The New Haven Pizza Co
747 Wolcott Rd, Wolcott
(203) 879-8800
Customers' Favorites
Baked Stuffed Shrimp Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Mashed Potato Bacon
Chicken Parmigiana
Eggplant Rollatini
Margherita Pizza
Menu
Photos
+27 photos
+26 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Food is honestly amazing. From the stuffed shells, to their homemade meatballs; their cauliflower crust is awesome, and so is their stuffed shrimp pizza. Sounded weird to me and everyone said I must try it..: wow… they were right!! We are guilty of eating here 4 times in past 9 days ?. My kids love it and I’m PICKY with pizza and Italian food especially growing up in Connecticut. Great place and the staff is always accommodating. Thank you
Crust- 8.2
Cheese- 8.3
Sauce- 8.2
The cheese was oily but had some good flavor. Could’ve used less overall.
The sauce was slightly sweet. Perfect amount of sauce throughout each slice.
Crust was also a bit oily and lacked flavor. Undercarriage was decent but had flop. Parts of the crust were uneven, some were doughy and some were crunchy.
Cheese- 8.3
Sauce- 8.2
The cheese was oily but had some good flavor. Could’ve used less overall.
The sauce was slightly sweet. Perfect amount of sauce throughout each slice.
Crust was also a bit oily and lacked flavor. Undercarriage was decent but had flop. Parts of the crust were uneven, some were doughy and some were crunchy.
This pizza is excellent!! My husband and I just moved to Wolcott a month ago and have yet to find decent pizza in the area. Him being from NY is very particular about the type of pizza he eats. Standing ovation from us!! We ate it all before we were able to take a photo! But we ordered a large 1/2 pepperoni and 1/2 anchovies. We will be back.
