STUFF-A-BAGEL DELI-BAKERY

Obsessed with their chicken salad! Customer service is always top tier!

Stopped by Stuff-A-Bagel Deli & Bakery for breakfast. The bagels were fresh and delicious — just be sure to mention if you want them toasted, otherwise they’re served as is.

They give a huge portion of cream cheese — some will love it, but I’ll probably ask for half next time.

Overall, a great local spot for freshly made bagels and a satisfying breakfast.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great breakfast...egg n cheese is amazing.

So great

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Come here often, and left with nothing and disappointed today. Asked for coffee and the girl at the counter says she’s about to throw it out. I ask for a cup to see and i come back with just over half a cup and tell her it’s gone.

While i’m looking to order food she charges me for the coffee.

I said “Are you really charging me for the coffee?” She said Yes.

Guess you needed that $2.35

I loved stuff a bagel until today

Service: 1

Just stopped into Stuff-a-Bagel for the first time in a while. Came back into town to visit after moving away. Sad to say the whole place had changed. None of the original decor and atmosphere existed anymore. All of the photos of families and New York City sports on the wall were taken down for a bleak “modern” feel. I was informed there was new ownership at the Milton Street location which was obvious. Our hearts sank after walking in and not feeling like we were in the same place we loved for years. We miss the old Stuff-a-Bagel and that classic NY deli feel. Food was not the same and our bagels were not toasted as requested.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 3

I revisited stuff a bagel this morning after long boycott. I was always a big fan but a laundry list of issues keep me away. Much to my surprise they once again raised the price of a bagel $1.75 in my opinion as Highway robbery for a bagel. Especially one that is not what it once was. They are often undercooked and underseasoned, and yes overpriced.
Most of these locations are hard to get in and out of making it difficult. They have cash registers that make you feel guilty about not leaving a tip for regular cash register Service they charge you extra for a credit card even with the exorbitant prices of the bagel.
As they grew somewhere along the line quality control went out the window. It saddens me because I used to love this place now I think I’m going on another boycott for a while again. It drives me nuts because I know they are capable of doing it so much better. I feel robbed of my favorite breakfast shop.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Dozen Bagels

Best breakfast sandwiches around, without a question.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Always love a NY style bagel shop an the owners an workers are awesome..Love the food..

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Taylor Ham, Jersey Turnpike, Chicken Salad, Egg \u0026 Cheese

I really liked this place. We were in Cape Coral for vacation and found this place next to the Chinese spot we ordered dinner from. We decided to eat here the next day. I got an everything bagel toasted with bacon egg and cheese and my wife a cross isn’t with scallion cream cheese. Everything was fresh and delicious! We saw that there was an olive cream cheese and asked if we could try it. The lady was super kind and brought some out on a fork. Delicious! The place was packed and they had some cool bagels as well like French toast and rainbow. Will go back for sure!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I stopped here every day during my visit in Cape Coral and this bagel shop by far is the best experience I’ve had over any bagel restaurant. The prices are fair, the bagels are outstanding with multiple options and the pumpkin cream cheese was beyond amazing! Lots of options for lunch and crafted coffee.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Saw the sign and craved that New York taste! I got it! Lovely!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Best bagels in Cape!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Stuff a bagel 🥯 speaks for its self. Both my young boys love to come in and see everyone and everything. Best food everytime. Best people working and the atmosphere is o so well

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Hidden Gem. Some of the best tasting bagels I’ve had since being in Central Florida. Place reminded me of being back in NYC. Highly recommend checking them out

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5