From the beginning every pizza I ordered was amazing. Truly. Perfectly cooked. Great taste. Visually stunning. But now…. Idk what has happened. In only a short time it’s already gone down hill. I don’t get it. Two times ago I ordered pizza and it was straight burnt. Like inedible. I thought they were having an off day. Although to be honest I’ve worked in restaurants my entire life and if you see you desecrated a pizza you start over. Not serve it to a customer who’s paying top dollar. They’re quite pricey which normally is a non issue bc I’d rather pay more for an amazing pizza than less for a pile of junk. The last time I got the pizza it was undercook and flabby. Again I thought .. maybe they were so busy they weren’t paying attention. Or maybe bc it was earlier in the day and the ovens weren’t hot enough yet. Either way I’ve had it enough times to chalk it up as a fluke. So today I decide to order it again. I even told the girl taking the order about the last two times I ordered and how I’d really appreciate it if they could make sure it was done correctly. Charred but not burnt and not undercooked. She was very sweet and said absolutely I know exactly what you mean. Ok perfect! I go and pick up my pizza and not only is it not cooked correctly, but it looks as if it was made last night. You know how pizza looks the next day. It didn’t look fresh. The cheese wasn’t melty. It wasn’t even warm. It sincerely looked like a pizza they made the day before and saved it for the next day not wanting to throw it away wasting $$. It wasn’t cheesy but dry. The crust looked like it was cooked ok but just by the skin of its teeth. It’s nothing like it used to be. Idk if they’re cutting corners or have a new cook but they need to go back to the original way bc this is not good. And again, they’re on the expensive side. $17 for a small pizza is a lot of money. It’s bread sauce and cheese. I got half pepperoni. But still, that should be like $12. I don’t mind paying more when it’s delicious but this was something I coulda gotten anywhere. It’s too bad bc they used to be amazing. I don’t enjoy writing bad reviews but I’m really bummed. And the pictures they post on the Wallingford fb forum always look so amazing. Every pie that leaves the building should look like those photos. We eat with our eyes first so when something doesn’t look right it automatically tells your brain it isn’t good. I gave it 3 stars bc I know what it could be and what it once was but if I based it solely off todays plus the last 2 visits they would have gotten 1 ⭐️. I tried to give them a fair chance to recover but this is now 3 strikes. Please do better. You were the best around. It’s very disappointing
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 4
Ryan Holznagel
Small joint amazing pizza gotta get it!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dave Dave
One of the top pizzerias in the state! If you haven't tried Inferno Apizza it's a must!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mark Jas
Just tried this spot for the first time. Ordered the fresh tomato and the eggplant special pie. Both pies were cooked extremely well, perfect for New Haven style. The prices are a bit high for what I would call a medium size pizza (16” large). Also, there was a lack of taste… just bland. It’s like there wasn’t enough garlic or oregano just overall taste to the pizza. I had high hopes when I saw the pies and how good they looked. The taste wasn’t there though. Probably won’t go back but I hope they continue and figure things out better. They definitely know how to cook a pie.
Erick Oertel
I got 2 medium pies. 1 sausage and 1 mushroom and spinach. the pies were cooked perfectly. crispy and the sauce and cheese were excellent. the toppings were fresh and not from cans. the sausage was real deal Italian. highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Roy Young
Quite possibly the worst tasting pizza I’ve ever had.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
John Plasse
Super good new haven style pizza. Had a roni/bacon and it was FANTASTIC. Not an eat in joint best for pick up.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 3
Mike Barnabas
New Haven style pizza!! Small place, but a killer pie! No Subs?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joseph Cellini
Absolutely amazing pizza!!! This hidden gem is off the charts!! So glad it is in Wallingford! A must try !!!
I tried your Pepperoni pizza, little sweet n little spice..OMG, this was cooked perfectly and tasted amazing! I’m not a spicy eater but the honey with the mild spice hit the spot! I usually get mozzarella pizza, but this time I tried the Pepperoni sweet n spicy, I’m so happy I did! I will be back for more, thank you. Mary Ann
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: House Salad, Plain Pizza
Mandy Doyle
This is some great New Haven style pizza. Tonight was our first night trying them and we will definitely be going back. Mandy and Tommy
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brendan Jooss
I’ve known Mike for a long time now, and know how much he puts into Inferno. His work ethic is immeasurable, and the pride he takes in his craft speaks measures. The pizza speaks for itself. Overall great experience, get down here if you haven’t already.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dennis Adams
This place has the foundation to be a great place for thin crust pizza. The sauce and cheese balance flavor was great. Let me preface this with saying the rest. I enjoy a pizza with a char or crisp crust. There's a saying it's not burnt it's well done. Iin this case it's a bit beyond char. This is just burnt crust in most places. The image of the garlic bread really details the burntness. On the left you can see a good crisp char on the right you see it's clearly burnt bread. The pizza has the same issue some minor char but mostly just a burnt black crust.
