I've been struggling to find a pizza place I like that has delivery. Last night, I orderer the Kingpin on Uber Eats and am thrilled to say I have my new favorite pizza place.
Thomas Descalzo
If they close at 8 pm on Sundays, it would be good if they put it online so I can save myself a 15-minute drive just to be told they're closed.
J K
Excellent pizza and service. Hats off to
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Christine O'Mealy
Great place to go with kids.
The server was extremely hospitable, and the kids had fun. Food was yummy and quick enough seeing as how they had just opened when we got there.
Will definitely return in future.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
james Wray
Love this Pizza..Garlic cheese bread...Garlic knots...It's a great find....The prices are not bad..The pizza is worth every penny...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Terrye Veal
The order took forever, but I was okay with waiting an additional 20+ minutes. It seemed that they were not staffed properly. Others in front of me order was behind and or they did not have the product to put on their pizza. I was still optimistic about my order. I ordered a white pizza with extra cheese and pepperonis. The pizza looked beautiful. There was no extra cheese on it, but still excited to taste it. Well, when we tasted the pizza, it tasted like nothing. It had no flavor. Big globs of ricotta with zero flavor. No garlic, no sauce, just globs of unseasoned ricotta and cheese falling off. I had to put some flavor on it and more cheese that I paid for and did not get on the pizza and some garlic butter on the crust. Basically had to doctor up on the pizza in order to get it down my throat. I most certainly will not be back. It could have just been a bad night for them. But I'm good.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Natasha Gonzalez
I have been coming here for years, when it was the original owners for Infinity Pizza. The new owners, Joe and his family took over. Most new owners of an establishment change a lot of things. They kept a lot of the original. They have their own style of making pizza with their Joes' American. I love new york style BUT I am a fan of the crunch in that style. I love crispy crust! We will continue to come here, even though it takes us 35-40 mins. Definitely worth the drive.
Joe's daughter (i forgot her name) is super nice and treats customers like friends/family.
I will always support family owned business!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mandy
Great pizza place for family fun! Service was friendly and pizza was delicious! Ordered the Kingpin pizza with gluten free crust and it was delicious! Very cheesy with a garlic oil base. My partner ordered the Sorcerer Supreme and was able to substitute the mushrooms and olives with tomatoes and pineapple. Marvel comic movies playing on tvs along with some sports and video game playthroughs. Several games available to play for old arcade vibe. Great family and nerdy atmosphere!
Dietary restrictions: Gluten free crust option for celiacs.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sorcerer Supreme, White Pizza With
steve geo
Great New York style pizza, good ingredients, good service, it felt like a comic book store scene but the kids loved it. And it was priced right. Plus they also have a good deep dish not as deep as Chicago style but worth it.
I'm from NY, and consider myself a pizza conessiuer, I refuse to eat frozen or any of the chains... After seeing reviews I decided to give them a try, first disappointment was the dough/crust was overcooked, not supposed to be hard, brittle, and burnt. Second disappointment was the amount of toppings, especially seeing what they charged me for it! After eating 2 slices, I was done. If your pizza quality is like this consistently, I don't see you getting mny repeat customers..... You guys can do better! I hope you do.
Nora Jean
We were unaware of the new ownership and change of atmosphere otherwise we probably wouldn’t have went. We loved Infinitely pizza for its unique experience and being a nerd this place felt like a dream. Me and my fiancé went with hopes to dine in but after being there for 10 minutes we decided to take our food to go as it felt more like a sports bar than a nerdy pizza joint with all the people screaming at the tv. The food still taste the same but they removed a lot from the menu. I feel after the change of ownership they might as well just change the name and theme because nothing about this place felt the same.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 4
Michelle
When I heard that Joe's was buying Infinity Pizza they promised nothing would change. At this point, other than the names of the pizza on the menu, what's the same? Too many spices in the marinara, totally different tomato sauce in both taste and texture, different cheese, the branding is off the pizza boxes and I just read the games are gone now too. Just call it Joe's Pizza. The transition is complete. There's nothing left of the pizza place we loved. Infinity made a much better pie. Sad day.
Food: 3
Nicole Franke
Website said $14 for a 14in but you get there and they say $18 due to new ownership. One and done. Also the establishment smells like a port-a-potty, change your mop.
Alexandra Staats
First timers… what caught our attention were the apps all over their google page, especially the Jalapeño Poppers… But unfortunately they do not make those anymore. Hopefully they come back as a special. Also the games are gone too from the pictures online… not sure what happened there.
