The staff, the food, the atmosphere are all outstanding. Evan and Ian are undeniably the best bartenders EVER! We spend way too much money there but it’s worth every penny! Highly recommend the donuts if you have a sweet tooth!
Voyage35430598826
We wanted to have a cocktail while listening to live music. Mar Jo Lee was beyond gifted in vocals. Pleasure to have her sing a Nina Simone song I requested. The waitstaff was ridiculously amazing and spot on.
F9850ITtracyw
Anna ( our server) was awesome. Food & drinks are great.Filet Minon sliders are SO good!!!! Best cocktails in the Keys! LOVE the Toasted Coconut Mojito!!! Our favorite joint!!!
lindafV8856YQ
Anna Is the best!!! Thank you thank you ! She took care of everything we needed! My favorite place ! Music was great Food is awesome!!!!!!!
Guide38187765944
Best place to get a few cocktails & munchies.. only thing that made it better, was our server Anna.. food was superb, service from Anna was ⭐️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️!
larrymV4585WY
Great place, good food & drinks and the wait staff was beyond perfect. Good was time had by all. We really enjoyed the Blue Point Oysters.
abigailh741
Square grouper has been one of my favorite places in the keys for years because it has the best cocktails (bubonic tonic margarita), food (all of it) and service (anna!!) absolutely recommend 🙌🏼
C8367ZHtonyas
Excellent food and service! Wonderful server, did a great job! Thank you Anna! The entire staff works together and was attentive.
Departure05486110824
Amazing service.. Food is amazing, Anna our server was a Rockstar! We are here during stone crab season. Happy hour $5... the entire staff works as a team and very attentive
Letty C
Ordered stone crab happy hour-guess what they ran out right before happy hour ended. Ordered soft shell slider- guess what again! Ran out. This is 6:30pm on a Saturday night. Ordered the fish of the day (wahoo) a favorite. Mine was overcooked, my son’s fish of the day was so over cooked he sent it back. What can I say. I live close by, this is a place I love to hang out and recommend. Not any more. Sorry Square Grouper, too many failures to count as a mistake. When your restaurant’s name is a fish, you should be able to know how to cook it and have enough stone crab during season to fill you orders. Dissatisfied and disappointed.
Consistently great! Can’t wait until they reopen in October! ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
67cassic
Stopped in to My New Joint last week on a whim while traveling up the Keys. The decor is eclectic and sets the mood for a nice date night. We love oysters and our waitress Anna B. was able to thoroughly guide us through the Raw bar menu. The Shigokus were briny and buttery, just as we were hoping for. Portebello fries are a must and don’t skip over the “Drink of the Week”. The Cosmic Nimbus was so refreshing, and I’m not even a Gin kind of gal! Thank you Anna for the great service and great recommendations !
Kathryn Katz
Last Wednesday, my friend and I got a table at My New Joint instead of our usual spot at the bar. We were lucky to have Anna as our server, who made our evening fantastic. Even with a busy section, she balanced attentiveness and space perfectly. Thanks to her, we had a great time and will definitely be back to sit in her section again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jennifer Hallett
A hidden gem! If I could give them 10 stars I would. Try Voodoo ? Shrimp! Coconut mojito shown in pic. Atmosphere makes this well designed and thought out space. Chris the bartender was awesome. Entertainment was fabulous.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fried Banana Split
Matthew Harris
Great spot if you are in Cudjoe, we met friends for cocktails and they were good pours! Large selection of craft beer, bourbon and tequila. My Old Fashioned was on point. Definitely one of the nicest and cleanest bars in all of the keys. Cold air and not your typical keys style place. If you are looking for a nice place to take your lady or your man out after a long day of fishing this is it!
The staff, the food, the atmosphere are all outstanding. Evan and Ian are undeniably the best bartenders EVER! We spend way too much money there but it’s worth every penny! Highly recommend the donuts if you have a sweet tooth!
We wanted to have a cocktail while listening to live music. Mar Jo Lee was beyond gifted in vocals. Pleasure to have her sing a Nina Simone song I requested. The waitstaff was ridiculously amazing and spot on.
Anna ( our server) was awesome. Food & drinks are great.Filet Minon sliders are SO good!!!! Best cocktails in the Keys! LOVE the Toasted Coconut Mojito!!! Our favorite joint!!!
Anna Is the best!!! Thank you thank you ! She took care of everything we needed! My favorite place ! Music was great Food is awesome!!!!!!!
Best place to get a few cocktails & munchies.. only thing that made it better, was our server Anna.. food was superb, service from Anna was ⭐️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️!
Great place, good food & drinks and the wait staff was beyond perfect. Good was time had by all. We really enjoyed the Blue Point Oysters.
Square grouper has been one of my favorite places in the keys for years because it has the best cocktails (bubonic tonic margarita), food (all of it) and service (anna!!) absolutely recommend 🙌🏼
Excellent food and service! Wonderful server, did a great job! Thank you Anna! The entire staff works together and was attentive.
Amazing service.. Food is amazing, Anna our server was a Rockstar! We are here during stone crab season. Happy hour $5... the entire staff works as a team and very attentive
Ordered stone crab happy hour-guess what they ran out right before happy hour ended. Ordered soft shell slider- guess what again! Ran out. This is 6:30pm on a Saturday night. Ordered the fish of the day (wahoo) a favorite. Mine was overcooked, my son’s fish of the day was so over cooked he sent it back. What can I say. I live close by, this is a place I love to hang out and recommend. Not any more. Sorry Square Grouper, too many failures to count as a mistake. When your restaurant’s name is a fish, you should be able to know how to cook it and have enough stone crab during season to fill you orders. Dissatisfied and disappointed.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Consistently great! Can’t wait until they reopen in October! ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stopped in to My New Joint last week on a whim while traveling up the Keys. The decor is eclectic and sets the mood for a nice date night. We love oysters and our waitress Anna B. was able to thoroughly guide us through the Raw bar menu. The Shigokus were briny and buttery, just as we were hoping for. Portebello fries are a must and don’t skip over the “Drink of the Week”. The Cosmic Nimbus was so refreshing, and I’m not even a Gin kind of gal! Thank you Anna for the great service and great recommendations !
Last Wednesday, my friend and I got a table at My New Joint instead of our usual spot at the bar. We were lucky to have Anna as our server, who made our evening fantastic. Even with a busy section, she balanced attentiveness and space perfectly. Thanks to her, we had a great time and will definitely be back to sit in her section again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A hidden gem! If I could give them 10 stars I would. Try Voodoo ? Shrimp! Coconut mojito shown in pic. Atmosphere makes this well designed and thought out space. Chris the bartender was awesome. Entertainment was fabulous.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fried Banana Split
Great spot if you are in Cudjoe, we met friends for cocktails and they were good pours! Large selection of craft beer, bourbon and tequila. My Old Fashioned was on point. Definitely one of the nicest and cleanest bars in all of the keys. Cold air and not your typical keys style place. If you are looking for a nice place to take your lady or your man out after a long day of fishing this is it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...