Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe

1980 Mayport Rd, Atlantic Beach
(904) 524-7274

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

+61 photos
+60 photos
Add a photo

Order Online

Recent Reviews

I’m overall happy with the pies! I did drive a distance and got there 30 minutes before opening to not have any pecan pies, or the strawberry rhubarb.. However I was pleasantly happy with the chicken pot pie! The pumpkin was kicking with freshness and a bit of cinnamon flavor! Then I ended up picking the coconut custard which was very creamy just not my top pick. Love that they are homemade!
Great place from fruit pie to pot pies. Price of pies may shock you, but these pies are made like your mama's, not out of the freezer section of your grocery stores or bakery.

Currently supporting our active military during the shutdown with a free chicken pot pie. Highly recommend you support these ladies and donate to thier veterans funds.
Went there with my girlfriend Angel after hearing about this place on the news where you can donate a pie to a military family. We purchased a chicken pot pie which was absolutely delicious!! Then we donated two more. The staff were very sweet and helpful. Also, the fresh squeezed lemonade is the best!! We will certainly be back for more!!

More Reviews