Walked into this place for the first time ever. About to drop $25 ($27-28 with tax) on a 16" "Mediterranean" pie... Me: "Could I substitute the broccoli with Pepperoni?" Guy behind counter: "No we can't do that, because it's too expensive." Me: "Have a nice evening." (I walked out) Is common sense fading away from society, or something? I won't be back there again. Boardwalk Pizza (down the road) is a bit more expensive and super delicious. I think I'm going to head there this weekend. They don't provide ignorant excuses like Anthony's did to me.
Michele O.
We decided to stop by and try their pizza as it has been a while since we have been to Anthony's. The Pizza was over cooked, dry and barely any sauce and cheese. Pizza Hut would have made a better choice. Will not be back.
Ish
I’m pretty sure I’m not the first one to confuse this place with the other Anthony’s “coal fired” Pizza. Pizza was ok, 7 out of 10!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Elizabeth Guillet
I make sure to go there when I visit a friend in the area. Never fails me. Their sign that states "Best Pizza Since I Left New York" is ?
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
I Garcia
OMG! CASSELBERRY ANTHONYS PIZZA NEW CHEF,NEW STAFF,AMAZING FLAVOR.NEW RUSSIAN CHEF ALEX ,BEST EVER.BACK TO BEST ALL ANTHONYS PIZZA.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jerica M.
The food is okay, the pizza was really greasy & in general the food was so expensive i think we got 1 Large pizza and a Large salad it was like $80 the service was good & fast i never went back though Angelina's pizza is more natural food / Organic so i would rather go there. The ambiance is okay just got it togo nothing special
Billy B
Great NY style pizza
Anthony D.
Terrible pizza. Sauce on pizza is bad. Bad tasting. Garlic rolls are awful. Dry, dinner rolls with garlic just put on top. Save your money and go elsewhere.
Eric G.
This place is the real deal and as close to NY pizza outside of the City. They've been around for years and their quality is always on par. I wish the prices weren't so high (especially thanks to the endless inflation that has hit everyone) but you're still not exactly overpaying. They make quality NY pizza and other Italian dishes very well and been going here for years now.
Jennifer Adams
I work across the street from the Anthony's in Casselberry FL. I order a slice of Bianca with spinach and a side of marinara sauce. They said 5-10 mins. I believe i was there in like 8 mins. the pizza was cold and crust harder than a rock. Spinach was nasty and slimy and the sauce is watery. for almost $8 dollars, was a waste of money. Never had a problem besides the garlic knots which i didn't leave a review because i got back to work ate 2 and had customers. Wont eat there again.Parking: no
I've tried this place several times. I frequent the Publix next door so it's convenient. I've had mediocre food in the past, but a calzone being burnt to a crisp makes me want to never try again. For the prices they charge, I would hope for more. Maybe I'll try again in a year. Charging $5 for a slice with a couple toppings has me questioning my future self already.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Destination Unknown
Never returning because of the female workers that no business being there. They obviously don't want to be there and it shows. Pizza is good but not good enough to deal with nonsense.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Shelly Bassgirl
The staff is amazing.. the guys behind the counter.. especially my pizza maker. And the guy counter but i think hes a manager... super attentive and know what i order and make it on spot 100% although it changes time to time.They know me and have consideration. Really it is the best pizza place all around. I've been coming here over 11 years.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Edwin Reyes
Ordered a chicken cabanera, the taste was very dry mo flavor, I've tasted better. There pizza is very good. The waiters are friendly, n ut won't be going back due to their prices very expensive for there dining.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Patti P.
Wow the spaghetti was amazing!! Big portions abd the garlic knots are simply delicious! I can't wait to go back!!! The pizza is good too !
Walked into this place for the first time ever. About to drop $25 ($27-28 with tax) on a 16" "Mediterranean" pie... Me: "Could I substitute the broccoli with Pepperoni?" Guy behind counter: "No we can't do that, because it's too expensive." Me: "Have a nice evening." (I walked out) Is common sense fading away from society, or something? I won't be back there again. Boardwalk Pizza (down the road) is a bit more expensive and super delicious. I think I'm going to head there this weekend. They don't provide ignorant excuses like Anthony's did to me.
We decided to stop by and try their pizza as it has been a while since we have been to Anthony's. The Pizza was over cooked, dry and barely any sauce and cheese. Pizza Hut would have made a better choice. Will not be back.
I’m pretty sure I’m not the first one to confuse this place with the other Anthony’s “coal fired” Pizza. Pizza was ok, 7 out of 10!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
I make sure to go there when I visit a friend in the area. Never fails me. Their sign that states "Best Pizza Since I Left New York" is ?
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
OMG! CASSELBERRY ANTHONYS PIZZA NEW CHEF,NEW STAFF,AMAZING FLAVOR.NEW RUSSIAN CHEF ALEX ,BEST EVER.BACK TO BEST ALL ANTHONYS PIZZA.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food is okay, the pizza was really greasy & in general the food was so expensive i think we got 1 Large pizza and a Large salad it was like $80 the service was good & fast i never went back though Angelina's pizza is more natural food / Organic so i would rather go there. The ambiance is okay just got it togo nothing special
Great NY style pizza
Terrible pizza. Sauce on pizza is bad. Bad tasting. Garlic rolls are awful. Dry, dinner rolls with garlic just put on top. Save your money and go elsewhere.
This place is the real deal and as close to NY pizza outside of the City. They've been around for years and their quality is always on par. I wish the prices weren't so high (especially thanks to the endless inflation that has hit everyone) but you're still not exactly overpaying. They make quality NY pizza and other Italian dishes very well and been going here for years now.
I work across the street from the Anthony's in Casselberry FL. I order a slice of Bianca with spinach and a side of marinara sauce. They said 5-10 mins. I believe i was there in like 8 mins. the pizza was cold and crust harder than a rock. Spinach was nasty and slimy and the sauce is watery. for almost $8 dollars, was a waste of money. Never had a problem besides the garlic knots which i didn't leave a review because i got back to work ate 2 and had customers. Wont eat there again.Parking: no
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings
Restaurantji Recommends
I've tried this place several times. I frequent the Publix next door so it's convenient. I've had mediocre food in the past, but a calzone being burnt to a crisp makes me want to never try again. For the prices they charge, I would hope for more. Maybe I'll try again in a year. Charging $5 for a slice with a couple toppings has me questioning my future self already.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Never returning because of the female workers that no business being there. They obviously don't want to be there and it shows. Pizza is good but not good enough to deal with nonsense.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
The staff is amazing.. the guys behind the counter.. especially my pizza maker. And the guy counter but i think hes a manager... super attentive and know what i order and make it on spot 100% although it changes time to time.They know me and have consideration. Really it is the best pizza place all around. I've been coming here over 11 years.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered a chicken cabanera, the taste was very dry mo flavor, I've tasted better. There pizza is very good. The waiters are friendly, n ut won't be going back due to their prices very expensive for there dining.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Wow the spaghetti was amazing!! Big portions abd the garlic knots are simply delicious! I can't wait to go back!!! The pizza is good too !