My husband and my family including myself have been customers to restaurant for a couple of years now. Wouldn’t change it for anyone else. The owner and his wife are amazing. His daughters are very courteous. The food delicious. When I get my old colony craving I call them up and they deliver. Fresh, hot or cold. U must try this place. One of my favorites when I want to shed some pounds is my special spring salad, which his wife makes for me. Thank you for being great people to your customers.Dietary restrictions: Ask the chef. They meet ur needsParking: Awesome. Plenty of it
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Steak Bomb, Chicken Cutlet, Onion Rings, Chicken Cutlet Sub, Penne Vodka, Steak, Grilled Chicken, Meatlovers Pizza, Loaded Wrap, Margarita Pizza, Colony Works Pizza, Old Colony Pizza, Steak and Cheese, Pizza with Real Cheese and Sauce, Pepperoni Pizza, Subs, Cheese Pizza, Vegetarian Pizza
Ralph Davila
Really good food you have to try them.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
R Money
Really good pizza, nice, friendly, people. Excellent customer service! Give this place a 5+ Stars!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Old Colony Pizza
Lindsey L.
Excellent service always in person and on the phone. We ate inside and the buffalo chicken salad was one of the best I've ever had!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sarah Sagnella
Such great food especially for the price. Everytime we order we can not believe our portions and how amazing it all tastes! We try something new almost every order. This is a hidden gem in town and more people need to check it out!
D Richello
Always great no matter what we get, pizza, pasta, sandwiches all service with a smileKid-friendliness: We have taken our grandchildren there and the staff is very accommodating and remembers allergy restrictions.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatlovers Pizza, Old Colony Pizza
Nikki J.
I have become tired of New Haven style pizza. This led me to a search for something that was more NY style. I was going through Wallingford on my way home and stopped to get a Spinach/Pepperoni pie. I was pleased with the size of the Medium, and it fulfilled my wishes for the kind of pie I grew up with. I can't wait to get back and try some of their house combos.
John B.
I am New Haven grown so pizza , thin crust pizza is a favorite of mineToo much oil ants me , low grade cheese is disgusting and adds to the oilWe purchased three slices of cheese and several knotsI had to take a quick picture before it was all gone And on top of good food , family operated they are open on Mondays!! Try it you'll like it
Khraig Schupp
I entered with no expectations and left with a want to return.I was somewhat shocked when I went to place my order, and I was told the pizza cook was out on a delivery. Being a Sous Chef myself, I'm fully aware of the industry's struggle right now. 5 stars for the struggle.The restaurant is clean, and the staff was super friendly. I don't have a single complaint , which says a lot from my other reviews.I will return in the future to try other pies besides the vegetarian pizza. Most likely the meat lovers. Stay tuned for more pictures and videos.Vegetarian options: Veg pizza is phenomenal!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Greg G.
I am always looking for a new place to eat. Found one today! Tried a mozzarella pie here and it was good! The crust was perfectly crunchy and thin, the sauce was not too sweet but nice and the cheese was generous! I forgot to take a picture but I plan on doing that next time! The staff was extremely friendly. Great conversations while I waited for my lunch. I love finding these types of spots that are usually only spoiling the local crowd!
Very good pizza, for non wood fired. I typically only go for wood fired/brick oven pizza as i personally just like it better, but i have wanted to try these guys for a while. Very good stuff, we will be ordering again! Sauce and cheese are just right. Friendly staff.
Food: 4
Service: 5
Brianna Collin
Deliver handled well but I did not receive dressing for my Ceasar salad....sooooo do you not give dressings with your salads? Was more than confused. So. Now I have a dry Ceasar salad. Pretty bummed. Pizza was phenomenal
shoshana pursley
As anyone from the area knows, there are A LOT of pizza places. We tried Old Colony for the first time and it's definitely my new favorite. Have only tried the pizza, so far, but we can't wait to try everything else they offer!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Cheese Pizza
gary y
Gary YaleTry Old Colony Pizza in Tracy part of WallyWorld. Victor and Family are the best little Family owned eating place tucked away that you probably drive by it everyday in Tracy and not know it's even there. They Make the Best Lunch Specials along with making his own Fresh Crispy Hard and Sub Rolls on Sundays? (You Must Call ahead for large orders and he will make them for you) and they are Good Sized. I not saying his Pizza is the best like a NH one but not bad either. Their Pizza is a Thin Crust Pie. But people have different tastes especially for Pizza and toppings so that's really hard to judge. Just tell him how you like your Food Prepared with all the fixings and he will make it that way just for you. He offers about a Pound of Fries or Onion Rings for Only extra $1 on Some of his Specials.. Can't Beat that. He just doesn't do Pizza. He does Soups, Wraps, Breakfast, Sandwiches, Slices, Pizza Bites, Salads, Stuffed Breads, Hot Dogs, Burgers, Dessert. His Menu has All kinds of items. and best of all they do deliver or Door Dash, Grub Hub. Check out their Web-Site and order on line. Gotta go and try it you'll be Surprised. Very Reasonable Priced too. Just google Old Colony Pizza for Menu. Old Colony Pizza in Tracy next to the Laundromat. Tell them Gary Told you about them.....?
Derek Strasheim
Great Food with a great variety for any meal! Affordable and great pricing with that homemade taste! Highly recommend for catering an event or family function!!Kid-friendliness: Great family dining experience.Wheelchair accessibility: Easily accessible for all.
