The food and wait staff were excellent. The only complaint was that the dining area is small and there was a family of seven that were quite noisy.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Norman Schwartz
New owners doing a great job
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jamal Tarib
We are new to the Middletown DE area, as we just moved from New York, so we were looking for a pizzeria which serves New York style pizzas. Caruso’s pizza was nearest to our new place and had decent reviews. The cashier was new but the owner was besides her helping her. Both of them were courteous and welcoming. They helped me choose the pizza I wanted and it was ready by the promised time. The pizza was good, and as it was a large one, we even saved some for the following day and it did not disappoint. We found our pizza joint and would highly recommend.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Greg Safian
Hands down the best NY style pizza in New Castle County. Even if you don’t live in Middletown, it’s worth the trip. They have a large and unique selection of slices that come out perfectly crispy. Service is great! Our favorite pie to take home is the upside-down square pie add sausage. This place is a must try!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nuvolina
I stopped to have a couple of slices to go and I have to say that the tomatoe Sicilian was really good. The sauce was an actually good one! I'm always looking for nice pizza in the States and when I find one that I would eat again, I have to leave a review!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stephanie Byron
We stopped here while traveling, and so glad we did! It was a quaint place with a great looking menu. Our kids were with us, so we just ordered a pizza. I think I threw them for a loop when I asked for 2 slices without cheese on the pie, but they nailed it! (One kid doesn't like cheese) Also- they do not skimp on the toppings at all. We ordered pepperoni and meatballs and holy moly those meatballs slices were thick! Very impressed on the value of the whole meal. There were others around us whose meals looked delicious. The staff was super friendly and the place was clean.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Haley Roca
I just want to start off with saying your food here is amazing. But your service is absolutely horrible. I’ve been coming here for two years now and Melina is so rude and disrespectful it’s not even okay. She walks around like she always has an attitude every time I come in. When she is irritated she gets snippy with her customers. And that is not only not lady like but not good customer service either.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 1
Dawn Sheehan
Everything was outstanding
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Christopher Donahue
Caruso's is an excellent pizza restaurant and the great Italian cuisine.
Their cannoli dessert is pretty good too.
j z
Unfortunately we are throwing in the towel on this place. Got the 3rd large takeout pie in 4 month period of buying them and again the back crust is decently burned. We didn’t even save a few leftover slices for tomorrow- just tossed them. We gave up on their dinners a while ago - so that’s it for us and this place.
14$ salad was just a shit ton of lettuce & a few pieces of chicken nothing else is ridiculous, step it up
Brandy Davis
The food, service and atmosphere was perfect. True italian dishes made perfect. Italian wedding soup, baked ziti and penne alla vodka were amazing. We have finally found an Italian restaurant near by with delicious food and excellent service!!!
Saundra Ferrara
Perfect location, the waitress was perfect, so kind and quick. The place is decorated perfectly. But unfortunately there were fruit flies like crazy in the restaurant. They were so bad it started to turn us off. The food had flavor, and it would be perfect it it truly wasn't for the flies. The leftovers we ended throwing out because we didn't feel comfortable eating it.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
Diane Pozzi
I took tomatoe pies to a party and everyone raved about it. The fresh basil was a great addition.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tomato Pie
George Pappas Jr
Wasn’t a fan of the owner staring her guests down while they ate. She should have made herself useful and found a new meatball recipe. Not sure if owners changed recently but the food definitely changed for the worse unfortunately
The food and wait staff were excellent. The only complaint was that the dining area is small and there was a family of seven that were quite noisy.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
New owners doing a great job
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
We are new to the Middletown DE area, as we just moved from New York, so we were looking for a pizzeria which serves New York style pizzas. Caruso’s pizza was nearest to our new place and had decent reviews. The cashier was new but the owner was besides her helping her. Both of them were courteous and welcoming. They helped me choose the pizza I wanted and it was ready by the promised time. The pizza was good, and as it was a large one, we even saved some for the following day and it did not disappoint. We found our pizza joint and would highly recommend.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hands down the best NY style pizza in New Castle County. Even if you don’t live in Middletown, it’s worth the trip. They have a large and unique selection of slices that come out perfectly crispy. Service is great! Our favorite pie to take home is the upside-down square pie add sausage. This place is a must try!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I stopped to have a couple of slices to go and I have to say that the tomatoe Sicilian was really good. The sauce was an actually good one!
I'm always looking for nice pizza in the States and when I find one that I would eat again, I have to leave a review!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
We stopped here while traveling, and so glad we did! It was a quaint place with a great looking menu. Our kids were with us, so we just ordered a pizza. I think I threw them for a loop when I asked for 2 slices without cheese on the pie, but they nailed it! (One kid doesn't like cheese) Also- they do not skimp on the toppings at all. We ordered pepperoni and meatballs and holy moly those meatballs slices were thick! Very impressed on the value of the whole meal.
There were others around us whose meals looked delicious. The staff was super friendly and the place was clean.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I just want to start off with saying your food here is amazing. But your service is absolutely horrible. I’ve been coming here for two years now and Melina is so rude and disrespectful it’s not even okay. She walks around like she always has an attitude every time I come in. When she is irritated she gets snippy with her customers. And that is not only not lady like but not good customer service either.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 1
Everything was outstanding
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Caruso's is an excellent pizza restaurant and the great Italian cuisine.
Their cannoli dessert is pretty good too.
Unfortunately we are throwing in the towel on this place. Got the 3rd large takeout pie in 4 month period of buying them and again the back crust is decently burned. We didn’t even save a few leftover slices for tomorrow- just tossed them. We gave up on their dinners a while ago - so that’s it for us and this place.
Restaurantji Recommends
14$ salad was just a shit ton of lettuce & a few pieces of chicken nothing else is ridiculous, step it up
The food, service and atmosphere was perfect. True italian dishes made perfect. Italian wedding soup, baked ziti and penne alla vodka were amazing. We have finally found an Italian restaurant near by with delicious food and excellent service!!!
Perfect location, the waitress was perfect, so kind and quick. The place is decorated perfectly. But unfortunately there were fruit flies like crazy in the restaurant. They were so bad it started to turn us off. The food had flavor, and it would be perfect it it truly wasn't for the flies. The leftovers we ended throwing out because we didn't feel comfortable eating it.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
I took tomatoe pies to a party and everyone raved about it. The fresh basil was a great addition.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tomato Pie
Wasn’t a fan of the owner staring her guests down while they ate. She should have made herself useful and found a new meatball recipe. Not sure if owners changed recently but the food definitely changed for the worse unfortunately
Loading...