Some tasty pies. Mmmm. My great Nonnie from the old country would approve, capice?Friendly and welcoming staff and nice atmosphere. Recommended.
Scott Palmer
Always have a great meal here. The owner and the staff are like family to one another. Friendly people and great food.✊?????
Joel
First time dining in, always get pizza to go and can barely get home before eating all my share, but today we had the alla vodka and ravioli entrees. Delicious as always, this is the only way I get out of making sauce on the weekends. Thanks guys, love coming here.
Adam Quinn
Ate here for the first time with the family last week and we were shocked about the cost for pizza at this establishment. For 2 pizzas and an appetizer, a small salad and a few drinks it ran us $89.47. The pizza we ordered was one featured in the reviews online however we were charged $4.00 for each topping including the cheese. Since when are we charging extra for cheese? We couldn’t respond to the owners lovely stay off Google reply so we edited our review. Your staff did tell us we don’t make the prices. We paid our bill as we would never not do that to a business. All we were stating was no pizza should cost $29. $4 per topping no matter what it is, is wild. Your staff was very nice, but your pizza is way to expensive. At the end of the day that’s what it was about, pizza is bread and cheese. It’s not complex. We brought our gripe to the counter when paying our bill and that’s what we were told, we don’t make the prices. We understand prices are up, everyone feels it. But $29 for one pizza is beyond steep. We edited our review after your lovely “stay off Google” comment. That’s why Google exists, for fair reviews. It’s 2022, this is where your business is reviewed not via a phone call. If you can’t take a review maybe don’t be on Google as a business. Our family is business owners themselves and we would never rudely respond the way your owner did to us. The food was great but we won’t stray from our go to pizza place in town ever again. Lesson learned!
Pamela Tramontano
great pies! frequently choose them over all!
Cheri Herald
I tried Natalie’s Pizza. Finally, after living in Wallingford for over 35 years, I found a place in town that knows how to make a good pizza. The Elm City was simple but delicious.
Chris Strahowski
Great pizza, but not just pizza. All the dishes are excellent. It might be the new go-to for pizza and casual dining.
ME Sutton
Ordered two scrumptious pizzas last night! Absolutely delicious and cooked to perfection! The crust is the best!
Barbara Ann
Cute and super clean little place definitely worth trying out! The pizza has a nice, thin, and flavorful crust, the sauce is light and flavorful as well, with a fair amount of toppings.
Burton P Vitale
Last night we found a hidden gem of a apizza restaurant. Natalie's of Wallingford makes pies worthy of being called New Haven style. Family owned everyone was pitching in from grandfather to granddaughter, in between doing homework.I would compare the pies to Zuppardis of West Haven. The toppings were plentiful and tasty. We had a sausage and pepper, The old world,clam with bacon and garlic and an outta this world buffalo chicken. Prices were reasonable for the times, I would highly recommend trying this great apizza shop here in town.
I was extremely sad to see Stella's pizza close, but..... we have a winner people! Yes, Natalie's Apizza has hit the mark for great tasting Italian pizza. The sauce and crust are stand alone in taste and flavor! If you like Greek style this is not for you. Once you try Natalie's Apizza, you will see for yourself!
IRS Medic
With so many incredible choices around, it is hard to stand out. But Natalie's sure does. Beyond. Nothing to improve. Here we have a thin pie. And balanced so, so incredibly well. Real thought went into this. They truly understand how things should be.
Nicholas Gratton
The staff and food is amazing. Very attentive and you can tell they put their passion in their food. Will definitely be returning!
Marissa Tiroletto
The pizza is amazing and the owner and his team are incredible. Highly recommend! One of the best in town!
Reinaldo Galindez
Natalies in Wallingford...i would say one of the best pizza in area.wont change it...ive learned how too do pizza in philly and had my place for years in PR ...but this is way better...
Some tasty pies. Mmmm. My great Nonnie from the old country would approve, capice?Friendly and welcoming staff and nice atmosphere. Recommended.
Always have a great meal here. The owner and the staff are like family to one another. Friendly people and great food.✊?????
First time dining in, always get pizza to go and can barely get home before eating all my share, but today we had the alla vodka and ravioli entrees. Delicious as always, this is the only way I get out of making sauce on the weekends. Thanks guys, love coming here.
Ate here for the first time with the family last week and we were shocked about the cost for pizza at this establishment. For 2 pizzas and an appetizer, a small salad and a few drinks it ran us $89.47. The pizza we ordered was one featured in the reviews online however we were charged $4.00 for each topping including the cheese. Since when are we charging extra for cheese? We couldn’t respond to the owners lovely stay off Google reply so we edited our review. Your staff did tell us we don’t make the prices. We paid our bill as we would never not do that to a business. All we were stating was no pizza should cost $29. $4 per topping no matter what it is, is wild. Your staff was very nice, but your pizza is way to expensive. At the end of the day that’s what it was about, pizza is bread and cheese. It’s not complex. We brought our gripe to the counter when paying our bill and that’s what we were told, we don’t make the prices. We understand prices are up, everyone feels it. But $29 for one pizza is beyond steep. We edited our review after your lovely “stay off Google” comment. That’s why Google exists, for fair reviews. It’s 2022, this is where your business is reviewed not via a phone call. If you can’t take a review maybe don’t be on Google as a business. Our family is business owners themselves and we would never rudely respond the way your owner did to us. The food was great but we won’t stray from our go to pizza place in town ever again. Lesson learned!
great pies! frequently choose them over all!
I tried Natalie’s Pizza. Finally, after living in Wallingford for over 35 years, I found a place in town that knows how to make a good pizza. The Elm City was simple but delicious.
Great pizza, but not just pizza. All the dishes are excellent. It might be the new go-to for pizza and casual dining.
Ordered two scrumptious pizzas last night! Absolutely delicious and cooked to perfection! The crust is the best!
Cute and super clean little place definitely worth trying out! The pizza has a nice, thin, and flavorful crust, the sauce is light and flavorful as well, with a fair amount of toppings.
Last night we found a hidden gem of a apizza restaurant. Natalie's of Wallingford makes pies worthy of being called New Haven style. Family owned everyone was pitching in from grandfather to granddaughter, in between doing homework.I would compare the pies to Zuppardis of West Haven. The toppings were plentiful and tasty. We had a sausage and pepper, The old world,clam with bacon and garlic and an outta this world buffalo chicken. Prices were reasonable for the times, I would highly recommend trying this great apizza shop here in town.
Restaurantji Recommends
I was extremely sad to see Stella's pizza close, but..... we have a winner people! Yes, Natalie's Apizza has hit the mark for great tasting Italian pizza. The sauce and crust are stand alone in taste and flavor! If you like Greek style this is not for you. Once you try Natalie's Apizza, you will see for yourself!
With so many incredible choices around, it is hard to stand out. But Natalie's sure does. Beyond. Nothing to improve. Here we have a thin pie. And balanced so, so incredibly well. Real thought went into this. They truly understand how things should be.
The staff and food is amazing. Very attentive and you can tell they put their passion in their food. Will definitely be returning!
The pizza is amazing and the owner and his team are incredible. Highly recommend! One of the best in town!
Natalies in Wallingford...i would say one of the best pizza in area.wont change it...ive learned how too do pizza in philly and had my place for years in PR ...but this is way better...
Loading...