Idk what ppl are complaining about. I’ll say Don’t travel out of your way to get your pizza from here. But it’s simple and great if you’re staying in Dewey. Or finishing your bar crawl for the night, stopping by, and grabbing a pie on the way back to where you’re staying. Delicious fresh. Not the best left over. 5 stars all the way. It’s what it is. ?
Food: 5
Daniel B.
The worst pizza in the world! Ellios frozen is much better! Save yourself $5 for one slice!
Leslie G.
The service was terrible last night. The woman behind the counter was on the phone and ignored us and we were the only people in there. When she finally took our order she was very rude. I don't need pizza that bad that I would eat it there. It wasn't that good anyway.
Grant Czerwinski
Tried calling numerous times to place an order and they didn't answer. Went through their online ordering system which works ok, then the pizza I got was incorrectly made. I got their "Little Italy" and only got pepperoni and meatballs on it, it was missing half of the ingredients.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 3
Greek Boss
This was by far the nastiest pizza I have ever had in my life. This place definitely only caters to the drunk crowd late night. Went in and ordered a large cheese pizza and they handed one to us not even a minute later. That was the first red flag that it was not even fresh and they just gave us one that’s been sitting around. The cheese around each slice were stuck to the box and when you would try to pull a slice out all the cheese would fall off completely. What a mess. Horrible quality and just horrible food. Should have looked up the reviews before going. I miss the old run down building that actually had great pizza here! Never again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jet13663410933
The pizza was a terrible cardboard crust with a watered down sauce. Mama Celeste's Father would be rolling over in his grave !!!
Clarissa V.
Who is mad at this pizza?!?! It's great pizza especially at night. And they're fast. No nonsense. It's cheese or pepperoni. That's it. Take your pick, sprinkle your stuff and get out. The boys don't want you to burn your mouth but who cares you eat it hot while you're walking and it's amazing. Goes well after drinking and dancing at Starboard
Robert Mitchell
Unfortunately I should have gone home and made a freezer pizza. We waited 15 minutes for 3 premade slices that were heated up under a lamp. Maybe good for a stop after the bar where you couldn’t care less about what it tastes like.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Louie Jacobs
Terrible pizza. Horrible customer experience. Needs a renovation again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Matthew Shea
Exceptionally bad pizza. Staff was glued to their phones and didn’t look up for over a minute after walking into the shop. Better off getting a frozen from the nearest drug store.
Pizza was horrible and lukewarm even after waiting for it. All employees were on their phones and wouldn’t walk up to the counter. I don’t leave reviews let alone bad reviews but this was a pretty sad piece of pizza.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Steve McCloskey
Much nicer inside now. But I miss the dirty store with the good pizza. With one of the former proprietors working there, how does the pizza suddenly become garbage?
Food: 1
Alex M.
Straight up booty juice. I can't believe this place replaced Mama Celeste. This is as bad as pizza can get.
830susannet
Ordered a large cheese pizza around 9:00 pm and had to wait 30 mins. It was busy so no big deal. The pizza was tasty but way too salty and greasy! With some tweaks this place will be good. And for those asking for Mama to come back, she is still there making the pizzas.
Eric Hutchison
Perfect for what it is, drunk bar pie. Does the job.
Idk what ppl are complaining about. I’ll say Don’t travel out of your way to get your pizza from here. But it’s simple and great if you’re staying in Dewey. Or finishing your bar crawl for the night, stopping by, and grabbing a pie on the way back to where you’re staying. Delicious fresh. Not the best left over. 5 stars all the way. It’s what it is. ?
Food: 5
The worst pizza in the world! Ellios frozen is much better! Save yourself $5 for one slice!
The service was terrible last night. The woman behind the counter was on the phone and ignored us and we were the only people in there. When she finally took our order she was very rude. I don't need pizza that bad that I would eat it there. It wasn't that good anyway.
Tried calling numerous times to place an order and they didn't answer. Went through their online ordering system which works ok, then the pizza I got was incorrectly made. I got their "Little Italy" and only got pepperoni and meatballs on it, it was missing half of the ingredients.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 3
This was by far the nastiest pizza I have ever had in my life. This place definitely only caters to the drunk crowd late night. Went in and ordered a large cheese pizza and they handed one to us not even a minute later. That was the first red flag that it was not even fresh and they just gave us one that’s been sitting around. The cheese around each slice were stuck to the box and when you would try to pull a slice out all the cheese would fall off completely. What a mess. Horrible quality and just horrible food. Should have looked up the reviews before going. I miss the old run down building that actually had great pizza here! Never again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
The pizza was a terrible cardboard crust with a watered down sauce. Mama Celeste's Father would be rolling over in his grave !!!
Who is mad at this pizza?!?! It's great pizza especially at night. And they're fast. No nonsense. It's cheese or pepperoni. That's it. Take your pick, sprinkle your stuff and get out. The boys don't want you to burn your mouth but who cares you eat it hot while you're walking and it's amazing. Goes well after drinking and dancing at Starboard
Unfortunately I should have gone home and made a freezer pizza. We waited 15 minutes for 3 premade slices that were heated up under a lamp. Maybe good for a stop after the bar where you couldn’t care less about what it tastes like.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Terrible pizza. Horrible customer experience. Needs a renovation again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Exceptionally bad pizza. Staff was glued to their phones and didn’t look up for over a minute after walking into the shop. Better off getting a frozen from the nearest drug store.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Pizza was horrible and lukewarm even after waiting for it. All employees were on their phones and wouldn’t walk up to the counter. I don’t leave reviews let alone bad reviews but this was a pretty sad piece of pizza.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Much nicer inside now. But I miss the dirty store with the good pizza. With one of the former proprietors working there, how does the pizza suddenly become garbage?
Food: 1
Straight up booty juice. I can't believe this place replaced Mama Celeste. This is as bad as pizza can get.
Ordered a large cheese pizza around 9:00 pm and had to wait 30 mins. It was busy so no big deal. The pizza was tasty but way too salty and greasy! With some tweaks this place will be good. And for those asking for Mama to come back, she is still there making the pizzas.
Perfect for what it is, drunk bar pie. Does the job.