Captain Mac's Fish House & Seafood Market

I am so thankful for all the fishermen that gather incredible seatood and Captain Mac's is a great place to get it fresh or cooked. I love their steamed clams and Silver Queen corn on the cob.

We love coming to Capitan Mac’s when we come to Ocean City. Excellent fresh seafood options to dine in or take to go. Crab are excellent. Ordering at the counter makes things so efficient and smooth. The owner Bruce and the staff are friendly, helpful and hardworking. A must try!

Best soft shell crab I've had in years!

Love this place. Simple, delicious seafood. Gorgeous views from the back deck. What more could you want?

Captain Mac's Fish House & Seafood Market in Selbyville, DE, is a true gem for seafood lovers. I loved the food—each dish was fresh, flavorful, and expertly prepared, showcasing the best of local catches. The portion sizes were generous, offering great value without compromising quality. Dining outside was a real highlight; sitting by the bay added a serene and scenic backdrop that made the meal even more enjoyable. Whether you're craving a casual seafood feast or simply want to soak in some beautiful waterfront vibes, Captain Mac’s delivers on both taste and atmosphere. Highly recommended!

One of our favorites stops while at the beach. So few spots like this left; to be delicious, the food doesn’t need to be complicated. Fresh catches, expertly seasoned, and a peaceful outdoor deck for summer seating. Highly recommend the blackened tilefish platter or sandwich.

Fresh and delicious bites. Crab cake was great!

We go here regularly and have never had a bad meal. If a mistake is made on an order they are always quick & courteous to make it right & usually let you keep the mistake. VERY HIGHLY recommended & we have turned quite a few folks into this amazing restaurant. We love it!!

No soft crabs that day, even tho it was still listed on the menu board inside..we still had good meals..

The food was delicious! We will definitely come back next time we are in the area.

Every time we come to the ocean I make it a point to go to Captain Mac's. They have the best seafood in town and the prices are far more reasonable than anywhere else.

I got the Captain's platter with the crabcake. The crabcake wasn't huge but it was fair for the price with everything else you get in the platter. The blackened mahi mahi is always delicious, the scallops were pretty good. It's hard to tell if they needed more seasoning because I ate them right after the blackened Mahi. They were good though. The shrimp were also delicious. I was actually surprised at how many shrimp came with the dish. It was more than I expected.

The kids fish sticks are also mahi mahi. Where else can you get mahi mahi for a kids fish sticks!?

We purchased a home in BB 3 yrs ago. Really enjoy every time we go to Captain Mac’s. Great seafood, perfect drink selection, dessert and always made to feel welcome.

I had friends who traveled over three hours to Selbyville just for the day and were craving crab. However, when we checked Captain Mac’s website, it stated that they serve eat-in crabs until 5 p.m. Despite this, we arrived at 4:35 p.m. and ordered six crabs. To our surprise, the lady at the counter informed us that they no longer served crabs after 4 p.m. I kindly reminded her of the information provided on the website, but she became quite defensive and claimed that the website had been hacked, and they disregarded it. Despite my explanation, she offered no apologies and displayed an extremely rude demeanor. As a result, we were left feeling very dissatisfied and disappointed.

Tasty seafood + excellent steamed and raw top necks, great wild caught fish market for takeout.

Beyond Outstanding! Captain Mac’s Fish House in Fenwick Island blew me away! From the moment we arrived, everything was incredibly organized and efficient. The service was fast and friendly, and the food—wow! No table service, which adds to the efficiency. Can order fresh seafood and everything to go! The fries were hands-down the best I’ve ever had, crispy and perfectly seasoned.

We had lunch out on the back covered deck, which was a great spot—relaxing, breezy, and with plenty of shade. The portions were generous, and everything we tried was fresh, flavorful, and cooked to perfection. You can tell they take pride in every dish they serve.

I will absolutely be coming back often. A true hidden gem at the beach!