As busy as they are, you always feel like your number one in this place. I love a good martini and that martinis here were made perfectly even with a packed bar. The atmosphere was so great. Put us in a whole better mood. Thank you so much we love this place, the pizza sauce is the best I’ve had in the long while. Love the pizza as well.
Parking: Great sports bar coming for the game on Sunday. Lots of space and the fountain in the front outside is so nice to watch and soothing.
Kid-friendliness: Perfect for all ages but mainly a nice adult sports bar.
Wheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair access I checked that out for a handicap member of my family who I’m bringing on Sunday. Thank you for that.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizzas
Steve Policastri
Ordered takeout and the wings were definitely the best I've had in cape coral so far in almost 2 years. Boneless and bone in both top notch
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Terri Petersen
6 months still no AC Broccoli, chicken rice served cold. Needs updating. Seems like they are planning to close. Neon Sign lighting has been out for months.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Ribs
Kimberly A Stout
This is excellent bar type food. I've had a Gyro and a Wrap another night and both were very good. Prices are on the lower end for restaurants. Monday nights they have free music bingo. Several large groups showed up for beer and bingo on the outdoor bar patio. Each bingo card has a different theme of music ... 80s, 90s and pop. (I had to Google the words on some songs to match the artist and title... or you can work in groups).
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken, Gyro
Stephanie Marquardt
The management in that place is absolutely ridiculous and the bartenders have no personality except for Nick. He’s cool but the young girl in the inside bar is absolutely should not be in the business. The food is going down big time. I can see why the other two places have closed.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
Lora Guglielmini
This is the second time I have been here in about 2 months. Not my choice. A/C was not working either time. The first time someone told me that it had not been working for over a month. That is ridiculous. I’m really not sure how they stay in business. This second time the ice tea maker was also broken and there were about 6 kitchen appliances in the back parking lot. Not sure what that was about. I gave it 2 stars because we were a group of 10, and they accommodated us well, probably because there was no one else inside. The server was good and attentive. Come on Stevie’s, you should treat your customers better and if not your customers, your staff.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 4
Donald Goebel
Good for, no real atmosphere, great band.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Burger
Kit K
When high expectations come crashing down.
We were in the mood for a Chicago Deep dish and after looking around, we found Stevie Tomato's and the description on the website described what sounds like an Uno's type pie. It was not.
It was an insult to pizza, not just Chicago. It was an oversized regular dough ball pushed in a cake pan with no butter, leaving air gaps that didn't touch the bottom of the pan so there were pockets of raw dough. No crispiness, no flakeyness, just disgusting. Service was spectacular.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 5
Alexis Hernandez
Food is actually pretty good. Portions are on the generous side. The fish and chips is glorious. The burger was bland as can be. The time I visited there was no A/C, don't know if it was a problem with it or it's like that but it was awful. My waitress also seemed to be the only one bothered to be there. Everyone else seemed friendly. I'd go back for the fish alone.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Mark Dirienzo
We've been coming here for 3 yrs and never had a bad experience.
Fun bar to party at for the older blue-collar crowd. If you want to drink and laugh this is the spot. Great service!
However the food is absolutely disgusting. I took one bite and nearly vomited. 🤮 I wouldn’t feed my dog the food they serve here.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 4
Stephanie Marino
I don’t usually post bad reviews, but this one deserves it. I’ve been here before and it’s never been great, but usually “okay”. but today it was terrible. Food was not good, aside from the cheese fries. Brought out the wrong dish, forgotten grilled chicken with chicken Cesar salad, forgotten corn cob with kids meal, forgotten cheese fries for one of the kids, wings had to be taken back twice because they weren’t crispy…they were slimy, almost like they threw them in a microwave instead of a fryer. Service was slow. Waited 15 minutes for checks (after one check had been brought out to one of the couples already) and I had to go to the bar tender to get our server to get our checks…. Had to continue to ask for refills of water. And the AC wasn’t working. Tables and chairs are in rough shape. All in all, horrible experience for a restaurant that’s been in Cape Coral for many years.. 10/10 do not recommend. Don’t waste your hard earned money here.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Dixon Johnson
Was in Cape Coral about a month ago helping a friend with storm prep. He said Stevie Tomatoes was worth checking out and he wasn't kidding. The pizza and wings were great; The service and atmosphere were everything I could hope for. Plus, I got to meet John Melendez. He shows up negatively in a lot of reviews here. I don't get why; he seemed very friendly and well-mannered during our visit. My friend bought him a beer which he graciously accept, and we spent the next half-hour (give or take) talking about life in general. It was really cool to see this thoughtful, philosophical side of him. He was a very humble, self-aware an, completely at odds with what I expected. It was a great experience, as was everything else in my visit to Stevie Tomatoes. Highly recommended. I'll be back...and I can't wait for it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chip Ankrom
I have had on different occasions, french onion soup, wings, ribs and fries. All were delicious! I had no problem with any of my meals. I got 2 cheese burgers for my wife and I, that were supposed to be medium and both were well done. That has been the bad meal that I have had there so far. I have gone back week after week and sat in the bar area. Waitress was very great! Not really busy at lunch time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
J Dev
Sevice is always great. Fried zucchini is just freakin spectacular. It's gotta be a whole zucchini...it's spears..like big spears. You add the salt. Pizza is a little inconsistent, but not something that is a make or break. Honestly, I've ordered so many different things I can't remember them all...but the chili is something I'd definitely get again, and zucchini is EVERY time.
