This is a real human here - not some spam bot (leaving bad reviews). Straight up - best pizzas I've had anywhere in the US. *** Consistently. Have never left a review in my life - but the quality of my past orders, and seeing a bunch of Trolls leaving negative reviews, has prompted me to leave one. This particular location works magic in their little 700sf of a work shop! I'd honestly rate these guys an A to A+.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Reneé C.
This location is really hit and miss when it comes to accuracy. For example, this particular papadilla in the photo was supposed to be no bell peppers, and where’s the meat?? For whatever reason they are ALWAYS out of all dessert; out of the several times I’ve ordered dessert they only had it twice and one of the 2 times they only had the new salted Carmel brownie, which I took as a replacement and it was not bad. Food usually tastes good though and service is fast, I’ve never had to wait for my pizza after arriving.
Food: 3
Service: 3
Haroon
I called this place and place an order or 2 large pizza 50% off the lady who took my order was nice and friendly. I asked her the total she said 20.99 I went to pick up the pizza and the price went up to 23.99 I asked the guy that I talked to the lady over the phone and confirmed the price why it's now 23.99 can you call her out and confirm with her. I guess that hurt his EGO and he refused to call her and insist me buying at 23.99. very rude attitude so I walk out. Never again
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Scott Goldstein
Horrible pizza and expensive
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Susan Hanna
Pizza tastes good but not consistent with the amount of cheese or sauce used.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
baker5900
Ordered last night for an impromptu family gathering. Within 60 seconds of my order going through using the app, I was called directly from the store and a friendly female staff member informed me that they were out of one of my selected toppings. An alternate topping was selected, the young lady apologized again for the inconvenience and my daughter headed to the store to pick up our pizzas. Order of 6 pizzas with 10 various topping arrangements were made quickly and correctly. Our usual PJ's location has closed so we will definitely be using this one again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mark Miller
The pizza wasn't fresh. Price way to high
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 3
Jeff R.
I decided to stop at Papa John’s in Middletown to get the Shaq pizza or they call it Shaq a Toni. The service was good. The personnel was very courteous and helpful. The pepperoni pizza was very delicious .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
george collins
The service was great and the turnaround time of my order completion was good it was the outcome of one of my pizzas that was the issue. I ordered a half and half well done pizza.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
google user
Tiniest wings around. It’s like they pick the smallest available just for you!
This has to be the slowest pizza place ever! Don't order from here unless you have two hours to kill and want a cold pizza and the wrong drinks when it arrives.
Food: 2
Service: 2
Shane L.
Closed at noon on a Saturday for some reason, website still let us pay though. Dirty inside
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Kevin Patel
ordered delivery 2 times and take out 1 time in last 3 week. first time ordering delivery we waited 1.5 hrs only to have to call the store and find out the driver gave our order to the wrong house and they had to remake it. the second time we order the following week the delivery driver forgot 1 of the 3 items we ordered. the last time we ordered take out in hopes there will not be any issues. we got 2 new york style pizzas and wings. wings barely had any sauce on them, even though both pizzas were the same one was thicker than the other. both pizza only had cheese on half of the pie.
not ordering from here anymore
save yourself the anger!!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Eddie Hammon
Can’t order online then called number to order on phone after many tries finally got a rep at call center many delays finally made order then had to retry card. Then rep hung up. Could NOT reach again by phone
p marshall
I ordered 3 items but was given 2 pizzas instead of what I ordered. I called the manager, he refused to fix the problem and hung up. I will never call them again
This is a real human here - not some spam bot (leaving bad reviews). Straight up - best pizzas I've had anywhere in the US. *** Consistently. Have never left a review in my life - but the quality of my past orders, and seeing a bunch of Trolls leaving negative reviews, has prompted me to leave one. This particular location works magic in their little 700sf of a work shop! I'd honestly rate these guys an A to A+.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This location is really hit and miss when it comes to accuracy. For example, this particular papadilla in the photo was supposed to be no bell peppers, and where’s the meat?? For whatever reason they are ALWAYS out of all dessert; out of the several times I’ve ordered dessert they only had it twice and one of the 2 times they only had the new salted Carmel brownie, which I took as a replacement and it was not bad. Food usually tastes good though and service is fast, I’ve never had to wait for my pizza after arriving.
Food: 3
Service: 3
I called this place and place an order or 2 large pizza 50% off the lady who took my order was nice and friendly. I asked her the total she said 20.99 I went to pick up the pizza and the price went up to 23.99 I asked the guy that I talked to the lady over the phone and confirmed the price why it's now 23.99 can you call her out and confirm with her. I guess that hurt his EGO and he refused to call her and insist me buying at 23.99. very rude attitude so I walk out. Never again
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Horrible pizza and expensive
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Pizza tastes good but not consistent with the amount of cheese or sauce used.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Ordered last night for an impromptu family gathering. Within 60 seconds of my order going through using the app, I was called directly from the store and a friendly female staff member informed me that they were out of one of my selected toppings. An alternate topping was selected, the young lady apologized again for the inconvenience and my daughter headed to the store to pick up our pizzas. Order of 6 pizzas with 10 various topping arrangements were made quickly and correctly. Our usual PJ's location has closed so we will definitely be using this one again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza wasn't fresh. Price way to high
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 3
I decided to stop at Papa John’s in Middletown to get the Shaq pizza or they call it Shaq a Toni.
The service was good. The personnel was very courteous and helpful.
The pepperoni pizza was very delicious .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The service was great and the turnaround time of my order completion was good it was the outcome of one of my pizzas that was the issue. I ordered a half and half well done pizza.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Tiniest wings around. It’s like they pick the smallest available just for you!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
This has to be the slowest pizza place ever! Don't order from here unless you have two hours to kill and want a cold pizza and the wrong drinks when it arrives.
Food: 2
Service: 2
Closed at noon on a Saturday for some reason, website still let us pay though. Dirty inside
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
ordered delivery 2 times and take out 1 time in last 3 week. first time ordering delivery we waited 1.5 hrs only to have to call the store and find out the driver gave our order to the wrong house and they had to remake it. the second time we order the following week the delivery driver forgot 1 of the 3 items we ordered. the last time we ordered take out in hopes there will not be any issues. we got 2 new york style pizzas and wings. wings barely had any sauce on them, even though both pizzas were the same one was thicker than the other. both pizza only had cheese on half of the pie.
not ordering from here anymore
save yourself the anger!!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Can’t order online then called number to order on phone after many tries finally got a rep at call center many delays finally made order then had to retry card. Then rep hung up. Could NOT reach again by phone
I ordered 3 items but was given 2 pizzas instead of what I ordered. I called the manager, he refused to fix the problem and hung up. I will never call them again
Food: 1
Service: 1
Loading...