Incredible tomato pie with the perfect crust, a noticeably delicate light tomato sauce (not overpowering), and pleasant, efficient aervice despite the busy atmosphere.
Steve Amster
Best pizza I found in De so far.
The DDP
Grabbed a slice while walking the New Castle Farmer’s market. Great crust, supports the pizza well and has a little crunch. Toppings, cheese, and sauce were all well proportioned. I’ll have to go back and get a full fresh pie to give a more thorough taste test.
Lots of slices to choose from and with steady traffic they don’t sit for long. Seating area also available
$4 for the slice was worth it.
About Business
Came across here on Doordash but I haven't ate here inside Farmers Market in many-many years! Their NY style pizza is ridiculously delicious but also ridiculously priced. Even in these times a Lg Pepperoni pie should not be $25 and an XL Pepperoni pie should not be almost $30 I'm sorry. Love the pizza tho, just the pricing....
Ann Clark
Best tomato pie around. We have tried a lot of places and this is our favorite. Lots of sauce and the perfect crust. It is cash only.
Jim Garrett
A gem off of pizzeria in the middle of farmers market. They have many excellent tasting pizzas but lack a wood fire option. They make a very good Italian type crust as well as a couple of deep dish options. We love that their sauce is not sweet or salty and the pizzas are not overly greasy. Favorites are the sausage and mushroom and onions; spinach and ricotta and fresh tomatoes; the white chicken and broccoli pizza. The best values are a whole 16-in pizza for $24. You can mix and match 8 slices which normally would be $4 each to get the whole pizza price. People also line up for the end of the leftover end of day slices that used to drop down to $2 but I'm not sure if that's still the price. Consider Thursdays or early morning if you want to avoid the crowds or late in the afternoon.
Angel “Basilio” Ramos
Best PIZZA ever...?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mike Jeandell
I cannot walk in Farmers Market without getting a slice of Sicilian. I don't care if I'm stuffed from eating somewhere else, sooo good?
Jess Bond
Honestly some of the best Buffalo chicken pizza in the game. They have so many slices available you will be lost for words. Super crispy and delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sherry Jones
Authentic, delicious pizza. We ordered the Sicilian pizza with pepperoni and mushrooms. The dough was fresh, crispy on the outside and airy soft on inside. The price is very reasonable. Best pizza in the area for sure!
Recommended dishes: White Pizza, My Favorite Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza
Beth Amy Thomas
Great homesick pizza if you're from NY
Wllliam Maccready
Their Mexican pizza is the best pizza I ever had . Always get it , never disappointed Also their tomato pie is as good or better than anyone's anywhere
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: My Favorite Pizza
Evelin
Soo good. Had it a month ago and have to get it again!!!
Incredible tomato pie with the perfect crust, a noticeably delicate light tomato sauce (not overpowering), and pleasant, efficient aervice despite the busy atmosphere.
Best pizza I found in De so far.
Grabbed a slice while walking the New Castle Farmer’s market. Great crust, supports the pizza well and has a little crunch. Toppings, cheese, and sauce were all well proportioned. I’ll have to go back and get a full fresh pie to give a more thorough taste test.
Lots of slices to choose from and with steady traffic they don’t sit for long. Seating area also available
$4 for the slice was worth it.
Came across here on Doordash but I haven't ate here inside Farmers Market in many-many years! Their NY style pizza is ridiculously delicious but also ridiculously priced. Even in these times a Lg Pepperoni pie should not be $25 and an XL Pepperoni pie should not be almost $30 I'm sorry. Love the pizza tho, just the pricing....
Best tomato pie around. We have tried a lot of places and this is our favorite. Lots of sauce and the perfect crust. It is cash only.
A gem off of pizzeria in the middle of farmers market. They have many excellent tasting pizzas but lack a wood fire option. They make a very good Italian type crust as well as a couple of deep dish options. We love that their sauce is not sweet or salty and the pizzas are not overly greasy. Favorites are the sausage and mushroom and onions; spinach and ricotta and fresh tomatoes; the white chicken and broccoli pizza. The best values are a whole 16-in pizza for $24. You can mix and match 8 slices which normally would be $4 each to get the whole pizza price. People also line up for the end of the leftover end of day slices that used to drop down to $2 but I'm not sure if that's still the price. Consider Thursdays or early morning if you want to avoid the crowds or late in the afternoon.
Best PIZZA ever...?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I cannot walk in Farmers Market without getting a slice of Sicilian. I don't care if I'm stuffed from eating somewhere else, sooo good?
Honestly some of the best Buffalo chicken pizza in the game. They have so many slices available you will be lost for words. Super crispy and delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Authentic, delicious pizza. We ordered the Sicilian pizza with pepperoni and mushrooms. The dough was fresh, crispy on the outside and airy soft on inside. The price is very reasonable. Best pizza in the area for sure!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
The best pizza in Newcastle
We love ❤️ the pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: White Pizza, My Favorite Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza
Great homesick pizza if you're from NY
Their Mexican pizza is the best pizza I ever had . Always get it , never disappointed
Also their tomato pie is as good or better than anyone's anywhere
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: My Favorite Pizza
Soo good. Had it a month ago and have to get it again!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza in the ??
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Loading...