As always everyone loved their meals, you never disappoint. Phillip provided attention, personable and professional service.
Berta
We have been there multiple times for years. Never disappointed. Thank you. We tried to make Thanksgiving reservations for 4 pm. Please inform us if there are any cancellations. Thank you again. Berta.
Norma
We both had the Thai salad which was gd although do not like that type of greens would have liked to have the lobster roll but $46 is a bit much for a hot dog roll even e/lobster
Priscilla
We sat outside. So pleasant. Food was amazing!! Great service. Very attentive. Love Prime Catch!!!
Joanne
As always, our evening was so nice at Prime Catch. The diverse menu and cocktail/wine selections are great. And our waitress was so nice too.
Robin
We sat outside on the perfect South Florida evening! The coconut crusted halibut was delicious! The server was very accommodating to my dairy intolerance and made sure my dish was safe and yummy! We will be back!
Jeff
We had a great brunch with friends on the water we got fresh fish. Everyone loved their fish. Brittney, our waitress, was terrific. The music was great. My only complaint is that the music was a little loud to have a conversation with four people. We all agreed that we would definitely come back.
Nicole Nash
I was disappointed with my recent dining experience. The snapper fish was unfortunately lacking in flavor, and the accompanying vegetables were burnt. My cocktail contained an excessive amount of Angostura bitters, which made it unpleasant to drink. The portion size was also underwhelming, with only five small potatoes on the plate. The dinner roll was the highlight of the meal, though it was served with frozen butter. I hope the restaurant takes this feedback constructively to improve the quality and consistency of their dishes
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
jimiboynyc
They overcooked the fish . It was dry and had no flavor . The atmosphere was very nice. The service was great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 4
Chaya
Prime Catch is the best. The menu is huge; there's something for everyone, and it's all expertly prepared and sourced. The views are beautiful, and the service is flawless. It's like a vacation.
I had an absolutely terrible experience and will never return!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 4
Ruby
I've never had a bad meal, and I have ordered the Tristan Lobster Tail before and it was delicious. Unfortunately, when I ordered it last night, the tail was tough, the green beans were not well cooked and the fingerling potatoes were overcooked. I had to ask for a steak knife to cut through the food.
Jordan
The restaurant is beautiful and the view is lovely. Our service was impeccable and it seemed to have a smooth flow to it. We ordered the blue crab bisque and the French onion soup. Both soups were delicious. However, our entrees were very overcooked and lacked any flavor. The seafood did taste fresh but we paid good money for high end dishes and both were a disappointment! I would try this place again in hopes that maybe the bad entrees were a fluke. Again, beautiful restaurant and great service!
MA C
Nothing like I expected. Restaurant was elegant in Key West Style (that's the 2 star rating) Service was OK but the server wasn't knowledgeable. Food was awful. The couple we were with, had eaten at the restaurant before and both ordered non-seafood dishes.( that should have been my clue) The Calamari appetizers were okay. I ordered a seasonal special Summer Salmon dish that was truly awful. The vegetables tasted from a frozen source and the salmon was dry and tasteless. My husband ordered a seafood medley platter and had to request the condiments and butter ( inexperienced server or kitchen..??) The experience was truly a disappointment.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
Ruth
The food & service are excellent. Judy remembers her regular customers & is always warm & welcoming. It's a great restaurant
As always everyone loved their meals, you never disappoint. Phillip provided attention, personable and professional service.
We have been there multiple times for years. Never disappointed. Thank you. We tried to make Thanksgiving reservations for 4 pm. Please inform us if there are any cancellations. Thank you again. Berta.
We both had the Thai salad which was gd although do not like that type of greens would have liked to have the lobster roll but $46 is a bit much for a hot dog roll even e/lobster
We sat outside. So pleasant. Food was amazing!! Great service. Very attentive. Love Prime Catch!!!
As always, our evening was so nice at Prime Catch. The diverse menu and cocktail/wine selections are great. And our waitress was so nice too.
We sat outside on the perfect South Florida evening! The coconut crusted halibut was delicious! The server was very accommodating to my dairy intolerance and made sure my dish was safe and yummy! We will be back!
We had a great brunch with friends on the water we got fresh fish. Everyone loved their fish. Brittney, our waitress, was terrific. The music was great. My only complaint is that the music was a little loud to have a conversation with four people. We all agreed that we would definitely come back.
I was disappointed with my recent dining experience. The snapper fish was unfortunately lacking in flavor, and the accompanying vegetables were burnt. My cocktail contained an excessive amount of Angostura bitters, which made it unpleasant to drink. The portion size was also underwhelming, with only five small potatoes on the plate. The dinner roll was the highlight of the meal, though it was served with frozen butter. I hope the restaurant takes this feedback constructively to improve the quality and consistency of their dishes
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
They overcooked the fish . It was dry and had no flavor . The atmosphere was very nice. The service was great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 4
Prime Catch is the best. The menu is huge; there's something for everyone, and it's all expertly prepared and sourced. The views are beautiful, and the service is flawless. It's like a vacation.
Restaurantji Recommends
I had an absolutely terrible experience and will never return!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 4
I've never had a bad meal, and I have ordered the Tristan Lobster Tail before and it was delicious. Unfortunately, when I ordered it last night, the tail was tough, the green beans were not well cooked and the fingerling potatoes were overcooked. I had to ask for a steak knife to cut through the food.
The restaurant is beautiful and the view is lovely. Our service was impeccable and it seemed to have a smooth flow to it. We ordered the blue crab bisque and the French onion soup. Both soups were delicious. However, our entrees were very overcooked and lacked any flavor. The seafood did taste fresh but we paid good money for high end dishes and both were a disappointment! I would try this place again in hopes that maybe the bad entrees were a fluke. Again, beautiful restaurant and great service!
Nothing like I expected. Restaurant was elegant in Key West Style (that's the 2 star rating) Service was OK but the server wasn't knowledgeable. Food was awful. The couple we were with, had eaten at the restaurant before and both ordered non-seafood dishes.( that should have been my clue) The Calamari appetizers were okay. I ordered a seasonal special Summer Salmon dish that was truly awful. The vegetables tasted from a frozen source and the salmon was dry and tasteless. My husband ordered a seafood medley platter and had to request the condiments and butter ( inexperienced server or kitchen..??) The experience was truly a disappointment.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
The food & service are excellent. Judy remembers her regular customers & is always warm & welcoming. It's a great restaurant
Loading...