Paisano's Pizza

1508 Beaver Brook Plaza, New Castle
(302) 276-2625

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Nicholas Fisher

11:00pm means 11:00pm. Not 10:00. Not 10:50. Not 10:59. Because if your store is closed and the lights off 10-20 minutes before that means you started shutting everything down before that which is sad. Put the right hours.

shadypr24

First and last time i order from this place who can mess up a broccoli pizza I ordered it with extra cheese specifically mozzarella I guess they dont know what mozzarella cheese is because they added more ricotta cheese they literally gave me a ricotta cheese and broccoli pizza with some splashes of tomatoe sauce for the love of christ I shouldved looked at the riviews before ordering from this place 🤦‍♂️ lesson learned dont trust the stars on the reviews

Kinyetta Bell

I ordered a club sandwich and told them to hold the (pork) bacon mind you I’m allergic to pork they send my food out with it (pork) bacon . Call complain about it they come back pick the food back up wait 25 minutes they bring it back as I bite into the sandwich long behold I see (pork) bacon still on my sandwich as if they just took the bacon off and return the same sandwich back. Mind you no matter how big or small my order is they get tip 10$ or better this will be the last time I order from them I feel like it wasn’t fair to me a waste of 57$ all went in the trash plus tip and we order from them at-least twice a week

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Donna Bowman

I ordered a large pizza topped with eggplant parmigiana and was excited that I finally found a pizza place that offered it in Delaware after having it at Joe’s Pizza in Philly. As I was carrying the pizza to car, I noticed that the box felt very light. I opened the box and the topping on the pizza looked like some strange dried out type of mushrooms. It turned out to be dried out slices of eggplant. I went back into the store to tell them and the owner told me I had “to ASK for eggplant parmigiana”. Ummm - That’s what I asked for. After going back and forth I realized he had no idea what eggplant parmigiana was. Finally, he offered to make me a new one. I sat in my car with my friend and waited. While I was waiting, one of the workers kept coming to the window to look out at me. I went back in and they gave me a “fresh” pizza which was the dried out original pizza with a couple of blobs of ricotta. If you don’t know anything about Italian cuisine, don’t offer it on the menu and then try to argue with the customer about it. I hate to say this but a lot of pizza shops these days are owned by Mexicans who I know to be good hard-working people, but stick to the basic pizza, subs and steaks and TACOS. The thing is that years ago there was an Italian family who owned Paisano’s on Route 13 in Wilmington Manor, and I assumed this was their new location especially when I saw all of the Italian dishes on their menu. NEVER again!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

Guy Rocketram (Guy Rocketram)

Been ordering from here for a while. Food always arrives on time and always tastes great!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

James Williamson III

The food is great and the staff is really friendly. I highly recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Doc Purcell

Excellent. You wont be disappointed. This place is now our go to almost every week. Staff is awesome! Give en a shot.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lois R

I watch one of the cooks, take orders and without washing his hands went to straight back to making pizzas without gloves on.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Casper 718

Girl in the front gets orders wrong or gives your order to a different customer for whatever reason constantly .

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheesesteak Combo with Fries, Wings, Garlic Bread

Shanita Diaz

Horrible menu online. Cheese fries cooked fast so potatoes weren't done and we're soggy by the time they got to me. If you put a cover over fries without ventilation, they will get soggy. Cheap tenders over cooked. Cheese steak very light for the price and salty. Never would I ever think that a cheese steak sub was a plain cheessteak. Subs come with lettuce and tomato. Garden sub (as labeled)is unheard of, which is an actual cheese steak sub. I thought it was a vegetarian no meat. There was no trying to reconcile the situation. It is what you got, say the person on the phone.Please don't spend your money here. Try 3 Countries or Porto Fino's. Customer service is fantastic and the food is so much better.

Food: 1

Service: 1

LUMP HEAD

Order was messed up asked for a replacement was told no ! I spending alot money here every month . I am disappointed they couldn't fix my 10$

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Joe Dee

Best white pizza in Delaware

Mark Fellenbaum

Pizza and wing deal is the best around!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wings

Paul Chapman

Nice place, great staff. The cheese wasn't quite melted. Alot of good fixin's ? and a good crust. Nice price point too.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Mickey Matthews

The special stromboli was the best I've ever had. I will definitely order again!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Strombolis

Loading...