My husband and my family including myself have been customers to restaurant for a couple of years now. Wouldn’t change it for anyone else. The owner and his wife are amazing. His daughters are very courteous. The food delicious. When I get my old colony craving I call them up and they deliver. Fresh, hot or cold. U must try this place. One of my favorites when I want to shed some pounds is my special spring salad, which his wife makes for me. Thank you for being great people to your customers.Dietary restrictions: Ask the chef. They meet ur needsParking: Awesome. Plenty of it
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Steak Bomb, Chicken Cutlet, Onion Rings, Chicken Cutlet Sub, Penne Vodka, Steak, Grilled Chicken, Meatlovers Pizza, Loaded Wrap, Margarita Pizza, Colony Works Pizza, Old Colony Pizza, Steak and Cheese, Pizza with Real Cheese and Sauce, Pepperoni Pizza, Subs, Cheese Pizza, Vegetarian Pizza
Really good food you have to try them.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Really good pizza, nice, friendly, people. Excellent customer service! Give this place a 5+ Stars!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Old Colony Pizza
Excellent service always in person and on the phone. We ate inside and the buffalo chicken salad was one of the best I've ever had!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Such great food especially for the price. Everytime we order we can not believe our portions and how amazing it all tastes! We try something new almost every order. This is a hidden gem in town and more people need to check it out!
Always great no matter what we get, pizza, pasta, sandwiches all service with a smileKid-friendliness: We have taken our grandchildren there and the staff is very accommodating and remembers allergy restrictions.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatlovers Pizza, Old Colony Pizza
I have become tired of New Haven style pizza. This led me to a search for something that was more NY style. I was going through Wallingford on my way home and stopped to get a Spinach/Pepperoni pie. I was pleased with the size of the Medium, and it fulfilled my wishes for the kind of pie I grew up with. I can't wait to get back and try some of their house combos.
I am New Haven grown so pizza , thin crust pizza is a favorite of mineToo much oil ants me , low grade cheese is disgusting and adds to the oilWe purchased three slices of cheese and several knotsI had to take a quick picture before it was all gone And on top of good food , family operated they are open on Mondays!! Try it you'll like it
I entered with no expectations and left with a want to return.I was somewhat shocked when I went to place my order, and I was told the pizza cook was out on a delivery. Being a Sous Chef myself, I'm fully aware of the industry's struggle right now. 5 stars for the struggle.The restaurant is clean, and the staff was super friendly. I don't have a single complaint , which says a lot from my other reviews.I will return in the future to try other pies besides the vegetarian pizza. Most likely the meat lovers. Stay tuned for more pictures and videos.Vegetarian options: Veg pizza is phenomenal!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
I am always looking for a new place to eat. Found one today! Tried a mozzarella pie here and it was good! The crust was perfectly crunchy and thin, the sauce was not too sweet but nice and the cheese was generous! I forgot to take a picture but I plan on doing that next time! The staff was extremely friendly. Great conversations while I waited for my lunch. I love finding these types of spots that are usually only spoiling the local crowd!
Restaurantji Recommends
Very good pizza, for non wood fired. I typically only go for wood fired/brick oven pizza as i personally just like it better, but i have wanted to try these guys for a while. Very good stuff, we will be ordering again! Sauce and cheese are just right. Friendly staff.
Food: 4
Service: 5
Deliver handled well but I did not receive dressing for my Ceasar salad....sooooo do you not give dressings with your salads? Was more than confused. So. Now I have a dry Ceasar salad. Pretty bummed. Pizza was phenomenal
As anyone from the area knows, there are A LOT of pizza places. We tried Old Colony for the first time and it's definitely my new favorite. Have only tried the pizza, so far, but we can't wait to try everything else they offer!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Cheese Pizza
Gary YaleTry Old Colony Pizza in Tracy part of WallyWorld. Victor and Family are the best little Family owned eating place tucked away that you probably drive by it everyday in Tracy and not know it's even there. They Make the Best Lunch Specials along with making his own Fresh Crispy Hard and Sub Rolls on Sundays? (You Must Call ahead for large orders and he will make them for you) and they are Good Sized. I not saying his Pizza is the best like a NH one but not bad either. Their Pizza is a Thin Crust Pie. But people have different tastes especially for Pizza and toppings so that's really hard to judge. Just tell him how you like your Food Prepared with all the fixings and he will make it that way just for you. He offers about a Pound of Fries or Onion Rings for Only extra $1 on Some of his Specials.. Can't Beat that. He just doesn't do Pizza. He does Soups, Wraps, Breakfast, Sandwiches, Slices, Pizza Bites, Salads, Stuffed Breads, Hot Dogs, Burgers, Dessert. His Menu has All kinds of items. and best of all they do deliver or Door Dash, Grub Hub. Check out their Web-Site and order on line. Gotta go and try it you'll be Surprised. Very Reasonable Priced too. Just google Old Colony Pizza for Menu. Old Colony Pizza in Tracy next to the Laundromat. Tell them Gary Told you about them.....?
Great Food with a great variety for any meal! Affordable and great pricing with that homemade taste! Highly recommend for catering an event or family function!!Kid-friendliness: Great family dining experience.Wheelchair accessibility: Easily accessible for all.