Jeremiah's Italian Ice

2209 Santa Barbara Blvd #101, Cape Coral
(239) 541-8207

Recent Reviews

Dario G.

My favorite is mango tango. Affordable place to get yummy treats.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

David Orlowski

We always order a half gallon of italian ice online for a pickup or go there during lunch when its not busy.I just called and they claim they never provide this service and refused to do it for me unless I did a door dash which is double the cost. They told us they do not sell half gallons of Italian Ice and never did which is not true because I picked up 2 half gallons there in the past week in person.So we go in person to the store and ask to purchase a half gallon which is on the menu and the 2 employees with curly permed hair claim they don't sell it and never have sold it.We decided to purchase 2 quarts of black cherry ice. It tasted totally different than it did when we purchased the half gallon early in the week as well as the orange which also had no flavor.Not sure what happened in the course of a few days but not only does the product lack any flavor but it was so hard you needed a chisel to take a bite out of it unless you let it thaw out for 15 minutes.Very disappointed in the service and the products. It appears the staff needs to be trained better!

Service: 1

Marti gonzalez

we got a small cup inside the large cup that we ordered, the employee made me feel dumb when talking to her and did the order wrong, the worst experience ever in Jeremiah's.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 1

Kim Fenty

SOOOOOOO GOOOOOD!!! YUMMMMMMM SO MANY

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sour Green Apple Pumpkin Pie, Oreo, Horchata Gelati

Barney Moore

Very fast service, delicious! I will say that I've visited several other locations, and this one assembled my gelati a little to quickly so it was sloppy. The Italian ice in my sugar cookie was a bit too frozen and not quite the consistency I'm used to. Overall it was still delicious, I just feel like they could have taken a little more time to make the gelati a little nicer.

Jack H.

It's so good me and the family went and they had all dofrent types of flavors The service was great The place was sick it had a froggy surfing the ambience was fantastic

gino graziano

The ice was spectacular the manger was so nice and kind she helped me choose a flavor and allowed me to try multiple flavors until I chose great experience 10/10

Vinnie Hacker

Kiara has the best service ever. Shes a great manager.

Like this comment.

Phenomenal Italian ice!!! Make sure to get some custard too

Shshsh Shsjwhh

Best person service from the manager. It was a hot day and she gave me and my dying siblings free ice cream

John Iger

Great Gelati Ice Cream! We love getting out for a dessert.

Elisha Moody

This is a gem! Always super tasty. I had the funfetti and it was delicious

Magnus Thiersmann

Been very hit and miss the last few months. Several times we've come here during regular business hours and they were not open. Sometimes there's a sign on the door stating they're closed, and other times just locked doors. The ice cream temp and quality is inconsistent as well. Usually a good mix that holds up through the duration of enjoying the treat but sometimes it's melting within a couple minutes of receiving it. Not a big deal for mixes in a cup but pretty tragic for a child's soft serve cone that is prepared 8 inches over the cone top and melting moments after receiving it. We like it here and were strong supporters when they first opened but the reliability and quality have declined through the summer (2023). Hopefully they can turn it around and improve. In the meantime, set your expectations accordingly on your next visit.

Indi Ca

Waited at the window for a little under 5 minutes before being acknowledged. The ice cream is usually pretty good, if they have what’s available on their menu, which doesn’t seem super often :-/

Kenyon Montemoino

The bathrooms are completely filthy, and the actual ice didn't even taste good 0/10. also people at the front were lowkey rude. def dont recommend coming here ? i wish i cld put 0 stars but the app won't let me anyways bye ✌?

Load More