However the pizza we ordered was friggin perfect. We ordered a giant pie, and 2 beers… $45 Actually seems reasonable compared to other places.
I've been struggling to find a pizza place I like that has delivery. Last night, I orderer the Kingpin on Uber Eats and am thrilled to say I have my new favorite pizza place.
If they close at 8 pm on Sundays, it would be good if they put it online so I can save myself a 15-minute drive just to be told they're closed.
Excellent pizza and service. Hats off to
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great place to go with kids.
The server was extremely hospitable, and the kids had fun. Food was yummy and quick enough seeing as how they had just opened when we got there.
Will definitely return in future.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love this Pizza..Garlic cheese bread...Garlic knots...It's a great find....The prices are not bad..The pizza is worth every penny...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The order took forever, but I was okay with waiting an additional 20+ minutes. It seemed that they were not staffed properly. Others in front of me order was behind and or they did not have the product to put on their pizza. I was still optimistic about my order. I ordered a white pizza with extra cheese and pepperonis. The pizza looked beautiful. There was no extra cheese on it, but still excited to taste it. Well, when we tasted the pizza, it tasted like nothing. It had no flavor. Big globs of ricotta with zero flavor. No garlic, no sauce, just globs of unseasoned ricotta and cheese falling off. I had to put some flavor on it and more cheese that I paid for and did not get on the pizza and some garlic butter on the crust. Basically had to doctor up on the pizza in order to get it down my throat. I most certainly will not be back. It could have just been a bad night for them. But I'm good.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
I have been coming here for years, when it was the original owners for Infinity Pizza. The new owners, Joe and his family took over. Most new owners of an establishment change a lot of things. They kept a lot of the original. They have their own style of making pizza with their Joes' American. I love new york style BUT I am a fan of the crunch in that style. I love crispy crust! We will continue to come here, even though it takes us 35-40 mins. Definitely worth the drive.
Joe's daughter (i forgot her name) is super nice and treats customers like friends/family.
I will always support family owned business!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza place for family fun! Service was friendly and pizza was delicious! Ordered the Kingpin pizza with gluten free crust and it was delicious! Very cheesy with a garlic oil base. My partner ordered the Sorcerer Supreme and was able to substitute the mushrooms and olives with tomatoes and pineapple. Marvel comic movies playing on tvs along with some sports and video game playthroughs. Several games available to play for old arcade vibe. Great family and nerdy atmosphere!
Dietary restrictions: Gluten free crust option for celiacs.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sorcerer Supreme, White Pizza With
Great New York style pizza, good ingredients, good service, it felt like a comic book store scene but the kids loved it. And it was priced right. Plus they also have a good deep dish not as deep as Chicago style but worth it.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Good Pizza ,
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Restaurantji Recommends
I'm from NY, and consider myself a pizza conessiuer, I refuse to eat frozen or any of the chains... After seeing reviews I decided to give them a try, first disappointment was the dough/crust was overcooked, not supposed to be hard, brittle, and burnt. Second disappointment was the amount of toppings, especially seeing what they charged me for it! After eating 2 slices, I was done. If your pizza quality is like this consistently, I don't see you getting mny repeat customers..... You guys can do better! I hope you do.
We were unaware of the new ownership and change of atmosphere otherwise we probably wouldn’t have went. We loved Infinitely pizza for its unique experience and being a nerd this place felt like a dream. Me and my fiancé went with hopes to dine in but after being there for 10 minutes we decided to take our food to go as it felt more like a sports bar than a nerdy pizza joint with all the people screaming at the tv. The food still taste the same but they removed a lot from the menu. I feel after the change of ownership they might as well just change the name and theme because nothing about this place felt the same.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 4
When I heard that Joe's was buying Infinity Pizza they promised nothing would change. At this point, other than the names of the pizza on the menu, what's the same? Too many spices in the marinara, totally different tomato sauce in both taste and texture, different cheese, the branding is off the pizza boxes and I just read the games are gone now too. Just call it Joe's Pizza. The transition is complete. There's nothing left of the pizza place we loved. Infinity made a much better pie. Sad day.
Food: 3
Website said $14 for a 14in but you get there and they say $18 due to new ownership.
One and done.
Also the establishment smells like a port-a-potty, change your mop.
First timers… what caught our attention were the apps all over their google page, especially the Jalapeño Poppers…
But unfortunately they do not make those anymore. Hopefully they come back as a special. Also the games are gone too from the pictures online… not sure what happened there.
However the pizza we ordered was friggin perfect.
We ordered a giant pie, and 2 beers… $45
Actually seems reasonable compared to other places.
Loading...