Get that char balance figured out and you've got a great contender for thin crust pizza in the area
A great a pie!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
From the beginning every pizza I ordered was amazing. Truly. Perfectly cooked. Great taste. Visually stunning. But now…. Idk what has happened. In only a short time it’s already gone down hill. I don’t get it. Two times ago I ordered pizza and it was straight burnt. Like inedible. I thought they were having an off day. Although to be honest I’ve worked in restaurants my entire life and if you see you desecrated a pizza you start over. Not serve it to a customer who’s paying top dollar. They’re quite pricey which normally is a non issue bc I’d rather pay more for an amazing pizza than less for a pile of junk. The last time I got the pizza it was undercook and flabby. Again I thought .. maybe they were so busy they weren’t paying attention. Or maybe bc it was earlier in the day and the ovens weren’t hot enough yet. Either way I’ve had it enough times to chalk it up as a fluke. So today I decide to order it again. I even told the girl taking the order about the last two times I ordered and how I’d really appreciate it if they could make sure it was done correctly. Charred but not burnt and not undercooked. She was very sweet and said absolutely I know exactly what you mean. Ok perfect! I go and pick up my pizza and not only is it not cooked correctly, but it looks as if it was made last night. You know how pizza looks the next day. It didn’t look fresh. The cheese wasn’t melty. It wasn’t even warm. It sincerely looked like a pizza they made the day before and saved it for the next day not wanting to throw it away wasting $$. It wasn’t cheesy but dry. The crust looked like it was cooked ok but just by the skin of its teeth. It’s nothing like it used to be. Idk if they’re cutting corners or have a new cook but they need to go back to the original way bc this is not good. And again, they’re on the expensive side. $17 for a small pizza is a lot of money. It’s bread sauce and cheese. I got half pepperoni. But still, that should be like $12. I don’t mind paying more when it’s delicious but this was something I coulda gotten anywhere. It’s too bad bc they used to be amazing. I don’t enjoy writing bad reviews but I’m really bummed. And the pictures they post on the Wallingford fb forum always look so amazing. Every pie that leaves the building should look like those photos. We eat with our eyes first so when something doesn’t look right it automatically tells your brain it isn’t good. I gave it 3 stars bc I know what it could be and what it once was but if I based it solely off todays plus the last 2
visits they would have gotten 1 ⭐️. I tried to give them a fair chance to recover but this is now 3 strikes. Please do better. You were the best around. It’s very disappointing
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 4
Small joint amazing pizza gotta get it!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
One of the top pizzerias in the state! If you haven't tried Inferno Apizza it's a must!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Just tried this spot for the first time. Ordered the fresh tomato and the eggplant special pie. Both pies were cooked extremely well, perfect for New Haven style. The prices are a bit high for what I would call a medium size pizza (16” large). Also, there was a lack of taste… just bland. It’s like there wasn’t enough garlic or oregano just overall taste to the pizza. I had high hopes when I saw the pies and how good they looked. The taste wasn’t there though. Probably won’t go back but I hope they continue and figure things out better. They definitely know how to cook a pie.
I got 2 medium pies. 1 sausage and 1 mushroom and spinach.
the pies were cooked perfectly. crispy and the sauce and cheese were excellent. the toppings were fresh and not from cans. the sausage was real deal Italian. highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Quite possibly the worst tasting pizza I’ve ever had.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
Super good new haven style pizza. Had a roni/bacon and it was FANTASTIC. Not an eat in joint best for pick up.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 3
New Haven style pizza!! Small place, but a killer pie! No Subs?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Absolutely amazing pizza!!! This hidden gem is off the charts!! So glad it is in Wallingford! A must try !!!
Restaurantji Recommends
Hidden gem in Wallingford! Fantastic pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I tried your Pepperoni pizza, little sweet n little spice..OMG, this was cooked perfectly and tasted amazing!
I’m not a spicy eater but the honey with the mild spice hit the spot! I usually get mozzarella pizza, but this time I tried the Pepperoni sweet n spicy, I’m so happy I did!
I will be back for more, thank you.
Mary Ann
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: House Salad, Plain Pizza
This is some great New Haven style pizza. Tonight was our first night trying them and we will definitely be going back.
Mandy and Tommy
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I’ve known Mike for a long time now, and know how much he puts into Inferno. His work ethic is immeasurable, and the pride he takes in his craft speaks measures. The pizza speaks for itself. Overall great experience, get down here if you haven’t already.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place has the foundation to be a great place for thin crust pizza. The sauce and cheese balance flavor was great.
Let me preface this with saying the rest. I enjoy a pizza with a char or crisp crust.
There's a saying it's not burnt it's well done. Iin this case it's a bit beyond char. This is just burnt crust in most places.
The image of the garlic bread really details the burntness. On the left you can see a good crisp char on the right you see it's clearly burnt bread. The pizza has the same issue some minor char but mostly just a burnt black crust.
Get that char balance figured out and you've got a great contender for thin crust pizza in the area
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 5
Loading...