Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe
1980 Mayport Rd, Atlantic Beach
(904) 524-7274
Recent Reviews
Sort by
1980 Mayport Rd, Atlantic Beach
(904) 524-7274
These chocolate pies, are just the best I've ever had. I love every part of it, it's awesome!
Amazing pies, friendly staff.
Great place to get a Key lime pie (without having to drive 8 hours to the Keys)
My wife stopped by here today coming home from work and surprised us with a French silk. It was delicious! Would definitely recommend and we want to go back and try more!
Kindest ladies ever, trust me. The pies are worth it. Especially the apple pie.
Outstanding service and exceptionally friendly staff. While the prices may be on the higher side, the quality more than justifies the cost you truly get great value for your money. The selection of both savory and dessert pies is consistently excellent, with delicious flavors that never disappoint.
BEST PIES EVER! YOU HAVE TO GO!
Bought over $60 worth of pies. They looked fantastic but the crust on all of them were so salty that I couldn’t eat anything. I personally love salt and add it to a great deal of things but I just couldn’t get past the amount of last they added to their crust. It’s as if they were attempting to make play dough.
Best pie ever
Truly Pie Heaven! Amazing, addictive pies and very lovely staff, 10/10!
Purchased the Valentines Special. We picked two Shepherds Pie’s and two Key Lime Pie’s. 30.00, reasonable for handmade pies with quality ingredients. Excellent pies.
Restaurantji Recommends
This place serves the absolute best pie! The shop is run by such sweet ladies. What a lovely atmosphere in there.
Got a chicken pot pie, a triple berry pie, and a keylime pie. Chicken potpie was devoured quickly, crust was flaky and buttery, the filling tasted amazing. Was worth the drive from Mandarin. Triple berry looks amazing, heating it up now
Excellent food
This little bakery's name caught my eye a couple years ago. The name is spot on: (1) A generous slice of sales revenue goes toward helping people around the world spend eternity with Jesus, in person. (2) My grandma's best pies don't come near the taste and texture of those made at Pie Heaven. Don't miss the rhubarb pie next summer!
Extremely good and very expensive.
Loading...