Star Fish Company
12306 46th Ave W, Cortez
(941) 794-1243
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
Been going for years. This year I walked out of the line twice. Food was not as good. I understand the Storms were brutal. Understaffed. And I was very loyal, Only ate seafood there no where else. With everything expense you have to have customer service.
We had the pompano fish, Atlantic salmon and seafood salad sandwich. ALL delicious! The woman who took our order was warm and friendly and was glad to answer any questions we had as this was our first visit. We are not from this area but plan to visit yearly and Star Fish will definitely be on our list of places to eat!
Fresh fish, really cold beer, seating right on the water. Someone mistakenly drove off in our car while at the restaurant and their manager Kris was gracious and gave us a free round while the police and rental car company got the car returned. CASH only restaurant and celebrates life at a slower pace. Good reminder that we all just need to take a deep breath and slow down.
Amazing food!!! So worth the wait (wasn’t that bad) scallops to die for and stone crab special was delicious.
We decided to go here last minute last night. We are here on vacay and this has to be one of the best meals we’ve had here so far! We had the blackened Mahi Mahi with cheese grits and the fried clam strips with sweet potato fries. The Mahi Mahi was the best we’ve ever had anywhere. Clam strips were cooked to perfection not dry at all. The hush puppies were delicious as well. Everything comes served in a to go box but don’t let that fool ya this place has really fresh, really good food! The service was excellent as well. We will be back! Thanks!
I sadly hate posting this review and 2 stars, because for years we have been wanting to try Star Fish Company and it was the biggest disappointment. We parked our boat, waited in line and then waited for an hour for food. The signs do say food takes a long time, so we were patient… however at an hour for waiting for a fish sandwich and fried shrimp, we said something. The server told us just a few more minutes. After 10 minutes, I said we were still waiting. After all the wait, we were then told there was a “problem in the kitchen” and it would be another 20-30 minutes for our food! Aka they lost the ticket or never made our order. We missed out on 1.5 hours of our rented boat time because of this. This is also not busy season and plenty of open tables. We sadly never got to try the food even though we heard it was wonderful. The atmosphere is neat and definitely check out their market to take fresh fish home. Just before you go check the wait and make sure you don’t have somewhere to be. ?
Freshest fish sandwich you will ever have. Exclusive and known by the locals. Hidden gem. Would recommend. Very kind and attentive service. Had Grouper sandwiches. Worth the wait
Best and freshest seafood and fried fish I have ever tasted at a restaurant. Simply the best seafood in Tampa bay.
Great place to grab a fresh catch. Cool bar area that you can order up the days catches.
Still the best seafood EVER
PLEASE SUPPORT THIS AMAZING PLACE FOREVER
Restaurantji Recommends
Best grouper sandwich in town!
Star Fish serves great fresh seafood in a beautiful old Florida setting. All our meals were spot-on but the downside is it took about 20 minutes waiting in line to order and then another 30 minutes to get our food delivered to our table. And what's even worse is we waited in line, ordered (4 of us) and got 4 beers while placing the order. The beers are small and we wanted at least two more while waiting for our food but had to go back into a long line! A ridiculous way to operate a restaurant! Will not be returning.
Food was great. Bring CASH!
Came all the way from Houston TX. Fried oysters were real greasy and I can't believe they charge 50 cents for tarter sauce in a seafood place. No more visits for me
The food was excellent!! Fresh seafood. Will highly recommend!!
Loading...