Multiple pizza slices of different variety, rice balls, fried raviolis, pastas and so on. It’s all great and the staff is personable, the new neighborhood pizza joint!!
And don’t forget dessert, always a new treat
Travis Cunningham
Had our first visit to Peter’s today. In town from Jax for FAU Family Weekend. Absolutely phenomenal pizzas! My wife had a slice of the margherita, and my son and I shared a Sicilian. All of it was very, very good. The Sicilian was very, very good. Referred to us by our sins teammate and it did not disappoint. We’ll be back!
Kyle Stevenson
Peter’s Pizzeria is fantastic! The pepperoni pizza is incredible, with a perfectly crispy crust and loads of savory pepperoni. The CBR pizza (chicken, bacon, ranch) was also a hit—rich, flavorful, and fresh.
Their bolognese pasta is a must-try too, with a rich, hearty sauce that’s packed with flavor. Definitely ate too much on my stop here but no regrets with food this good. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Slice of Pizza
Kaitlin
Amazing pizza spot. Super genuine shop, who makes actual NY/NJ style pizza. As a pizza snob from Jersey, I know how we like our pizza, and Peter's Pizzeria does it perfectly! Very reasonable prices, large slices & a very loyal customer. 10/10!! ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
K MAN
Peter really does make the world a better place one slice at a time!
Started off with their New York cheese pizza. Classic, dependable—like that old friend who always knows just what to say. Thin crust, perfectly cheesy. A bit of flop on the crust, but all the better when we reheat on the stone for leftovers.
But then came the showstopper: the Sicilian style pizza with pepperoni. This wasn’t just pizza; it was an experience. The crust was airy, almost cloud-like—if clouds were made of delicious dough. The mozzarella? Soft and embracing, like a warm hug from Nonna herself. And the tomato sauce? Bright and tangy, a vibrant dance of flavors.
Peter turns a simple meal into a standing ovation. If you’re looking for a slice of joy, this is the place to be. Pop in and say hi to Peter himself. Five stars? I’d give it the whole constellation! Bravo!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sicilian Cheese Pizza
rslmarchitect
Great slices
Rob
Phenomenal pizza, everything works so well together and the pizza was piping hot. The crust is really something special. Great service too! You gotta try this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
James Nebz
We drove from West Boca to East Boca to try Peter’s. Our group passed about 2 dozen pizza places to try this spot.
This is the Best pizza I have had in Florida.
We tried lots of different slices.
Each style was better than the next.
We also had a Chicken roll flavored with vodka sauce.
The owner is incredibly enthusiastic and is straight off the boat from Long Island.
He couldn’t have been any nicer.
We also had pistachio tiramisù and regular tiramisu .
P.S. the Sicilian slices were exceptional.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lori Welsh
First visit. Had heard from Many this pizza is incredible- we just moved into a place 5 minutes away- lucky us.
Picked up 2 pies: cheese & a pepperoni. Oh. My. Gosh.
Super crust, generous portions & the flavor is…10 stars for us.
The slices look super too - yum!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sasha B
my favorite pizza place ever (get the buffalo slice) ????
Brooklyn born, Bronx raised. Pizza is a NY thing. I've been in Florida for 30 years and never found a true NY tasting pizza. Some are good but No cigar. Pete's Pizza in Boca Raton Fl. Is the real deal NY Pizza. Pete has patented water filtration system that's like NY water. The one and only Pizza that is truly New York/New Jersey Pizza. The absolute best. Pete and Anthony are super cool guys. They're opening one in Pompano Beach soon. I will eat pizza only at Pete's Pizza.
Peters is the best pizza in Florida. Everywhere else is flat and doesn’t compare to the pizza and other menu items here at Peters. On top of that Peter himself is a great guy and it always feels welcome every time we stop by.
Peter’s Pizzeria in Boca is about to be the next great find. I wanted to try my friends recommendation of this incredible pizzeria and I am always chasing the perfect pie. My wife and I stopped in last night for dinner and it was an incredible experience. Upon walking in the aroma of fresh baked pizza along with the display of several different types of pies was a sign of great things to come. Also, the Bakers Pride ovens were a welcoming sight. Peter uses the finest ingredients some of which are flown in direct from Italy. There is passion and love from the owner, Peter himself, who is so knowledgeable about the art of making the best NY pizza slice. The pepperoni pizza was outstanding. Don’t sleep on their pasta dishes. We ordered a spaghetti bolognese that was probably one of the best dishes I have ever had in South Florida. Peter was so kind to send out a tasting of cheeses that were directly from Italy (Burrata and Grana Padano). AMAZING! With full bellies it was dessert time. He brought out a homemade pistachio tiramisu made by his mom. It was by far the most delicious dessert we have ever eaten! Run don’t walk to this little gem. And get ready for his new flagship location in Pompano coming soon!
