New York Pizza Fleming Island
1811 Golden Eagle Way #25, Fleming Island
(904) 579-3488
Customers' Favorites
Cheese Pizza Slice
Specialty Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Calzone Pizza
Garlic Knots
Pizza Roll
Meat Pizza
Calzone
Menu
Photos
+49 photos
+48 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
I have been here several times and the pizza is amazing. Closest to NY pizza. Adriana, is so refreshing to see for a young woman. She is passionate about her family’s business and cares about the customers. Our pizza was a little well done when they took it out so she gave us that one and another one to make up for it. Now this girl gets customer service. We didn’t even ask. Definitely will be back and recommend for others to try
I'LL Definitely be back.... it was delicious, reminds me of my younger days in Philly and NY. The grandma's pizza ..???? Muah delicious and the normal cheese slice is a true NY SLICE... You guys hit out the park, Best around here hands down.
Great Pizza. Super flavorful. I loved it because it wasnt super greasy!!! Would have been 5 years but they charge over 3 dollars per topping. A bit steep to sprinkle a few black olives on a pie. The buffalo fries were the best fries I have ever had.
You May Also Like
Brew-Bakers Cafe & Co. - 1811 Golden Eagle Way #23
![]()
Cafe, Bakery, Coffee & Tea
Planet Smoothie - 2245 Plantation Center Dr
![]()
Juice, Juice Bar & Smoothies