As busy as they are, you always feel like your number one in this place. I love a good martini and that martinis here were made perfectly even with a packed bar. The atmosphere was so great. Put us in a whole better mood. Thank you so much we love this place, the pizza sauce is the best I’ve had in the long while. Love the pizza as well.
Parking: Great sports bar coming for the game on Sunday. Lots of space and the fountain in the front outside is so nice to watch and soothing.
Kid-friendliness: Perfect for all ages but mainly a nice adult sports bar.
Wheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair access I checked that out for a handicap member of my family who I’m bringing on Sunday. Thank you for that.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizzas
Ordered takeout and the wings were definitely the best I've had in cape coral so far in almost 2 years. Boneless and bone in both top notch
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
6 months still no AC
Broccoli, chicken rice served cold.
Needs updating. Seems like they are planning to close.
Neon Sign lighting has been out for months.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Ribs
This is excellent bar type food. I've had a Gyro and a Wrap another night and both were very good. Prices are on the lower end for restaurants. Monday nights they have free music bingo. Several large groups showed up for beer and bingo on the outdoor bar patio. Each bingo card has a different theme of music ... 80s, 90s and pop. (I had to Google the words on some songs to match the artist and title... or you can work in groups).
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken, Gyro
The management in that place is absolutely ridiculous and the bartenders have no personality except for Nick. He’s cool but the young girl in the inside bar is absolutely should not be in the business. The food is going down big time. I can see why the other two places have closed.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
This is the second time I have been here in about 2 months. Not my choice. A/C was not working either time. The first time someone told me that it had not been working for over a month. That is ridiculous. I’m really not sure how they stay in business. This second time the ice tea maker was also broken and there were about 6 kitchen appliances in the back parking lot. Not sure what that was about.
I gave it 2 stars because we were a group of 10, and they accommodated us well, probably because there was no one else inside.
The server was good and attentive.
Come on Stevie’s, you should treat your customers better and if not your customers, your staff.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 4
Good for, no real atmosphere, great band.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Burger
When high expectations come crashing down.
We were in the mood for a Chicago Deep dish and after looking around, we found Stevie Tomato's and the description on the website described what sounds like an Uno's type pie.
It was not.
It was an insult to pizza, not just Chicago. It was an oversized regular dough ball pushed in a cake pan with no butter, leaving air gaps that didn't touch the bottom of the pan so there were pockets of raw dough. No crispiness, no flakeyness, just disgusting. Service was spectacular.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 5
Food is actually pretty good. Portions are on the generous side. The fish and chips is glorious. The burger was bland as can be.
The time I visited there was no A/C, don't know if it was a problem with it or it's like that but it was awful. My waitress also seemed to be the only one bothered to be there. Everyone else seemed friendly.
I'd go back for the fish alone.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
We've been coming here for 3 yrs and never had a bad experience.
Congratulations to Dani and Nick 2 of the best
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Fun bar to party at for the older blue-collar crowd. If you want to drink and laugh this is the spot. Great service!
However the food is absolutely disgusting. I took one bite and nearly vomited. 🤮 I wouldn’t feed my dog the food they serve here.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 4
I don’t usually post bad reviews, but this one deserves it. I’ve been here before and it’s never been great, but usually “okay”. but today it was terrible. Food was not good, aside from the cheese fries. Brought out the wrong dish, forgotten grilled chicken with chicken Cesar salad, forgotten corn cob with kids meal, forgotten cheese fries for one of the kids, wings had to be taken back twice because they weren’t crispy…they were slimy, almost like they threw them in a microwave instead of a fryer. Service was slow. Waited 15 minutes for checks (after one check had been brought out to one of the couples already) and I had to go to the bar tender to get our server to get our checks…. Had to continue to ask for refills of water. And the AC wasn’t working. Tables and chairs are in rough shape. All in all, horrible experience for a restaurant that’s been in Cape Coral for many years.. 10/10 do not recommend. Don’t waste your hard earned money here.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Was in Cape Coral about a month ago helping a friend with storm prep. He said Stevie Tomatoes was worth checking out and he wasn't kidding. The pizza and wings were great; The service and atmosphere were everything I could hope for. Plus, I got to meet John Melendez. He shows up negatively in a lot of reviews here. I don't get why; he seemed very friendly and well-mannered during our visit. My friend bought him a beer which he graciously accept, and we spent the next half-hour (give or take) talking about life in general. It was really cool to see this thoughtful, philosophical side of him. He was a very humble, self-aware an, completely at odds with what I expected. It was a great experience, as was everything else in my visit to Stevie Tomatoes. Highly recommended. I'll be back...and I can't wait for it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I have had on different occasions, french onion soup, wings, ribs and fries. All were delicious! I had no problem with any of my meals. I got 2 cheese burgers for my wife and I, that were supposed to be medium and both were well done. That has been the bad meal that I have had there so far. I have gone back week after week and sat in the bar area. Waitress was very great! Not really busy at lunch time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sevice is always great. Fried zucchini is just freakin spectacular. It's gotta be a whole zucchini...it's spears..like big spears. You add the salt. Pizza is a little inconsistent, but not something that is a make or break. Honestly, I've ordered so many different things I can't remember them all...but the chili is something I'd definitely get again, and zucchini is EVERY time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Loading...