Casapulla's Middletown Subs

Superb, excellent, great, epic, amazing service and subs! Delicious.

Just love the place feel like family

I have gone to Casapullas for over 30 years, used to work for DuPont they delivered every week. When they came to Middletown i was excited, advised the owner after twice they made my order wrong. He apologized and gave free sandwiches, I didn't go for awhile, went back again they messed my sandwich up owner had given me his phone # when I told him again he was not interested in hearing about it, have not been there for maybe 2 or 3 years thought I'd try again lol..what was I thinking once again young people they were all having a good time, I get home and again my sandwich was not as I requested, I asked when I called order can you please chop up my steak, I have digestive problems the guy said yes we will, I was optimistic, I get home and the sandwich is not as I requested and advised it would be. Ok lesson learned i will not go back.

Friendly service and tasty as all day!

Great subs as usual.

Price upgrade for travel subs, extra peppers etc, extra for any changes.

Friendly people making your food/ with that said I ordered a steak sandwich with fried onions. This is supposed to be the famous Casapullas? Should be called Steak-umms. These kids knew nothing about making a good steak or weren't told what to do- Good ingredients do help - Chop them onions and meat etc. Not sure about their subs but not going back to get a steak. Yuk!

Amazing place to go. Good food, friendly staff, nice atmosphere. It's a shame we don't have them in southern MD...

I decided to try Casapulla's in Middletown. I have had many really great steak sandwiches in the past, including Casapulla's in Elsmere, in the 70's. I ordered 2 large steak sandwiches w/ fried onions & ketchup on one . After the first bite, I wish I didn't. The onions were undercooked, with skins on them & at least 6 inches long. So, when you bit your sandwich, they pulled out like strings. The cheese was overbearing & not melted. It had ‘Steakum' type meat , that wasn't chopped up like normal steak sandwiches. If you've never had a really good steak sandwich or are starving, you might like it. If this Casapulla's is trying to carry on the legacy, it definitely wasn't with these sandwiches.

Amanda baker makes the best subs and she is very polite