Fathoms Restaurant

201 St James Ave, Carrabelle
(850) 697-9712

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Alexander Jones

Cold beer, fresh seafood, and a view! I’d show you my oysters and blackened grouper sandwich but they were too good to stop and take a picture. Two thumbs up.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Richard Provini

Hidden gem right in town. Ate here multiple times while we were staying at golf resort. Food was great, servers and patrons welcomed us and love the outside vibe. Even got to see and meet locals at open mic night on Thursday which was awesome.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

ablevyfl

Hidden gem right in town. Ate here multiple times while we were staying at golf resort. Food was great, servers and patrons welcomed us and love the outside vibe. Even got to see and meet locals at open mic night on Thursday which was awesome.

Trip57749883355

I was charged $16 for the $14 grouper tacos. When I questioned the bill, they pointed at the "Prices are subject to to change" note at the bottom of the menu. I was also charged $3 to pay with a credit card. When I said I would pay cash instead, they said too late. After I left, they added an additional $20 tip to my $38 bill!!!!!

CareyM1221

I ordered the crab. It was so good. The crab was seasoned perfectly. The Mac n cheese was really good too. My husband really did not like the idea that they had no french fries. But we tried the boiled potatoes.

carladV7176UB

Amazing Ahi tuna appetizer! Quite gourmet! The oysters and local beer were fabulous, too. (Everything else looked great, but that's all we had). Will return as often as possible.

Debrah Miller

We ALWAYS plan to eat here every time we stay in Carabelle. Great food, great service and always fun music. Lots of character and characters!!😄

Charles Teggart

Great place to eat local caught food! Even on a busy holiday weekend, we were able to get in and order our food with no issues. Everything came out hot and kept our drinks full!

Cheryl Devine

Be very careful buying the oysters. I ordered a dozen raw. Received 11 small, no tiny oysters. They were warm, with a handful of ice dropped in the middle of the tray. 35 years eating oysters, these were by far the absolute worst. Never again!!

Michelle Gregory

Great place, great staff great food. Live music, open air and cold drinks.

ryan elwer

Good food an service

Chevelle Dunlap

Service was slow and the food was not worth the money

Jarred Taylor

The food was good, staff was good prices seemed reasonable.

Darlene Johnson (Hickory Hills Haven)

Always love visiting this gem! Order the smoked Mullet ... You won't regret it! 😉

flintriverlife31716

My husband and I took our boys, 20 and 10 years old, here to eat, listen to the band, have a drink, and most of all, at a place where our energetic 10 year old could be loud and not bother anyone while they enjoy their dinners too! We sat outside with the band, and yes it was hot outside,yet with the fans and air being circulated just right, it was actually pleasant. The staff was quick and friendly. The rooms got their orders to us in a timely fashion. The food was perfect to each of us and we ordered a variety of foods. Raw oysters, seafood plate for my husband, a house salad for myself, a margarita that was to die for and he drank a few cold beers, we also ordered off of the kids menu which filled his belly with no complaints either. The prices were reasonable also. We thoroughly enjoyed our evening.

Loading...