Anthony's Pizzeria and deli. This is my favorite pizza place in CT. The pizza sauce is great. The mozzarella cheese is very neutral tasting and the dough and crust have a nice crunch to it. Highly recommend.
This is their second location, the original being in Cheshire. I've stopped in this location a few time but haven't written about it until now. Ermel, the owner, it usually here and is just such a great person and restauranteur. The pizza is excellent. The sandwiches and salads, made fresh, are also very good. The freshly baked cookies and frozen desserts round off a complete selection. Oh, yeah. He bakes fresh rolls and bread for sale each day, too! I can't say I've ever had a better roll anywhere.