Multiple pizza slices of different variety, rice balls, fried raviolis, pastas and so on. It’s all great and the staff is personable, the new neighborhood pizza joint!! And don’t forget dessert, always a new treat
Had our first visit to Peter’s today. In town from Jax for FAU Family Weekend. Absolutely phenomenal pizzas! My wife had a slice of the margherita, and my son and I shared a Sicilian. All of it was very, very good. The Sicilian was very, very good. Referred to us by our sins teammate and it did not disappoint. We’ll be back!
Peter’s Pizzeria is fantastic! The pepperoni pizza is incredible, with a perfectly crispy crust and loads of savory pepperoni. The CBR pizza (chicken, bacon, ranch) was also a hit—rich, flavorful, and fresh.
Their bolognese pasta is a must-try too, with a rich, hearty sauce that’s packed with flavor. Definitely ate too much on my stop here but no regrets with food this good. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Slice of Pizza
Amazing pizza spot. Super genuine shop, who makes actual NY/NJ style pizza. As a pizza snob from Jersey, I know how we like our pizza, and Peter's Pizzeria does it perfectly!
Very reasonable prices, large slices & a very loyal customer.
10/10!! ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Peter really does make the world a better place one slice at a time!
Started off with their New York cheese pizza. Classic, dependable—like that old friend who always knows just what to say. Thin crust, perfectly cheesy. A bit of flop on the crust, but all the better when we reheat on the stone for leftovers.
But then came the showstopper: the Sicilian style pizza with pepperoni. This wasn’t just pizza; it was an experience. The crust was airy, almost cloud-like—if clouds were made of delicious dough. The mozzarella? Soft and embracing, like a warm hug from Nonna herself. And the tomato sauce? Bright and tangy, a vibrant dance of flavors.
Peter turns a simple meal into a standing ovation. If you’re looking for a slice of joy, this is the place to be. Pop in and say hi to Peter himself. Five stars? I’d give it the whole constellation! Bravo!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sicilian Cheese Pizza
Great slices
Phenomenal pizza, everything works so well together and the pizza was piping hot. The crust is really something special. Great service too! You gotta try this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
We drove from West Boca to East Boca to try Peter’s.
Our group passed about 2 dozen pizza places to try this spot.
This is the Best pizza I have had in Florida.
We tried lots of different slices.
Each style was better than the next.
We also had a Chicken roll flavored with vodka sauce.
The owner is incredibly enthusiastic and is straight off the boat from Long Island.
He couldn’t have been any nicer.
We also had pistachio tiramisù and regular tiramisu .
P.S. the Sicilian slices were exceptional.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First visit. Had heard from Many this pizza is incredible- we just moved into a place 5 minutes away- lucky us.
Picked up 2 pies: cheese & a pepperoni.
Oh. My. Gosh.
Super crust, generous portions & the flavor is…10 stars for us.
The slices look super too - yum!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
my favorite pizza place ever (get the buffalo slice) ????
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken, Garlic Knots
Restaurantji Recommends
Best pizza hands down! Peter is the best!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brooklyn born, Bronx raised.
Pizza is a NY thing.
I've been in Florida for 30 years and never found a true NY tasting pizza. Some are good but No cigar.
Pete's Pizza in Boca Raton Fl.
Is the real deal NY Pizza.
Pete has patented water filtration system that's like NY water.
The one and only Pizza that is truly New York/New Jersey Pizza.
The absolute best.
Pete and Anthony are super cool guys.
They're opening one in Pompano Beach soon.
I will eat pizza only at Pete's Pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Sicilian Cheese Pizza
Peters is the best pizza in Florida. Everywhere else is flat and doesn’t compare to the pizza and other menu items here at Peters. On top of that Peter himself is a great guy and it always feels welcome every time we stop by.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken, Specialty Slice
Peter’s Pizzeria in Boca is about to be the next great find. I wanted to try my friends recommendation of this incredible pizzeria and I am always chasing the perfect pie. My wife and I stopped in last night for dinner and it was an incredible experience. Upon walking in the aroma of fresh baked pizza along with the display of several different types of pies was a sign of great things to come. Also, the Bakers Pride ovens were a welcoming sight. Peter uses the finest ingredients some of which are flown in direct from Italy. There is passion and love from the owner, Peter himself, who is so knowledgeable about the art of making the best NY pizza slice. The pepperoni pizza was outstanding. Don’t sleep on their pasta dishes. We ordered a spaghetti bolognese that was probably one of the best dishes I have ever had in South Florida. Peter was so kind to send out a tasting of cheeses that were directly from Italy (Burrata and Grana Padano). AMAZING! With full bellies it was dessert time. He brought out a homemade pistachio tiramisu made by his mom. It was by far the most delicious dessert we have ever eaten! Run don’t walk to this little gem. And get ready for his new flagship location in Pompano coming soon!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious pizza and great environment
Loading...