The food is always ready when I get there to pick it up, and always delicious. On the rare occasion the food is wrong, they always make it right by either remaking it for free or giving me 50% off the next order.Store is always clean and the staff if very helpful and friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chocolate Brownie, Halloween Special Pizza, Extra Cheesy Alfredo, Rolls
Justin Kelley
Who the heck doesn't open until 4pm on a Sunday? This place is an absolute disappointment. Papa John's in general is an absolute disappointment.
Chris Deegan
Foods OK, everytime I order a side of peppers. Sometimes it's four peppers for 75 cent a piece. Then it's 4dollars for a bunch of peppers. Seems like they make the prices up daily and change them. Super rude when carrying out most of the time. But hey, maybe I'm asking to much just a little kindness give and take.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Hank U.
Papa John's ! Always good. Love these guys. Open late, always great. Even delivered.
Shiloah
I ordered the garlic stuffed crust and it was just awful for one it had no garlic at all and the pizza itself was supposed to be hand tossed not micro. I mean this pizza was so thin that it was impossible to even eat it due to it being so flimsy. Their napkins were thicker, it was just awful and the workers weren't any better. I love Pappa Johns but I won't ever go back there.Parking: The parking for this place is all. They literally only have a couple spots and they're being monopolized by the workers there.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
sandy cianfarini
We walked in to order and a woman behind the counter said, "I'm gonna tell you right now, it'll be 10 minutes before I can even take your order." This was our first and last visit
Nicole Hickman
My husband ordered pizzas for delivery and some how they couldn't deliver them so they sent a doordasher to deliver nothing so they called to say they will remake our order I hope their is something a little extra in their because your food is good but comes with a $$ cost.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Amy Bullock
Garlic knots were not done. Very doughy.
Elaine Weil
DO NOT GET DELIVERY!!!They have been subcontracting to Doordash who leaves your food at the door and does't even ring the bell or knock!When you contact PJs they say oh yeah we know they do this and we'll give you $10 off your next order!
JC & PJ
Wish the Seaford PaPa Johns would be consistent in preparing pizza. My last 2 orders the crusted outer edges extend 1 1/4 to 1 1/2 inches towards center of the pie leaving an extremely thin center. Now and then the crust extends no more than 1/2 inch or less with the correct thickness in the center.Why such a deviation in prep of pizza must be due to inadequate training or standers.Entertaining future orders I will likely drive the extra miles to order pizza quality that I can rely on. It is ashame that a good pizza is ruined due to inconsistent preparation.Please wake up PaPa Johns! I also observed other similar complaints from the same Seaford Store.
$18.99 for a large extra cheese pizza. Ridiculous. Little ceasars isn’t as good but I’m not paying almost $20 for a pizza
Martha Buckley
Everyone is so friendly and pizza delicious.
Whitney King
This was my first time ordering from here and my food was delicious just absolutely delicious!!!
Hayley Steinbiss
$16.75 for medium pizza (only 12 inches in diameter)Incredibly overpricedMediocre pizzaI wouldn't reccomend anyone waste their money here
Chas Dugg
I called to place an order and they couldn't get it right. I told them nevermind and the Mgr. Called me back and after I told HER if they couldn't get the order right I know the pizza wouldn't be correct. So the MGR. told me never call there again...NO BRAINER WHY WOULD I. ????
The food is always ready when I get there to pick it up, and always delicious. On the rare occasion the food is wrong, they always make it right by either remaking it for free or giving me 50% off the next order.Store is always clean and the staff if very helpful and friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chocolate Brownie, Halloween Special Pizza, Extra Cheesy Alfredo, Rolls
Who the heck doesn't open until 4pm on a Sunday? This place is an absolute disappointment. Papa John's in general is an absolute disappointment.
Foods OK, everytime I order a side of peppers. Sometimes it's four peppers for 75 cent a piece. Then it's 4dollars for a bunch of peppers. Seems like they make the prices up daily and change them. Super rude when carrying out most of the time. But hey, maybe I'm asking to much just a little kindness give and take.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Papa John's ! Always good. Love these guys. Open late, always great. Even delivered.
I ordered the garlic stuffed crust and it was just awful for one it had no garlic at all and the pizza itself was supposed to be hand tossed not micro. I mean this pizza was so thin that it was impossible to even eat it due to it being so flimsy. Their napkins were thicker, it was just awful and the workers weren't any better. I love Pappa Johns but I won't ever go back there.Parking: The parking for this place is all. They literally only have a couple spots and they're being monopolized by the workers there.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
We walked in to order and a woman behind the counter said, "I'm gonna tell you right now, it'll be 10 minutes before I can even take your order." This was our first and last visit
My husband ordered pizzas for delivery and some how they couldn't deliver them so they sent a doordasher to deliver nothing so they called to say they will remake our order I hope their is something a little extra in their because your food is good but comes with a $$ cost.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Garlic knots were not done. Very doughy.
DO NOT GET DELIVERY!!!They have been subcontracting to Doordash who leaves your food at the door and does't even ring the bell or knock!When you contact PJs they say oh yeah we know they do this and we'll give you $10 off your next order!
Wish the Seaford PaPa Johns would be consistent in preparing pizza. My last 2 orders the crusted outer edges extend 1 1/4 to 1 1/2 inches towards center of the pie leaving an extremely thin center. Now and then the crust extends no more than 1/2 inch or less with the correct thickness in the center.Why such a deviation in prep of pizza must be due to inadequate training or standers.Entertaining future orders I will likely drive the extra miles to order pizza quality that I can rely on. It is ashame that a good pizza is ruined due to inconsistent preparation.Please wake up PaPa Johns! I also observed other similar complaints from the same Seaford Store.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 3
Restaurantji Recommends
$18.99 for a large extra cheese pizza. Ridiculous. Little ceasars isn’t as good but I’m not paying almost $20 for a pizza
Everyone is so friendly and pizza delicious.
This was my first time ordering from here and my food was delicious just absolutely delicious!!!
$16.75 for medium pizza (only 12 inches in diameter)Incredibly overpricedMediocre pizzaI wouldn't reccomend anyone waste their money here
I called to place an order and they couldn't get it right. I told them nevermind and the Mgr. Called me back and after I told HER if they couldn't get the order right I know the pizza wouldn't be correct. So the MGR. told me never call there again...NO BRAINER WHY WOULD I. ????