Sally's Ice Cream

Shuts down all dairy-eating arguments because this is how ice cream was meant to be 🍦🤤 Had the Cookies and Cream and Toasted Coconut but going back to try them all! Updated from previous review on 2025-10-26

Delicious! I loved the coconut milk ice cream as I cannot have regular milk, the texture and flavor of the ice cream was superb!

Usually we love Sally’s but we went there & my wife usually orders banana split but they had no bananas!

Wish I was allowed to sample 1 type of ice cream without having the brunette at the window roll her eyes and laugh at me… crazy how they’re doing this with another ice cream shop right next door

“Lady” rolled her eyes and shook her head when someone in my party asked a question about one of the flavors. Left immediately.

Ice cream is delicious but unfortunately went to go buy a quart of my favorite flavor which came to a total of almost $18 with a tip.. and only got about a half full container. So I was very upset to open it and find out there probably could have been about 3-4 more scoops put in there. Not worth the money to buy the whole quart… basically a Ben and Jerry’s size pint for triple the price. my pregnancy cravings were not satisfied.

staff was lovely, ice cream was incredible (i got chocolate raspberry), and prices were very reasonable. i’ll definitely be here again :)

Good ice cream if they can your order right. Maybe update your menu once in a while.

We have been coming to Flagler for 11 years, and always visit Sally’s because they have vegan ice cream and it’s delicious. I chose to write this review because of Cleona, an employee who has been there at each of our visits on this trip. I have observed her positive energy scooping ice cream & serving customers, even when there wasn’t change in the drawer, some of the ice cream was too frozen to serve, and also when they had to close early. Cleona is a gem, and Cleona—if you are reading this, I hope you always remember to stay in your energy. 🖤

Horrible picture but best ice cream! I mixed the cookies and cream with the pb cookie. If you go you must at least sample the pb cookie it changed my whole world !

The ice cream is amazing and the vegan options are clearly marked on a blackboard. At the time of writing, there are four vegan options: Peanut butter cookie, cookies n cream, and toasted coconut, and strawberry. It's also worth mentioning that it's right next door to Faro Beachside Eatery. Updated from previous review on 2025-08-09

Delicious 😋

Delicious ice cream! Great variety.

Friendly staff and delicious ice cream at a very reasonable price!

Fun walk up ice cream on the beach. Never miss it when my family is visiting Flagler beach