Maria's Pizzeria & Restaurant

1224 SE 46th Ln, Cape Coral
(239) 945-6006

Recent Reviews

Kate Boughton

The servers/waiters were all super friendly and nice. We ate outside, it was perfect for our large family. Great service. Pizza was good! Calamari was excellent.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tee Zee

Really enjoyed the food and service. My complaint would be with some drop ceiling tiles that need to be replaced.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Marsala

Howard Johnson

Excellent food and service!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Fred Buoni

Ordered the pizza because i love pizza and their pictures on the web looked great. Well, i got the pizza and looked nothing like the pictures on the web. They made pizzas just for the web cause very small pieses of sausage and had half of the pieces that were on the picures. Compare the pizza u get with the pictures on the web, nothing like it. Never again. If u want a great pizza? Go to Leoe's, Chicago pizza, or Restorante Sicilia.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Toppings

Ally

I’m not an i’m not a big fan of Italian restaurants, but after reading the reviews, I was really excited to come here, but I was quickly disappointed. It took us a while to be acknowledged, and to sit down, but other than that the service was pretty good. Our server was really nice and attentive. The ambience was all right, but what brought the stars down for me is that the food was so bad. Everything was like warm. The mozzarella sticks were all right, but what gets me is the plating of this, I just think it’s so weird(pictured). The soups were bland, and they both didn’t get finished. The best thing we ordered was the caprese salad, The tomatoes were hilariously large, but it was good. I got the Giovanni’s veal and not to be that person but it’s one of the most expensive things on the menu and it was not very good. I had to add all of these things to it to make it good. Mine was salvageable but for the margarita pizza absolutely not, i mean look at it. It was so soggy and flimsy. I took a picture of the bottom of the plate and you can see the oil or water whatever it was at the bottom. Overall, 2 stars.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 4

Katlyn Martin

Ordered delivery via door dash, our door dasher was at the restaurant 3 times. Our meal never was delivered, the restaurant canceled out order after 2 1/2 hours of waiting. Hungry kids were not happy, patents extremely unhappy. Extremely annoyed with this restaurant, and will not ever recommend.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Kelvin D.

This is the best Italian food you will have. That how the person going out if this place tell me on my way in... He was not kidding!!! The sauce is so rich and flavor amazing. The food came fast and was very happy about that

John J.

Ok, for starters I was hungry and was literally the first person to be seated at 4PM. A gentleman was ahead of me to pick up a rather large to go order. The server was very, very kind and led me to my table very quickly. I chose Maria's not because I had read a review or anything like that, but because a favorite bartender left the restaurant where I got to know her and returned to Maria's as a server. Enough about the why. My server (Tris) was just about the nicest (and most patient person) ever. She guided me in my choices and though she has worked there only a couple of months, she knew the menu very well. She was cheerful, responsive, and was on her game the whole time...while taking her time with me and making me feel like I was "somebody". I chose the pizza with a cauliflower crust and was so impressed with the quality of everything. The pizza sauce tasted like I always want pizza sauce to taste, but never does. There was another non-pizza dish on the menu that piqued my interest...so it is inevitable that I will be coming back very soon. They take reservations, but that wasn't an issue for me as early as I arrived. If you want a table at 7 probably on any night of the week you should book ahead. Yum, just yum.

Kat Weitzenkorn

Local Italian. Always good! Try the eggplant rollatini!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ron Tweedle

I ordered take out of 4 pizza’s. Their website prices are not the actual prices for the sizes and kind of pizza ordered. In addition I have never ordered a pizza anywhere where cheese is not included. They charge and additional $2.50 per pizza for mozzarella. I guess if you don’t want mozzarella you get dough and sauce as a pie.Very disappointing.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sharon Gannon

We got take out pizza, ziti in sauce, salad and garlic knots $29.00 got 3 meals out of it and absolutely wonderful!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dave T.

It's sad, but I'm done with this once great family owned establishment. I gave the new owners a chance. The final straw was my recent take out order. My order was done on line with a suggested pick up time frame given after checkout. I arrived at the later end of the time given in my confirmation only to wait another 10+ minutes before my order was retrieved from the kitchen. While waiting I observed the ongoing chaos at the understaffed front end. I had heard about this problem from a few of my neighbors. I watched one customer after a long wait, refusing her order because it came from the kitchen cold. The hostess offered to have a new order prepared, the customer refused. Furthermore, customers with reservations also had long waits before the hostess was able to find time to seat them. My neighbors stopped going months ago because they said the service had become unbearable. I now see why. Poor management is clearly the problem. I think that the hostess should not have to spend her time running to the kitchen and checking on take-out orders when she should instead be the "face" of the the house and greet and seat guests as they arrive. I can't imagine what it was like for those seated and eating in the dining area. The new owners need to call someone like Jon Taffer now, before it is too late!

Catherine S.

Great pizza fast delivery one of our favorites The Parmesan chicken calzone was excellent as was the vegetable pizza and pepperoni pizza. Plenty to feed a crowd.

Gavin H.

Ordered a small pizza tonight for dinner. I have tried several pizza places in the area and this was by far the best. Bella working the front counter was very friendly and you can tell that she truly cares about her customers and is passionate about her job that is not common anymore, especially in food service. It is clear that she is a true asset to this restaurant.

Nanette Marx

Third time here. Everything's always good. Our waitress was new, very eager to find answers about the questions we had.Prices are reasonable portions good sized.We need to go back for pizza, the ones we saw looked fantastic

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Load More