Jersey Mike's Subs

12.24.25 Just picked up some sandwiches from there.

The Black woman at the register did a nice job of relaying what I needed to the fillings topper. They weren't perfect, but they were delish! I stressed them out, but they did a good job. 😂👏🏾

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 3

Great service and food! Subs were awesome and customer service for delivery was great as well!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Darian (not sure if I am spelling her name correctly). She was a HUGE help over the phone with our Jersey Mikes order with DoorDash. GREAT customer service! She accommodated us, so much .. and she answered the phone right away. Thank you :)

Service: 5

Place an order for one sandwich and one salad and was charged for one sandwich and two salads however the cashier did catch it and gave me the refund was good other than that she did catch it and I was grateful she caught it other than this Jersey Mike's is more expensive than subways

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Awesome service! The taller woman with tattoos slicing the meat was super nice and also the gentleman at the register was great also. Sandwich was awesome and atmosphere in store was relaxing.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Everyone that works here is really nice and food is pretty fresh I hate wawa subs

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Well this review is long overdue,
my first time trying jersey mikes was at this location and it’s been a winner every single time I walked in or did door dash. The sandwich’s are amazing and the staff always makes sure to make sure your sandwich is to your exact liking, and the staff are amazing at customer service…

A special thanks to Cherri because she is always, always welcoming me and my family whenever we visit this Jersey Mikes. My only complaint is their sandwiches are so good, I’m subjected to gain weight if I frequent this place because I never want a mini or regular size sandwich, I always order a giant sandwich.

In closing, you can’t lose getting a sandwich from this place, coupled with the amazing staff, you are in for a real treat !

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Zack Pancake was absolutely fantastic! I was feeling indecisive about which sandwich to get, and he helped guide me to a great choice with patience and kindness. His positive attitude and caring personality really stood out.

My wife and I were actually on the way to the hospital and just needed a quick bite to hold us over — something Zack found surprising, but he remained completely focused on being warm, friendly, and helpful. He truly made a difference in our day.

Thank you, Zack! You were right — your last name really is unforgettable.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Wanted to give an updated review a year later to see if they still met my expectations, and they absolutely do. I have gotten a sub delivered to my work place multiple times this week and every time it is quick and JM follows my instructions for what I want on my sub and how much. For example, i always ask for exactly two tomatoes to be put on my sub for no reason at all, but they always follow it. wonderful!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Our chicken cheesesteaks were good, the people were polite and the place was clean. Will definitely go back.

Absolutely not! The food is always thrown together. Half the items we requested on our subs was missing. There was barely any meat on the cheesesteaks. This place is too pricey for the food and service to be this lackluster.

My family and I ordered subs tonight, your staff were absolutely amazing. Gluten free customer, truly appreciate your team making my sandwich with ensuring no cross contamination in front of me. I was never made to feel like I was a bother requesting gluten free sandwich. They made my sandwich, then my families non gluten free with grace and quickness. Truly thank you, it’s hard to eat out being gluten free, my meal tonight I was not worried with eating my sandwich. Thank you, for being so graceful and accommodating. Awesome team tonight.

I’ve been eating here for lunch during my breaks for over 2 years and all I have to say is this place is amazing! Staff is always nice and professional. The inside is always clean and the food is spot on. The freshly made bread everyday really makes them. Has to be one of the best sub spots in MiddleTown! Definitely give this place a try!

How hard is it to order a regular Italian cold cut without tomatoes 🍅 ? Easy right? We'll not at this location. Regardless the the was good, young man behind counter was very professional.

All i'm going to say is you can not go wrong with jersey Mike's. These sandwiches are always delicious and Juicy. The veggies are fresh, and the bread is soft. It's a good quick order and go spot. You can't go wrong with the cheese steak sub