Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe

1980 Mayport Rd, Atlantic Beach
(904) 524-7274

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Coconut Custard Pie
Strawberry Rhubarb
Bourbon Pecan Pie
Banana Cream Pie
Blackberry Pie
Chocolate Pie
Key Lime Pie
Apple Pie
Blueberry
All Pies

Menu

Pie
Apple Pie
Lemon Meringue Pie
Classic silky lemon curd under lovely meringue in our sweet crust.
Blackberry Pie
Coconut Custard Pie
We add a bit of nutmeg and coconut to classic egg custard and bake it in our sweet pie crust. Yummy!
Chicken Pot Pie
Made from scratch with anti-biotic free cage-free chicken, organic stock and enough organic vegetables to make mom happy in our double crust savory crust. It's comfort from heaven indeed!
Apple Cranberry Pie
Margarita Key Lime
Key West. Jimmy buffet. Margaritaville. inspired us to get the key lime pie drunk with tequila and triple sec. it's pretty awesome.
Organic Cherry
Country Chocolate
The perfect marriage between mousse and fudge. Nothing fluffy on top - just a simply wonderful smooth chocolate pie in our handmade sweet crust. This pie has resulted in marriage proposals!
Peach Pie
Juicy but not mushy - that's how each pie should be. And ours is that and more. In a lattice crust.
Mincemeat Pie
Shown with optional fancy crust top, available on request, once a year before Christmas we make this amazing stewed fruit - no meat. When it's gone, it's gone. Apples, raisins, currants, oranges, lemons, figs, cranberries, sherry, brandy, and spices go into this old world favorite.
Baked Strawberry
Strawberries baked in our sweet pie crust will remind you of your favorite biscuit and homemade strawberry preserves.
Strawberry Rhubarb
A midwest favorite made with ripe tangy rhubarb and sweet strawberries in our sweet lattice crust. Please contact the merchant for product availability.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+52 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+51 photos
Add a photo

Order Online

Recent Reviews

The bakers make a great, dense, and thick slice of pie with quality, complex filling inside a wonderful, perfect thickness, and great golden crust.👩‍🍳 🥧

I really wish for a luxurious, super beautiful meal of a slice of chicken pot pie accompanied by a nice medium portion greens side salad lightly topped with local fresh vegetable and tasteful dressing.
🐥 🥗

I really enjoy their Boston cream pie.
For either...
August 2025
Whatever they have on the board is what they have for the day.
We were told the small pies were 6in but definitely seemed smaller.
All of the pies are made in the on location kitchen.
We ordered a sclice of apple and mixed berry. We ordered a small key lime, margarita key lime and apple pie.
You can tell the lies are freshly made.
I have had presentation and tasting key limes. But it’s a small business to try at least once.
June 2025
My husband loves cherry pie. I ordered him a full size one for his birthday, and a week later -- when he had a friend visit -- I ordered them smaller pies. A cherry and a blueberry. They loved them.

There is a single table in the cafe, in case you want to eat in, but primarily you're ordering pies to take out.
June 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Voo Swar Restaurant & Lounge - 51 Robert St
American, Lounges, Chicken Wings, Gluten-Free, Vegetarian
1985 Coffee Shop & Events - 1985 Mayport Rd
Coffee Shops, Coffee, Coffee & Tea
Sub Cultured - 10 Donner Rd
Sandwich Shop, Salad, Cheesesteaks, Pet Friendly, Gluten-Free

Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe

1980 Mayport Rd, Atlantic Beach, FL 32233
(904) 524-7274