Being out of town, never know what to expect from the local beach pizza place.....it was very very good! Similar to a slice in NYC minus the copper water lmao. Delicious and we'd easily come back!Dietary restrictions: They have gluten free option for crust!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Pizza, Caesar Salad, Prosciutto and Arugula Pizza, Beef & Blue Pizza
Paul Martindale
Enjoyed the food and wine we had. Limited seating was available. We had a good seat because it was not crowded.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizzas, Meat Balls
Beth Binder
Best pizza and meatballs…food is so fresh, well prepared and the variety of pizzas is fabulous. Highly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sal Cannizzo
Pizza is very good and lots of options. However, there were some less-than-satisfactory aspects of the meal. We ordered a Willow Special that was supposed to have pesto, Italian sausage, mozzarella and sopressata. There was no pesto; instead, there were dried, cooked kale leaves. We were not informed of this substitution. We asked for dinner plates, because all that was provided when we sat down were tiny bread & butter plates. We were told there were no dinner plates, not even salad plates. This wasn't conveyed to us in an apologetic "sorry for the inconvenience" way, but rather in a matter-of-fact "take it or leave it/that's just the way it is" manner. We had to struggle to eat our pizza and salad on these tiny plates. We observed that the pizzas were served on long, rectangular plates, and asked if we could have some extra of those, but were told "no, these are only for serving pizzas." We pointed out that it was almost closing time and the restaurant was nearly empty, so couldn't they spare a few of those plates? The answer was "no." It seems the customer is NOT always right at Pie. We love the pizza, but at this point are unsure if we will ever go back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 2
Kinza Chaudhry
We ordered margherita, and goat cheese, and artichoke pizza. I would say the goat cheese was slightly better. The ricotta and chocolate pie was really good!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
Michael Graeff
The pizza and key lime pie were great. Orange and Lemon Crush's were good staff was helpful and friendly. It was a little noisy for only being half filled. All around good experience though.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizzas
michelle denicola
A few vegan options, the pizza was yummy, the salads were fresh and the garlic bread was great. The restaurant was homey and welcoming.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Andy Lomax
Waited 5 min for the hostess to stop chatting with a waiter to even be acknowledged. Then waited 15 min after being seated...my wife TRYING to make eye contact with any wait staff...before we walked out. They weren't that busy - plenty of open tables - but clearly they didn't want any more customers. Too bad, the pizza looked good on other people's plates... (And this wasn't an aberration...the table next to us also waited a long time for wait staff to show up)
Service: 1
Brian Q.
Good food but a bit pricey for pizza. Guess that's what you have to expect by the Beach area.
For what was billed as best pizza in Bethany, we were very disappointed. No pepperoni!...No iced tea...pizza was incredibly greasy and service was slow and disinterested. Will be trying other pizza places in the future in Bethany.
JayCeeDE
We are “locals” and always eat pizza on Fridays. The PIE website indicates if open or not. We have driven there numerous times and although web site says it is open; it is NOT. This has happened enough times that we no longer bother . . . .
Adam Hochman
Went there over summer with family. Reasonably priced really good pizza (interesting topics), good salads and relaxed vibe. Only complaint is wish they were open more hours.
Lisa C.
Really good pizza with some unique specialty pizzas. They have GF crust available, which is your typical bland one, nothing special. But the delicious toppings and flavor make all the difference, and they definitely didn't skimp on the toppings. We had 3 different pizzas and they were all very tasty. We ordered when they first opened and it was ready very quickly.
Andrew Super
This has become our go-to spot for takeout pizza in Bethany. It’s always good, pizzas combos are interesting and always tasty, and their salads and appetizers meatballs are great. Love Pie!
Very good food and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Being out of town, never know what to expect from the local beach pizza place.....it was very very good! Similar to a slice in NYC minus the copper water lmao. Delicious and we'd easily come back!Dietary restrictions: They have gluten free option for crust!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Pizza, Caesar Salad, Prosciutto and Arugula Pizza, Beef & Blue Pizza
Enjoyed the food and wine we had. Limited seating was available. We had a good seat because it was not crowded.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizzas, Meat Balls
Best pizza and meatballs…food is so fresh, well prepared and the variety of pizzas is fabulous. Highly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza is very good and lots of options. However, there were some less-than-satisfactory aspects of the meal. We ordered a Willow Special that was supposed to have pesto, Italian sausage, mozzarella and sopressata. There was no pesto; instead, there were dried, cooked kale leaves. We were not informed of this substitution. We asked for dinner plates, because all that was provided when we sat down were tiny bread & butter plates. We were told there were no dinner plates, not even salad plates. This wasn't conveyed to us in an apologetic "sorry for the inconvenience" way, but rather in a matter-of-fact "take it or leave it/that's just the way it is" manner. We had to struggle to eat our pizza and salad on these tiny plates. We observed that the pizzas were served on long, rectangular plates, and asked if we could have some extra of those, but were told "no, these are only for serving pizzas." We pointed out that it was almost closing time and the restaurant was nearly empty, so couldn't they spare a few of those plates? The answer was "no." It seems the customer is NOT always right at Pie. We love the pizza, but at this point are unsure if we will ever go back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 2
We ordered margherita, and goat cheese, and artichoke pizza. I would say the goat cheese was slightly better. The ricotta and chocolate pie was really good!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
The pizza and key lime pie were great. Orange and Lemon Crush's were good staff was helpful and friendly. It was a little noisy for only being half filled. All around good experience though.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizzas
A few vegan options, the pizza was yummy, the salads were fresh and the garlic bread was great. The restaurant was homey and welcoming.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Waited 5 min for the hostess to stop chatting with a waiter to even be acknowledged. Then waited 15 min after being seated...my wife TRYING to make eye contact with any wait staff...before we walked out. They weren't that busy - plenty of open tables - but clearly they didn't want any more customers. Too bad, the pizza looked good on other people's plates... (And this wasn't an aberration...the table next to us also waited a long time for wait staff to show up)
Service: 1
Good food but a bit pricey for pizza. Guess that's what you have to expect by the Beach area.
Restaurantji Recommends
For what was billed as best pizza in Bethany, we were very disappointed. No pepperoni!...No iced tea...pizza was incredibly greasy and service was slow and disinterested. Will be trying other pizza places in the future in Bethany.
We are “locals” and always eat pizza on Fridays. The PIE website indicates if open or not. We have driven there numerous times and although web site says it is open; it is NOT. This has happened enough times that we no longer bother . . . .
Went there over summer with family. Reasonably priced really good pizza (interesting topics), good salads and relaxed vibe. Only complaint is wish they were open more hours.
Really good pizza with some unique specialty pizzas. They have GF crust available, which is your typical bland one, nothing special. But the delicious toppings and flavor make all the difference, and they definitely didn't skimp on the toppings. We had 3 different pizzas and they were all very tasty. We ordered when they first opened and it was ready very quickly.
This has become our go-to spot for takeout pizza in Bethany. It’s always good, pizzas combos are interesting and always tasty, and their salads and appetizers meatballs are great. Love Pie!