The New Castle Farmers Market has a large selection of foods to eat.Today I settled with Stoltzfus Sausage Sandwiches. I have to say. These sausage sandwiches are the real deal. The bread was nice and soft and the sausage had a crispness on the exterior while keeping its juicyness on the inside. Mine had grilled onions and a sauce. (No cheese) ? The fries had a good balance of salt. (No extra salt needed) The macaroni salad was ok. It wasn't traditional Amish but it had a nice peppery spice. Pretty balanced if you ask me.A friend of mine had a plain cheese steak. (No pictures) She said the meat was flavored and seasoned well but she wasn't moved by it. The cheese didn't complement the sandwich. She said it just seemed like it was two entities rather than one sandwich.Customer service was great. Everyone was smiling in the back and it seemed like everyone wanted to be there and was happy to serve.Overall I'll give it an 8/10
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Wheelchairmanjon
Sausage sandwich is
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jen T
While we usually go to the New Castle Farmers market on Sunday when they're not open, if we have time we always visit here. Food is good there's always a line when you get there. They also have an extensive menu so there's things here aside from sausage. Since you can get cheese steaks and burgers anywhere, get the sausage and enjoy.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Finn
Great sausage sanwhiches and quick and kind service
Marykay K
My husband ordered the favorite of sausage and pepper. He totally enjoyed it. I ordered a sausage w/ swiss and mushrooms. Both flavors are good separately, but I don't think it was on ideal mix. The sweet potato fries were fresh, hot and delicious!
John Larsson
Whether you order a turkey or pork sausage, hot or mild, order it with peppers, onions, and sauce. You can’t go wrong. They also have some great sides. The staff are friendly and orders come up pretty quickly.
Rick B
They made us fresh sausage sandwiches four minutes before closing. The sandwich was great I love this place.
amber viera
Great service! On a road trip through Pennsylvania and Delaware and stumbled upon this place, it was a good experience.
powerfulpro
Too bad this place is only open on Fridays and Saturdays at the Farmer's Market. Best Sausage Sandwiches ever. Steaks, cheesesteaks are also great. Have never had any bad food. Prices are reasonable. Servers are very willing and accommodating whether you are getting in or getting take-out.
RonB4610
Decided to stop at the Farmers Market to get lunch. Stopped for a mild sausage sandwich with fries and soda. Very good. There is a line which moves and counter space to eat or take out
When visiting the New Castle Farmers Market stop by Stoltzfus'. Freshly grilled sausage on a roll, reasonable priced tasty sandwich. Long lines & cash only business.
Archie M.
If you've never had a sausage sammich from here, you've NEVER had one. The Stoltzfus family has been serving up food in the New Castle Farmers Market for as long as I can remember. If it's a Friday or Saturday (the only days they are open), and your belly is growling, give them a try. The sausages are lean and full of flavor (I prefer the hot). Don't forget your side of deep fried vegetables
Amber D.
Friendly Staff and GREAT Quality food. I've tried the hot & mild sausage(choice of pork or turkey), fried veggies, and so much more. I have NEVER been disappointed. My mouth waters thinking about food from this establishment.
F B
Outstanding
Deniz Tezcan
These things are marvelous! Spicy or mild, these sausage sandwiches are legendary to locals. Highly recommended!
The New Castle Farmers Market has a large selection of foods to eat.Today I settled with Stoltzfus Sausage Sandwiches. I have to say. These sausage sandwiches are the real deal. The bread was nice and soft and the sausage had a crispness on the exterior while keeping its juicyness on the inside. Mine had grilled onions and a sauce. (No cheese) ? The fries had a good balance of salt. (No extra salt needed) The macaroni salad was ok. It wasn't traditional Amish but it had a nice peppery spice. Pretty balanced if you ask me.A friend of mine had a plain cheese steak. (No pictures) She said the meat was flavored and seasoned well but she wasn't moved by it. The cheese didn't complement the sandwich. She said it just seemed like it was two entities rather than one sandwich.Customer service was great. Everyone was smiling in the back and it seemed like everyone wanted to be there and was happy to serve.Overall I'll give it an 8/10
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Sausage sandwich is
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
While we usually go to the New Castle Farmers market on Sunday when they're not open, if we have time we always visit here. Food is good there's always a line when you get there. They also have an extensive menu so there's things here aside from sausage. Since you can get cheese steaks and burgers anywhere, get the sausage and enjoy.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great sausage sanwhiches and quick and kind service
My husband ordered the favorite of sausage and pepper. He totally enjoyed it. I ordered a sausage w/ swiss and mushrooms. Both flavors are good separately, but I don't think it was on ideal mix. The sweet potato fries were fresh, hot and delicious!
Whether you order a turkey or pork sausage, hot or mild, order it with peppers, onions, and sauce. You can’t go wrong. They also have some great sides. The staff are friendly and orders come up pretty quickly.
They made us fresh sausage sandwiches four minutes before closing. The sandwich was great I love this place.
Great service! On a road trip through Pennsylvania and Delaware and stumbled upon this place, it was a good experience.
Too bad this place is only open on Fridays and Saturdays at the Farmer's Market. Best Sausage Sandwiches ever. Steaks, cheesesteaks are also great. Have never had any bad food. Prices are reasonable. Servers are very willing and accommodating whether you are getting in or getting take-out.
Decided to stop at the Farmers Market to get lunch. Stopped for a mild sausage sandwich with fries and soda. Very good. There is a line which moves and counter space to eat or take out
Restaurantji Recommends
When visiting the New Castle Farmers Market stop by Stoltzfus'. Freshly grilled sausage on a roll, reasonable priced tasty sandwich. Long lines & cash only business.
If you've never had a sausage sammich from here, you've NEVER had one. The Stoltzfus family has been serving up food in the New Castle Farmers Market for as long as I can remember. If it's a Friday or Saturday (the only days they are open), and your belly is growling, give them a try. The sausages are lean and full of flavor (I prefer the hot). Don't forget your side of deep fried vegetables
Friendly Staff and GREAT Quality food. I've tried the hot & mild sausage(choice of pork or turkey), fried veggies, and so much more. I have NEVER been disappointed. My mouth waters thinking about food from this establishment.
Outstanding
These things are marvelous! Spicy or mild, these sausage sandwiches are legendary to locals. Highly recommended!